
KARACHI:
The exploitation of donkeys in Karachi is so common that cruelty is often mistaken for a routine activity. Despite laws against animal cruelty in Pakistan, donkeys carry excessive loads beyond their physical capacity, particularly when transporting construction materials and waste.
Most working donkeys wear uncomfortable harnesses that cause injuries and are beaten with lashes. They are subjected to nostril slitting and other forms of body mutilation due to misconceptions about animal health. These practices cause suffering and often go untreated due to a lack of financial resources for veterinary care. Due to long working hours, they also suffer from malnutrition as a result of inadequate food, water and rest.
According to a 2019 academic study on donkey welfare in Karachi, researchers assessed 204 donkeys and interviewed 200 donkey owners. Their findings revealed that 78.4% of the donkeys had muzzle mutilations, 66.7% had superficial knee lesions, and 52.9% had low body condition scores. The study also found that waste collection was the primary source of income for 89% of the donkey owners interviewed. Various families depend on donkey carts for their livelihoods; however, economic hardship should not justify animal suffering.
Pakistan has animal cruelty legislation, including Sindh’s Welfare and Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act. However, enforcement remains limited. To prevent further abuse of working donkeys, the government should enforce existing animal protection laws and conduct regular inspections of working animals to identify signs of abuse, malnutrition or neglect. It should introduce load limits to prevent overloading and establish a mechanism for reporting animal cruelty, ensuring complaints are acted upon. Affordable or free veterinary treatment should be available in areas where working donkeys are common. Moreover, the public can contribute by reporting visible cruelty to relevant authorities and spreading awareness through programmes that educate others about the proper handling of working donkeys.
Working donkeys are important to Karachi’ families. However, their inability to speak for themselves should never justify their suffering.
Samaha Khan
Karachi