When thousands of Palestinians rallied for freedom this past weekend, Benjamin Netanyahu’s response was not to stand by their ‘freedom’.

Israel and US are ‘champions’ of human rights, but not when it comes to Palestine

In this “better them than us” scenario, it's justified to injure 1,400 Palestinians over jeopardising even one Israeli

Darius Shahtahmasebi April 03, 2018
Almost a month ago, Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, tweeted to show solidarity with the Iranian women protesting against Iran’s hijab laws, mentioning that he stands by those who stand for ‘freedom’.

Nikki Haley, Donald Trump’s ambassador to the UN, also said something similar in January of this year when protests began to rock Iran shortly after the beginning of 2018.
“The people of Iran are crying out for freedom,” Haley said at the time. “All freedom-loving people must stand with their cause.”

And yet, when thousands of Palestinians rallied for freedom of their own this past weekend, Israel’s response was not to stand by their ‘freedom’. Instead, it deployed over 100 snipers to the Gaza border, and shot the protesters down in cold blood. Reports have emerged that some 1,400 people were injured, and at least 15 were killed by the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF).

The protests, which actually involve young, peaceful and unarmed protesters, represent the 700,000 Palestinians who either fled or were expelled from their homes when Israel first sprang into existence in 1948. They are protesting for the right of return to their land, having been trapped and enclosed in what is widely regarded as an open-air prison, subject to routine bombing by the Israeli military.

As of this year, 97% of Gaza’s drinking water has been contaminated by sewage and salt. For most of last year, the residents of Gaza were restricted to barely four hours of electricity in a day. By 2020, the UN has predicted Gaza will become completely uninhabitable.

The people of Gaza are clearly crying out for freedom. So what was Netanyahu and Haley’s response this time around?

Netanyahu not only accepted responsibility for the IDF mowing down unarmed civilians, but he actually bore this responsibility with pride. In a statement released on Saturday, the Prime Minister stated:
“Well done to our soldiers. Israel acts vigorously and with determination to protect its sovereignty and the security of its citizens.”

Israel’s Defense Minister, Avigdor Lieberman, went even further by saying its military ‘did what had to be done’, and added,
“I think that all of our troops deserve a medal.”

Brigadier General Ronen Manelis tried to claim that had Israel not responded with such brute force, the alternative would have been even worse, stating, “we prevented a bloodbath.”

One can only wonder what sort of activities can be justified using this type of logic. Using violence to prevent violence from taking place only makes sense when it becomes clear what is really being discussed here. Namely, this is a “better them than us” scenario, in which it is justifiable in the eyes of the IDF to injure 1,400 Palestinians rather than jeopardise the safety of even one Israeli.

At Kuwait’s request, and following UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres’ call for an independent and transparent investigation into Israel’s actions, the UN Security Council held an emergency meeting on Friday, with the aim of issuing a statement condemning Israel’s deadly use of force.

The US blocked the statement several times. Apparently, Haley’s role as ambassador to the UN involves convening emergency meetings for protests inside Iran, but the 2 million residents of Gaza do not deserve equal respect and treatment.

While the killing of at least 15 protestors and the injuries of another 1,400 might seem like harsh measures, the blunt truth of the matter is that this is just the beginning of something far more sinister.

The Trump administration will officially be moving the US embassy in Israel to Jerusalem on May 14, 2018, in order to solidify Trump’s recognition of Jerusalem as Israel’s true capital. However, the following day (May 15, 2018) is the day the current Palestinian protests are leading up to – known as Nakba Day to the Palestinian people. This day represents the expulsion of 700,000 Palestinian people from their homes as mentioned earlier, and is a highly emotional occasion marked every year by the Palestinians.

The decision to move the embassy the day before Nakba Day is nothing short of an impending explosion. At the time, Hamas immediately warned,
“this will be the trigger which would detonate the whole area in the face of the Israeli occupation.”

In turn, Israel has also warned it will expand its response if these border clashes continue at Gaza.

Make no mistake – this conflict is only beginning to heat up, and the worse, unfortunately, is yet to come.
Darius Shahtahmasebi The author has completed a Double Degree in Law and Japanese from the University of Otago, with an interest in human rights, international law and journalism. He's a fully qualified lawyer in two separate jurisdictions, and writes about foreign policy for Anti-Media. He tweets at @TVsLeaking ‏(https://twitter.com/TVsLeaking)
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.

Facebook Conversations


Rex Minor | 2 years ago | Reply | Recommend Both the people of the USA and Israel are not indigenous folks of the lands they have occupied but of nomadic origin and very likely to leave and move on once the heat becomes intolerable. Human rights is not their business. The Palestinian folks need patience like their thousands years old olive trees. the God of Ibrahim knows of their sufferings. Rex Minor
Massie V Awidad | 2 years ago | Reply | Recommend The writer of this article is either out of touch with reality or has been payed to write this; if the US and Israel are champions of human rights then I'am heavy weight champion of the world
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ