KARACHI:
This refers to an article by Mr Khalid Ranjha published in these columns regarding the CSS examination conducted under the Federal Public Service Commission (FPSC). The article raises certain concerns regarding the CSS examination system. However, most observations appear to be based on assumptions and generalised perceptions rather than verifiable facts, besides being unsupported by data, research, or empirical evidence.
Candidates appearing in the CSS examination are provided a broad range of optional subjects to choose from according to their academic background and preference. The examination scheme has been designed to ensure diversity of disciplines and fairness amongst candidates. For this purpose, optional subjects are divided into groups, and restrictions are placed on the number of subjects that may be selected from a single group so as to maintain balance and equal opportunity.
The assertion that examiners intentionally target certain optional subjects chosen by a large number of candidates is baseless. Each subject is assessed independently by qualified subject specialists in accordance with prescribed standards and procedures. The suggestion that marking trends are manipulated to reduce the burden of examiners is devoid of any substance and evidence.
Similarly, the assertion regarding “instructed marking” is a serious allegation. The Commission follows a structured and transparent assessment process whereby each subject is evaluated by its respective examiner on merit. The Commission will be pleased to review any evidence, research and data on the subject available with the author or the publisher.
Moreover, written examination and interview are distinct components to assess a candidate. The Commission maintains relevant examination data which does not support the contention that interview scores are influenced by written examination performance.
The FPSC remains committed to ensuring a fair, transparent and merit-based competitive examination process. It enjoys the confidence of candidates and the public at large due to its institutional credibility and established procedures.
Atiq Ahmad
FPSC, Karachi
