Imran Khan and the MQM: Similar yet distant

What is Imran Khan's argument with MQM all about, when his political ideology is very similar to it?

Syed Ali November 21, 2010
Imran Khan is well known for his work in the development sector. He is also a national sports hero and hopes to bring reforms that will change the status quo and bring progress and prosperity in Pakistan by doing away with the corrupt and feudal controlled system.

Khan leads a pro-democracy center-right political party, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf or "Pakistan's Movement for Justice"  – justice, which is said to be the main agenda for reform. He offers an ideology which is very similar to the center-left political parties, but he appears more interested in educated professionals, who are self-made and renowned international figures in their respective fields (like he was).

Good intentions but misguided actions

Khan would have individuals running the country as a non-profit charity organisation, where well known personalities with sound financial backgrounds work as volunteers. PTI also offers patriotism and aims to improve the national image with 'made in Pakistan' achievements, with the final vision of bringing people of this nation and those in the First World on a par.

There is no doubt his intentions for Pakistan's success are pure, but so far he has not been able to prove his worth in national politics. And it has been 15 years already. The only exception is when he won a National Assembly seat from his hometown in elections during General Musharraf's tenure. Khan let go of the seat after five years in protest against the president's office and the uniform. After being influenced by a religious party he boycotted the contest in 2008, as he felt a dictator would not be able to bring democracy under his rule. But this did not stop him form fielding candidates in by-elections throughout Punjab, held under the government that was elected during the reign of a Musharraf. Despite that, he continues to highlight the similarities between a dictator and the democratic president of today.

Most Pakistanis who support him are young or female. That is primarily because he is the most good looking male politician around, and a successful cricketer who made it to the Hall of Fame with his personal achievements. Pakistan's population and demographics are in his favour, if we categorise with numbers, then in all fairness his following should be well above 2/3rd of the total population of Pakistan.

Khan also claims he has never voted for elections in his life, except for his own seat in 2002 as he had always harboured doubts about the electoral process in the country.

Imran Khan’s stand against the MQM

What caught my attention was that Khan continued to reiterate that he does not see an alliance with MQM even though his movement is following the same goals. He believes that MQM is a 'terrorist organisation'  and perhaps, he feels, not up to his level of politics.

In 2009, when Khan had gone through a minor medical procedure at his hospital, I remember MQM Punjab's senior members and the coordination committee members had paid a visit to Khan to inquire about his health. He remains upset with the MQM because they had filed a disqualification reference against him when he was an assembly member. This was after Khan had vowed to have an MQM leader arrested in the UK within three months, extradited to Pakistan and tried for charges.

Calling a national political party that holds the mandate of millions 'terrorists', is unjustified. Would his statement of calling MQM 'deshatgard' mean he rejects the voters of MQM as thugs and militants, who are from the middle class and working to provide Pakistan 68 per cent revenue and make up to 25 per cent of the GDP but only because the majority in Karachi votes for the MQM.

Hypocritical arguments

I find it very strange that Khan is ready to pursue peace talks with the Taliban, who are known to the world as terrorists, but is not willing to meet the MQM leaders from a center-left progressive political movement similar to his own. He justifies this by saying that the US too is willing to negotiate with the Taliban, without realising that the Afghan Taliban are fighting foreigners and the Pakistani Taliban are killing their own people.
Syed Ali A businessman who writes on politics and civic issues. He completed his masters in business administration from Boston University. He tweets @abidifactor.
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


amin | 11 years ago | Reply @Ahsan: the main reason you dont know much people from TI is because they never got elected. farooq sattar and company were elected and then its obvious people will notice them in the media and stuff. To back up my point ask yourself do u know anyone from maulana diesal party or jamate islami? quote "When we look deep into Altaf’s personality, we see a simple but iron-willed individual, a deeply wronged man who is keen to correct social injustices and to civilize/modernise the nation" simply abusive to his wife and against the creation ofthe country he wants to rule Lmao(the altaf indian video). living the life of luxury in london while his party members destroy the peace of my city karachi.Can you tell me why there was voilence and people shops shut down when this MQM guy was killed in london? Is this justice you are talking about?. MQM did not do anything to civilize as far as i know. they are only known good killers. all they are proud of is provinding us with a "do numbri" mayor. Quote "In my opinion therefore, Imran Khan is: a) looking to fix the ‘image’ of Pakistan and not its problems (he is barely aware of the ‘problems’ and more confused than aware about whether these are really problems or not). b) is highly sensitive (albeit subconsciously) to how Pakistan is perceived in the West." Image of pakistan and the problems are linked. Pakistan got a bad image because it got problems. he is not barely aware of the problems, he has travelled every part of paksitan unlike the british citizen altaf and his knowledge about the world and pakistan exceeds a 1000 times to that of altaf. He didnt simply return to pakistan to improve image so that he can live in peace in london. that is absurd. there are many pakistanis i see who get rid of thier pakistani identity completely to get US or UK nationality and behave like they aint even aware of pakistan. IMran could have done it too if what you are saying was true. More or less he is the best leader in current times with some soulutions that people may critisize but they shouldnt reach the conclusion even before he takes steps to implement them plus altaf got no solutions so according to me he aint even in the picture right now.. yes imran aint perfect but he is ultimately only a human.
xiaahmad | 11 years ago | Reply those ppl who say Imran needs to learn politics I would say if by that you ppl mean that he become like current politicians then I really hope that he dont learn politics We need honest people not liar politicians. MQM needs to change Altaf hussain to get more support that person is hold MQM back most of the hate against MQM is because of Altaf and his policies.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ