The third daughter: Man tries to kill wife after ultrasound result

Pregnant woman, who was beaten and maybe poisoned by her husband, gave birth in a car enroute to the hospital.


Owais Jaffery January 19, 2011

KHANEWAL: A man tried to kill his wife after ultrasound reports revealed that she was about to give birth to a baby girl, the couple’s third daughter.

The pregnant woman, who was beaten and maybe poisoned by her husband, gave birth in a car enroute to the hospital. Kacha Kho resident, Aliya, was beaten by her husband after the couple returned from the doctor’s offices on Tuesday afternoon. Aliya’s husband, Muhammad Ali, was enraged after he discovered that he was about to have a third daughter.

Muhammad Ali and his father, Allah Ditta, shackled Aliya with manacles to a door after they returned from the doctor’s appointment. Ali tried to abort the child and tried to inject his wife with poison. Three hours after Ali had administered the injection, he started beating Aliya along with his father.

Aliya began yelling out loud for help and her neighbours stormed into the house. “The doctors had conducted an ultrasound and revealed the Aaliya was about to have a third daughter,” said her neighbour Mahnoor. “When we found her she was chained up and he was beating her because he wanted to get rid of the child,” she said.

“They initially hit us as well and they were hurling abuses at her but we managed to get her out,” said Ali’s neighbour Kashif. “They kept saying that if she was going to bring ‘another’ girl into the house it was better if they both died,” Mahnoor said. “By the time we rescued her from the men, she had gone into labour so we rushed her to the hospital,” Kashif added.

Aliya’s neighbours called her maternal uncle Qaisar Abbas, who informed the police of the matter. “I received a call from her neighbours asking me to meet them at the hospital. They said she was in grave pain,” Abbas said.

Kacha Kho Police Station House Officer (SHO) Zahid Gujjar, said that he sent a team to apprehend the victim the moment he received the news.

Police officials managed to arrest Ali, who fled the scene, after being tipped off to his location. “We are questioning both men and pursuing the case,” Zahid said, adding that Aliya was being given police protection.

Police officials have lodged an FIR no 14/2011 under section 506,342 against Muhammad Ali and his father Allah Datta on the application of Qaisar Abbas.

Aliya was shifted to the Tehsil Headquarters Hospital where she gave birth to a healthy baby girl.

The name of the victim has been altered to protect her privacy.

Published in The Express Tribune, January 19th,  2011.

COMMENTS (14)

Matt Wilson | 13 years ago | Reply @Maria: I agree with everything you said. I would add, however, that in much the same way that Iran claims to "not have any gays", Pakistan might itself suffer from under reported infanticide. In any case where abortion is outlawed, or "frowned upon" as you put it, people aren't going to be so willing to call attention to it. And while you certainly are correct that one man's criminal acts do not represent the mindset of his people, the case against Islam fueling this kind of barbarism is not completely without merit. It is my position that the Qu'ran would seem to indicate, if not expressly encourage, mistreatment of women and the God-like authority men wield over them. However, I think with any system of belief, there will always be a mix of moderates and extremists. The average person has enough moral decency to disregard the extreme views expressed in most religious doctrine, whether it's Islam or Christianity or Judaism, and whether they realize they're doing it or not.
Maria | 13 years ago | Reply Cecille: I challenge your assertions because I know that female infanticide is not a problem in Pakistan through my work in the medical field. Abortion is frowned upon in Pakistan. Yes lower income families may wish for more males, especially since males will provide more income for the family, but there is no issue with female infanticide as practiced is India or other nations. I would ask you to reference statistics on gender in Pakistan, which does not show a "missing" percentage of girls as in India or China. Yes we definitely need to educate the public and value the contributions of women more. And no the actions of one criminal does not reflect the mindset of a society any more than the killing of abortion doctors in the US reflects the practice of society there. The same way criminals are brought to justice there, we wish to see criminals in our society brought to justice. You seem to have your own axe to grind but remember when you point a finger at others, four fingers are pointing back at you.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ