Quota over merit

Letter April 23, 2025
Quota over merit

In every flourishing society, merit serves as a cornerstone of progress. A nation cannot move forward if its most talented and deserving individuals are denied opportunities based on regional, ethnic, or socio-political classifications. Unfortunately, the reality of Pakistani systems overshadows qualifications over quotas.

Dr Martin Luther King Jr once said, “I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the colour of their skin, but by the content of their character.” This vision of justice, equality, and merit-based recognition resonates deeply today. Shouldn’t our youth be judged by their talent, hard work, and character rather than their region or background?

Unfortunately, the quota system often favours individuals based on location or group identity, rather than ability. This demotivates deserving candidates and weakens the spirit of fairness in our society. Considering that Pakistan is an Islamic state, justice and merit should be essential values in our country. Islam commands that roles and responsibilities be given to the most capable individuals, not based on tribal, ethnic, or regional affiliations.

 We must ask ourselves: Why not merit? Why not build a society where every child, regardless of background, knows that their hard work will be fairly rewarded? There is strong reason to rethink and reform the quota system, ensuring a just balance that supports the needy without compromising the rights of the deserving. 

Razi Alam
Karachi