TODAY’S PAPER | November 22, 2026 | EPAPER

Is asking for rights a crime?

Letter November 22, 2026
Is asking for rights a crime?

KARACHI:

Teachers are the architects of any society. They lead children out of the darkness of ignorance and shape them into informed, responsible citizens. A nation that honours its teachers invests in its own future. A nation that humiliates them undermines the foundations on which it stands. It is therefore deeply regrettable that whenever teachers raise their voices for their legitimate rights, the government answers with force rather than attention.
Long-standing grievances go unaddressed, and peaceful protest is met with batons, tear gas and water cannons. This raises some uncomfortable questions. Is it a crime to protest peacefully for one’s rights? Do teachers not have the right to present their charter of demands to those in authority? And what drove them, in the first place, to leave their classrooms and stage a sit-in on the streets of Karachi?
The scenes outside the Karachi Press Club on November 4, where protesting teachers faced police brutality, tear gas and water cannons, cast serious doubt on the Sindh government’s democratic claims. What exactly was their offence? They asked for a proper service structure, fair promotions and the resolution of problems that have lingered for years. These are not unreasonable demands. They are the basic conditions of a dignified profession. What kind of governance turns its force on people who have spent years in classrooms shaping the minds of our children? Every baton that falls on a teacher also falls on the education system the government claims to be reforming.
A teacher is not a criminal to be subdued but a partner to be heard, and rulers who promise better education must begin by securing the respect and economic well-being of those who deliver it. Force will not silence legitimate grievances; it will only deepen mistrust and widen the gap between the state and the people who serve it, so dialogue, not repression, is the only sensible way forward. The Sindh government should engage with teachers in good faith and promptly accept their legitimate demands, including a proper service structure.
Azhar Azad Mughal and Dr Intikhab Ulfat
Islamabad