Full-spectrum deterrence? Envoy rejects West’s concern

Says tactical N-weapons have been centre of dialogue with US.


Our Correspondent December 18, 2015
PHOTO: AFP

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan has been successful in deterring India’s aggressive designs by developing tactical nuclear weapons and should reject Western pressure in this regard.

This was stated by Pakistan’s former representative to International Atomic Energy Agency and Conference on Disarmament Zamir Akram.

He was delivering a lecture on ‘Politics of Nuclear Non-Proliferation, NSG and Way forward for Pakistan’ at the Islamabad-based think-tank Strategic Vision Institute (SVI) on Friday.

Tactical or short range nuclear weapons have been at the centre of the dialogue with the United States over strategic issues.

US Special Envoy for Afghanistan and Pakistan Richard Olson this week told a Congressional Panel that Washington was holding ‘candid discussions’ with Islamabad on its tactical weapons.



Akram said pressure was being exerted on Pakistan to cap its nuclear and missile programme.

“We should categorically tell the western countries that we cannot cap our strategic programme,” he advised.

He further rejected Western concerns about Full-Spectrum Deterrence saying it can be achieved at the minimum level and there was no contradiction between the two concepts.

He was of the opinion that after India adopted ‘Cold Start Doctrine’, Pakistan was left with the choice of either matching India’s defense expenditure or opting for the cost-effective tactical weapons.

“This (strategy of developing short range missiles) has worked for Pakistan,” he maintained.

The former envoy said that the West has been particularly biased against the Pakistani programme.

Meanwhile, Indians, he said, were being given a free hand to expand both conventional and nuclear capabilities. India, he opined, was a beneficiary of dynamics of international strategic environment where US wants to promote it as a counter to China’s rise as a global power.

About the significance of getting NSG’s membership, he said, “it was a measure of one’s status as nuclear power.”

Pakistan, he suggested, can counter Western pressure on its nuclear programme by leveraging its strategic importance for the West in the context of its counter-terrorism efforts.

President SVI Dr Zafar Iqbal Cheema said it was absurd to ask Pakistan to revert from full-spectrum deterrence to strategic deterrence and unilaterally sign the CTBT that the US itself has not ratified.

Published in The Express Tribune, December 19th, 2015.

COMMENTS (1)

John B | 5 years ago | Reply "Pakistan, .......can counter Western pressure on its nuclear programme by leveraging its strategic importance for the West in the context of its counter-terrorism efforts." So, if the west does not agree to pak demands, pak will unleash the terrorism or ignore terrorists? This is the most illogical analysis of strategic thinking and shows the dirth of intellectual input in policy making. It is time for pak to seriously make a table of cost Vs benefit of her nuclear program. No country in today's world can get away with using nuclear weapons. Time for younger generation of PAK to educate the old school .
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

E-Publications

Most Read