Pakistan's mullahpoly: My way or the highway

Clerics act like they have a copyright over Islam, promoting intolerance and hate. Is this what Jinnah wanted?

Tanzeel Ahmad December 27, 2010
In Pakistan, it seems as though religious clerics have acquired a copyright over Islam, and are exercising this right in its full capacity, including its publication, adaptation, distribution and interpretation.

I can safely say that most of us believe that Islam is a religion for all humanity and everyone has a right to learn and practice it. However, the custodians of Islam in this country like to follow and impose their self proclaimed rule.

If "Islam Incorporated" was a company than religious fanatics would be the management. The creditors (Islamic sects) loan its goods and services; shareholders (madrassah owners) invest their capital (madarsah education) and the employees (jihadi brigade) who contribute their labour to achieve and safeguard vested interests

Why legislate faith?

My concern is why does the government not allow all people to practice and preach their religion? Why do some laws declare some faiths null and void?  We all know that Islam is the fastest growing religion and can never be erased from the face of earth but we are not ready to believe in Allah who has taken sole responsibility to save the book and religion till the end.

Bhutto’s motto and political gain

Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto appeared on the political scene with his political slogan of:
“Islam is our religion, democracy is our politics, socialism is our economics.”

He won the elections but over the years, the notions of democracy and socialism faded into the background and Islam came to the forefront, especially when Bhutto proclaimed Friday as the weekly holiday and declared Ahmadis as non-Muslims. This was the beginning of the nightmare of religious intolerance.

Zia’s Islamisation

The nightmare worsened during the era of Ziaul-haq who handed religion over to illiterate mullahs and tried to Islamise all aspects of civil, political and social life from schools and hospitals to government offices. In consultation with the then religious scholars, he introduced law which resulted in the undermining of women’s rights.

The introduction of blasphemy law worked as an insult to the minorities’ injuries which led to hundreds of innocent people being killed and jailed on mere allegations.

These draconian laws are still thriving in Pakistani society, and “the privileged” majority think the right to declare anyone kafir or even kill in the name of religion just because they are allowed to believe that they are the true followers.

Sects and sub-sects

Different brigades of bearded men wearing black, green, white, brown turbans belong to different sects and sub-sects. They are more devoted to their religious doctrine than Islam. They claim to be a brotherhood but if you talk to them separately they don’t spare a second to “prove” another sect “non-Muslim”.

Pakistan’s religious cartel has been agreed on this: the minimum common agenda is that all Ahmadis are non-Muslims and their entry into the religious market might reduce their profit share in the cake. Thus, religious conglomerates of Pakistan have engineered separate laws to bar new players and (even after declaring them non-Muslims) have banned  them from practicing their version of Islam, let alone preaching.

A competitive religious market

Pakistan is the only country where dominating religious scholars have established such a “mullahpoly” that doesn’t allow competitors to even greet each other in an Islamic way or recite kalmah. Our traditional scholars are unaware of their competitor’s guerilla marketing strategy that relies on time, energy and imagination rather than a big marketing budget.

In his opening speech to the constituent assembly, Quaid-e-Azam said:
“You are free to go to your temples; you are free to go to your mosques or to any other place of worship in this state of Pakistan. You may belong to any caste or creed – that has nothing to do with the business of the state.”

But today’s Islamic Republic of Pakistan is an entirely different country than the one Jinnah had envisaged for us. He envisioned Pakistan as a moderate, progressive nation where minorities would be allowed to preach and practice their religion freely. Regardless of whatever logic our scholars present, they cannot justify curtailing religious freedom since that is a clear violation of Pakistan’s constitution and Jinnah’s thoughts. We are certainly living in the geographical location that Jinnah fought and struggled for, but in terms of vision and policy we are living in a chaotic mess with no improvement in future.
Tanzeel Ahmad A UAE based marketing professional who is interested in politics and cultural issues. He blogs at
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


MUNIB | 12 years ago | Reply @Shalal: here we go . . . one more "thekedar" of ISLAM from Mullah Inc
shahina | 12 years ago | Reply People say that illiteracy is the main problem in Pakistan but i have seen many litterates having no knowledge of there religion and totally relying on mullahs makes every thing worse though ! As said by the Holy Prophet(saw) of Islam that in the laters days these Mullah will be the worst creatrures on earth we all can see with our own eyes this being fullfilled with our own eyes how these Mullahs have nothing to do other than engraving hatracy among each others sects and giving fatwas of killing ! May Allah help all of us follow the true teachings of hazrat Muhammad (saw) and apply ir in our daily lives Ameen !
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ