Another women's bill passed - so what?

Does passing a bill and making it into a law and then leaving it to rot on shelves help? So far, it hasn't.

Ayesha Jehangir November 23, 2011
So another bill was passed in the National Assembly for taking women rights forward. As a woman, and an ardent advocate of women rights, I should be happy and celebrating. But, seriously, I am not.

In fact, what does this Prevention of Anti-Women Practices (Criminal Law Amendment) Act 2011 have to offer that the Protection of Women (Criminal Laws Amendment) Act, 2006 or the Protection Against Harassment of Women at Workplace Act 2010 did not offer anyway?

Women are still raped, killed for ‘honour’, thrown acid on and harassed at the workplace. Does passing a bill and making it into a law and then leaving it to rot on shelves help? So far, it hasn’t. Pakistan is still third in the list of world’s most dangerous places for women after Afghanistan and Congo.

The PML-Q’s Donya Aziz, author of the newly-passed bill, said in its objectives that the legislation aimed to reduce social injustice against women by proposing severe punishments, which is commendable. However, she and others involved in tabling and passing the bill should not forget that in Sindh alone, some 1,000 forced marriages take place every year, of which a mere 12 to 15% come to notice. The rest die suffocating under ‘political influence’ and the power of money. The ones presented before courts linger due to fake documents, absent respondents and missing witnesses.

My question is: will this bill also counter political suppression and the influence of money in such cases?

Which brings me to the much talked about case of Dost Muhammad Khosa’s missing wife, considered ‘killed’ by many. This can be a good case to begin with, to check the transparency of this law and that of our political parties in power and to test the claim of ‘reducing anti-women practices.’

We live in a country where 14,000 women die every year during childbirth and several more due to unsafe abortions; where 90 per cent of women face domestic violence of some kind and every year more than 1,000 are victims of honour killings; where two-thirds of women are illiterate and more than nine million girls do not go to school; where 70 to 90 per cent of women in rural areas are victims of domestic violence, and a woman is raped every two hours. What is the government doing for them? I hope they are not preparing more bills to pass.

I am not a pessimist, but I am also not an idealist. If we want to make the situation in Pakistan any better for women, we first need to provide them their basic human rights and facilities.
Ayesha Jehangir A sub-editor on the Lahore desk of The Express Tribune. She graduated from Kinnaird College with a masters in mass communication and is a Friedrich Ebert Stiftung Fellow of Journalism at DW, Bonn.
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Aakasa | 12 years ago | Reply I was in dark. I wasn't scared. I saw a dog coming. I wasn't scared. I saw a man coming. I was scared. :) When words leave off, silence captures the true essence of what we want to say.
SAJJO | 12 years ago | Reply Wow it is so shameful to hear this. I am from Trinidad but descend from Punjab, it is so upsetting and disgraceful to see what women in Pakistan go through, thank God this does not happen in my country. Also excellent article to have the courage to highlight this. I admire youm and with more exposure like this article, things will eventually change for the better.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ