Two party system and ethnic politics

It is time Pakistan moved on from ethnocentric politics to a two party based system. We need a new era of politics.

D Asghar January 06, 2011
It is often debated why the political process is so weak in a country as old as Pakistan. Yes, the direct and indirect military intervention is one of the primary reasons, but the poor performance of political parties must share the blame as well.

The country is bitterly divided on ethnic and, arguably in some cases, religious lines. This division impacts political parties to a great extent, as they are in essence a reflection of the sentiments and views of the general populace.

Ethnic politics

Sadly, right after its inception, the founding political party, the Muslim League was divided and subdivided into so many factions and branches (denoted by an alphabetic letter like N, Q, F, Z) that it is hard to decipher who represents which faction; it is almost an alphabet soup.

The Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) was, in the past, able to boast about being a representative of all four provinces of the country. However, the rules of engagement have changed tremendously in the recent years. Overall, it has a perception of being a Sindhi dominated party, often using its infamous ‘Sindh card’ to its advantage.

The Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM), which started out as the Muhajir Qaumi Movement, even with its refined renaming could not change its overall image. It is a party of the ethnic Urdu speaking minority on the surface, while on the mean streets of Karachi it is often remembered by different names.

The Awami National Party (ANP) is a supposedly secular and progressive movement, following the non-violent principles of Bacha Khan. In reality it is a Pukhtoon party with a major vote base of Khyber-Pukhtunkhwa. Similarly, we have the Jamiat Ulema-i-Islam-Fazal (JUI-F) which, although a religious political party wields its K-P centric clout.

Balochistan is riddled with the Balochistan Nationa Party (BNP), the Jamhoori Watan Party (JWP) and many others that cater to the ethnic culture of province.

The Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), the second largest party after the PPP, headed by twice elected former Prime Minister Mian Nawaz Sharif, is more or less a Punjabi party, with its roots firmly grounded in the Punjab province.

Weak coalitions

With these divisions along and the lack of cohesive nationalistic ideologies, we end up with weak ethnocentric parties. They cobble up coalition governments, but due to the lack of a unified national strategy and varied interest, they are only interested in engaging in ‘bargaining tactics.’ Not to mention, there are the ‘non political forces’ who do not want any political culture to prosper in the country.

In the end, we have weak coalition governments, often held hostage by stakeholders, who end up hurting the process and alienating the electorate. The disenchanted electorate ends up considering the military a viable option, and often forgets that all the military does is create another PML with a new letter comprised of its own cronies.

The solution

The solution lies in a strong two party system, where both parties are truly representative of the entire electorate of the country. The parties must have roots in all four provinces and their ideologies and manifestos should be aligned, not on the basis of the regional language, but the overall national interest. The formation of governments would be a lot easier and the transition from one to the other would be relatively smoother and painless. The political process will prosper and the votes will not be expected based on geographic, tribal or linguistic lines. It will be a new era in national politics, where Pakistan will truly be at the forefront of any agenda.
D Asghar A mortgage-banker by profession who also loves to write.
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Dumbo | 13 years ago | Reply @ Maria bibi , get an independent analysis approach . The mighty army and a nouveau rich gentry is ruling this land of pure and it is highly unlikely that they would relinquish this "right " in any near future . Do you really think they would late MQM to spread out in Punjab and KP ? Comeon be rationale , read the writing on the wall : The poor masses of Punjab and KP would alwyas bring into power the Corrupt to the core " Leaders: " again and again . And as far as Imran is concerned , first ask him to make uphis mind , where exactly he wants to GO . That is the irony .
Maria | 13 years ago | Reply @Ali: I agree that Imran Khan's party is the only party which has grassroots support among all peoples in Pakistan and is not necessarily based in any province. To some extent, the PPP is also the only party with a support base in all provinces, though primarily in Sind. I disagree that the MQM is seen as an inclusive party. Apart from Karachi, the MQM has no support and despite the name change, it is still regarded as an ethnic party of migrants from India. I don't know how it can overcome this label.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ