What really goes on in the Sindh Assembly

Ministers in the assembly have no idea about the content of legislation; they're just there to gossip and socialise.

Hafeez Tunio February 08, 2011

In June 2010, legislators from the Sindh Assembly zealously thumped their desks after passing a bill for the establishment of the “Sindh Revenue Board” to collect sales tax on services.

While covering the story, I was surprised to know that a majority of legislators were not even aware of the bill’s significance; they didn’t know the difference between tax on services and tax on goods.

One of the MPAs went on to say, “We have no idea about the bill; it is enough that we have supported it.” And I can assure these were the exact words of the lawmaker, who belonged to the treasury benches.

During assembly sessions, I sometimes sit in awe of these ‘educated’ lawmakers, who gossip with each other, while the speaker pleads for attention.

However, warnings always go in vain, which illustrates a lack of interest on the part of legislators towards their jobs. In reality, they are required to make laws, shed light on important public issues by raising points of order, submit resolutions and adjournment motions, and so on.

However, out of the assembly’s 168 members, barely ten actively take part in the legislation, or in other words, do what they are paid for.

The rest of the members come in late to the session, and always seem to be moving from one place to another, in pursuit of getting their personal work done by ministers.

The chief minister (CM) remains busy during assembly sessions signing papers, while MPAs and ministers scurry around the CM, waiting for an opportunity to sit next to him and brief him about their matters.

According to a progress report published by the Sindh Assembly last year, a majority of the legislators belonging both to the treasury and the opposition, remained silent during the entire year. They did not table a single bill, and did not move a single resolution or an adjournment motion.

With such a massive opportunity to address the province’s issues at a platform that possesses the capacity to make a significant difference, the numbness of the legislators will never cease to amaze me.

Hafeez Tunio

Political reporter https://twitter.com/etribune">@etribune 

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


parvez | 13 years ago | Reply It is when you read articles such as this that call it as it is, that one gets frustrated. You then start wondering why one should back this so called democratic system, this charade, this carefully constructed system of selection whereby a few hundred rotten individuals are repeatedly served up as law makers.
Let us not digress | 13 years ago | Reply That is exactly the reason why our people need to be louder about accountability. These guys go around doing whatever they wish without any sense of responsibility towards those who got them these seats in the first place.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ