Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa’s examination boards, beginning with BISE Swat, have decided to appoint fresh graduates for invigilation and marking — a move presented as reform. While the intent to engage youth is commendable, the policy raises serious concerns about examination credibility.
Invigilation is not a routine clerical task; it requires authority, classroom control and the experience to enforce rules under pressure. Expecting new graduates to manage crowded halls overlooks the reality of organised cheating networks. Even senior teachers, backed by institutional authority, often face intimidation. It is unrealistic to assume temporary appointees can withstand such pressure without similar safeguards. Moreover, temporary staff operate without a clear legal framework to ensure accountability in cases of malpractice.
If K-P boards wish to involve young professionals, they should adopt a hybrid model — pairing them with seasoned invigilators. Reform should strengthen public trust in examinations, not place high-stakes assessments at unnecessary risk.
Manzar Hassan
Peshawar
