Moving to Pakistan: My rational fears

I have to admit it - as an American hearing of bomb blasts daily in Pakistan, I am scared of my upcoming trip.

Cheree Franco December 14, 2010
As newspapers report more blasts every day, and as one of those blasts killed a would-be colleague, I have to admit it, I’m scared of moving to Pakistan.

And I’m defenseless. I don’t speak Urdu or Punjabi or Pashtu or any language except English and a poor smattering of Spanish. I’m American, and I look American. I’m female and tiny. My only defenses are my wits, and as my last post proved, those are sometimes off-mark. My friends and especially my family implore me—why are you going?

I often wonder if I should have been an artist rather than a journalist. These days both seem to be similarly impractical career choices, and one is a whole lot safer. As an artist, you can seem edgy, dangerous, flashy and exciting without actually putting yourself in danger. As a journalist, you can be bored and boring, even, while putting yourself in tremendous danger. I’m not sure the adrenaline is worth it, and sometimes I wonder if my contribution has any value. There are so many voices commanding greater knowledge than my own.

Am I foolhardy, guided by ego, to go and do and see and have people feign respect for my willingness to take these risks? If I’m not genuinely offering a fresh perspective, my efforts are merely a waste of everybody’s resources—most of all, my own.

I move constantly. I’ve been in Starkville, Mississippi nearly a year, which is about how long I stay anywhere.

I’m cozy here, doing my little PR job for a university, curling up to watch movies with my cats, dog and the best roommate ever, baking cupcakes for holiday parties and dropping in on my family just because, blogging under the tiny twinkly lights strung around my bedroom, crafting things, experimenting with vintage analogue cameras, stocking my shop.

I’m not restless yet, but I’m leaving anyway. And half-hoping that Pakistan will change everything, that it will be the beginning of my life as an international correspondent, that I will receive fellowships and grants and assignments and clamber the world over, filtering my water and living out of a backpack.

And I’m half-hoping I can return to things just as they are—roommate, pets, crafting.

I’ve read about Pakistani culture and I want to see everything, but will I be able to travel by myself, to trust people? Will I immerse myself in the culture or will I hole away in my flat, too paranoid to make the most out of this extraordinary (for most Westerners) experience?

If I truly consider the situation, everything’s threatening. My biggest concerns are obvious—random violence, kidnapping and ransom, laws I can’t comprehend, fears I don’t even want to write. But even simple things, like drinking water, could harm me.

Recently, I met a handful of amazing Pakistanis, even in my little Mississippi town. I correspond by email with Pakistani contacts. I have been both reassured and cautioned by all of these people.

I’m not backing out of this fellowship. I won’t let paranoia define my choices.

But I do think I should come clean. I’m American, and I’m sheltered— and no, those traits aren’t synonymous, and yes, they’re correlated. And as much as Pakistan fascinates me, it also seems alien and perilous. And then, in creeps the paranoia…
Cheree Franco A graduate of Columbia University’s Journalism School and fellow for The Express Tribune. She writes about art and culture for Juxtapoz magazine and blogs at
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Viren Das | 13 years ago | Reply @Tariq Qureshi: Hi Tariq ... why generalise all Indians? Anoop, has a point of view, though it is jaundiced and sarcastic. All he is hinting at is the plain fact that others, including Pakistanis, have pointed out ... that there is a conservative element, euphemistically put, in Pakistan that will scapegoat foreigners. It happens ... and not just in Pakistan. There are other Indians, Ms. Prasad's pointers are to be revisited, who have been very supportive of Ms. Cheree's visit and stay in Pakistan. Moreover, she brings a distinctly female point of view ... which I should say, is more relevant and pertinent than the less than helpful reply from most of the males, whether Indian or Pakistani. So, please, do not paint with broad brushstrokes. Thank you. And Anoop sahab, your point of view did not enlighten no one.
Erfan | 13 years ago | Reply Oh Wait don't go to Peshawar.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ