Discourse on corruption: an exercise in futility

Asking Nawaz Sharif or President Zardari to declare their assets is not going to rid the country of corruption

Heba Islam November 18, 2011
If there’s one thing that captures public imagination in this country, it’s the phenomenon of corruption. The very word, thrown around in public discourse by politicians, talk show hosts and drawing room conversationalists, is as omnipresent as the occurrence of the phenomenon itself.

Although the idea of ‘scourging’ Pakistan of corrupt politicians appeals to our morality-crazed middle class, my argument is that this paradigm is an inherently flawed way of viewing the problem.

Asking Nawaz Sharif or President Zardari to declare their assets is not going to rid the country of corruption – and here is why. Corruption and fraud are not the results of a few individuals who become the face of dishonesty in collective consciousness. Rather, it is very much an institutionalised and historical problem that Pakistan has faced since its very inception.  Corruption, therefore, needs to be contextualised before we all desperately jump on the next bandwagon declaring that it’s going to rid the country of evil by holding ten famous politicians accountable for their misappropriation of public funds.

In case you’re thinking, “well, it became worse when Zardari and his lot came along,” here’s an insightful excerpt from Jinnah’s speech to the constituent assembly in 1947:
“One of the biggest curses from which India is suffering—I do not say that other countries are free from it, but, I think our condition is much worse—is bribery and corruption.”

So here we see that this is in fact, a systemic malaise. Are corrupt politicians a cause for the problems faced by Pakistan or a symptom? I think it’s more a case of the latter. Legal lacunae, for example, facilitate this rampant dishonesty. The Acquisition of Land Act, dating back to 1894 has been modified over the years for (to quote one instance) for allowing the government to purchase land from the poor and sell it off to ‘land mafia’.

When you see that corruption is something that extends from top politicians and military brass to a clerk at the passport office, that’s when you know it’s time to address corruption as a structural issue. Looking up to those who plan to empty a corrupt politician or two’s pockets, therefore, is a flawed and short-term approach.
WRITTEN BY:
Heba Islam Heba Islam is a sub-editor at the national desk at Express Tribune. She tweets @hebaislam.
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.

Facebook Conversations

COMMENTS (14)

zameer afaqi | 8 years ago | Reply | Recommend A Request to the Friends' I request to my all friends that we are all respectable and we respect each others but some times consciously and Unconsciously we make some mistakes those are not fair for anyone.A few days ago,there is same happening to a friend which made him ashamed and worried. including that friend and to all friends there is a request please be careful for the next time when you upload any picture or update the stat mint. Because among you respectable friends there are also family members,including women and children.Please when you hit like any post you must have check clearly before hitting,because when you like or comment any post it reached to your all friends on Facebook.So be Careful and make this social network easier and good..zameer afaqi
Farrukh abbas | 8 years ago | Reply | Recommend Each of us try to get captured the opportunities does not think whose right is this blaming others not thinking ourselves what we r doing for our selfishnes then we ignore all the right just taking shortways to fulfill desires then no rules no justice & when we got captured then repent on our deeds and try to give false justification then we forget our cultures,customs & religious if we do so who can suport us we does not think these r the basic failures of our society b/c we have not the courage the reality there r many socio-economical hindrances come across our way but we have never forget that right direction is too much dificult but long lasting and forever
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ