Mukhtaran Mai case: Mubashar Luqman's big mistake

I felt nauseated after listening to the disgusting drivel on Luqman's show. Please! Enough of this NGO bashing.

Fouzia Saeed April 25, 2011
The Supreme Court (SC) judgement of Mukhtaran Mai’s case was a great disappointment, but the insensitivity displayed by some elements of the media, was shocking.

Many elements in the media treated the judgement as they treat every other issue – adding a lot of masala, controversy and sensationalism to it.

While I think that no issue deserves this sort of juvenile treatment, there should be a limit to the coverage of sensitive topics like this one.

The decision of the SC has been a big setback for the women of Pakistan. Most decent people in Pakistan, and the rest of the world, think women should not be raped and that gang rapes, especially those which are ordered by jirgas and take place in the presence of a whole village, should be punished. Hence, the court’s decision is a slap in the face of this nation and, yet, our media had the nerve to make fun of the victim. We expect more sensitivity from those who manage people’s access to information.

Get the facts straight

Among several programs that covered the decision, Mubashar Luqman’s Khari Baat on Dunya TV was by far the vilest. I was shocked when I watched it.

The host, who usually does a lot of homework on the cases he presents, seemingly had no knowledge of the details of the case. He had invited two guests, a journalist and a lawyer, who conveniently played what seemed like a game of volleyball with Mukhtaran’s story, with no counter-arguments presented.

Mukhtaran, who initially was on air, live from her home, walked out after hearing the low level of accusations. The argument that was presented in that program was that nothing had really happened and she had made up the whole story. They claimed that “human rights groups, NGOs and Mukhtaran made it up because this is how they earn their living”. I felt nauseated listening to their disgusting drivel.

If nothing happened, why has the SC confirmed that one person should remain in prison for the rest of his life for committing a rape?

The truth is that Luqman, and many other hosts who did programs on Mukhtaran, did not fully read the judgement. Nowhere does the court say that the incident did not take place.

Enough with the NGO bashing

During the program, a well respected nationally and internationally acclaimed scholar was also allowed to be run down. Dr Farzana Bari, who is the head of Gender Studies Department at Quaid-e-Azam University and also credited with setting up this department and building it into a significant institution, was ridiculed during the show.

She and her husband, Sarwar Bari, had been living comfortably in the UK for a long time before returning to Pakistan with a mission to contribute to their country. I am not only reacting to how Farzana was treated, but I would like to say that we women, who put out our necks on the block for human rights violation are pretty tired of being ridiculed, maligned and stereotyped.

It is high time that at least the so called ‘aware’ people start giving us some respect. It is pretty ironic that every time there is a human rights violation, people in media ask, “Where are the NGOs? What are you doing about it?” as if it is only our responsibility to prevent all offenses. And, when we do speak up, just as every citizen should, to make this system accountable, the media claims that we are paid to besmirch the honour of our nation.

The other thing I would like to clarify is that the category NGOs includes madrassas and all religious organization as well.  For your information, these ‘faith-based NGOs’ use up a significant portion of foreign funds. So, please! Enough of this NGO bashing!

There are good and bad in all sectors so I will not defend all NGOs, but let’s stop stereotyping everyone and placing them in one category - just as we should not stereotype media walas.

There are responsible and irresponsible elements in the media too. Many clearly do take money to present the news in a slanted way.  Many hosts take millions for a single program and yet they only bash politicians, but do not have the courage to say anything against the military or militant groups.

I am not saying all media is bad. Some dealt with issue very well. I would mention Naseem Zehra’s program on Dunya TV and Nadia Naqi’s on AaJ TV as outstanding examples.

Just so I don’t lose all respect for Mr Luqman, I would like to suggest that he hold another program on Mukhtaran Mai, but this time after doing his homework, and after building an understanding of what this case means to the country and to the women of Pakistan.
Fouzia Saeed A social scientist with a PhD from the University of Minnesota and the author of "Taboo! The Hidden Culture of a Red Light Area."
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Real Prince. | 12 years ago | Reply @deep: Why babbly about rape or sodomy when the event never occured? Forensic reports proved otherwise, else why would this firebrand CJP give a judgement against this angel of Pakistan who didn't waste a moment to bring musharraf's regime in trouble and firstly you guys were not satisfied with High Court setting free the innocent accused and now you're not satisfied with judgement of IFtikhar Chaudry. Just read the specifics of case in the article " Curious case of Mukhtaran Mai" that was published in The News.
Leila Rage | 12 years ago | Reply @Athar: @Fahad Raza: and many others Your responses all reflect the callous thinking of the general Pakistani man. Mr. Athar says that Mai has received a lot of money and he seems to think that this proves that she was exploiting these men for her own gains. Our government is prone to doling out money to victims of crimes and injustice to keep them quiet. Do you think that any amount of money could EVER compensate for her suffering and humiliation? I think not. She has to live with it for LIFE. And Mr. Raza, you commend Mubasher Lucman for doing a wonderful job---I wonder how you would feel if you were a victim of a crime and a TV show host humiliated and insulted you the way Mai was treated. I'm sure you would feel differently if you had been born as women. Only then would you understand the horrors faced by Pakistani women EVERY SECOND of EVERY DAY.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ