Please don’t kill my goat

I have always loved this Eid for the chance to make new goat friends. What I don't like is blood in my streets.

Nadya V November 03, 2010
My neighbours just bought these three cute little goats home, one each for their three little kids. They probably did that so the kids wouldn’t fight with each other while taking their new pets for evening walks, daily feeding, petting and other such childhood goodness which occurs at this time of the year.

I have always loved this Eid for the chance to make new goat friends. What I don’t like about this Eid is when we proceed to manhandle those gentle creatures, force them to the ground, watch our elders slit the throats of our new companions, string them up, skin them, bleed them dry, cook them and serve their innards fresh for dinner all on the same day.
When will we move beyond this barbaric, arcane ritual?

There is a reason why the act of butchery has been increasingly mechanized and hidden from society. Necessary evil though it is, there is absolutely no need for huge swathes of society to learn to murder a living creature, much less an intelligent creature, and worse, one you have kept and raised in your own home.

There is no need to take a symbolic gesture to such extremes in a world that is much changed from the times when this form of sacrifice was the norm. It is unhealthy for young children, and adults to experience (and perpetuate) violence on an animal.

I’m not even going to get into the nitty gritty of the roots of this ritual and why or why not it can or cannot, evolve into something less brutal. Google knows more than I do on that subject. I’m not going to stamp on it by citing the occasional case of men and women suffering from psychosis who proceed to slaughter their children in the name of God.

I am also not going to talk about how the psychological impact of seeing and inflicting this form of violence on a living creature may or may not be a causal factor behind a society’s desensitization to violence; an individual’s openness to committing further acts of violence; the confusion in a young, developing brain about what is morally right and wrong when it comes to killing; how there is a link between serial killers and a tendency towards torturing and murdering animals at a young age.

No the issue is much, much simpler than all the above if we just wake up from our collective slumber and thinly veiled justifications (of which I expect many in the comments) for an act of terror. Yes I said terror, yes I do eat meat, and yes I think there is little justification for hypocrisy, but must we celebrate it? Venerate it? Call it a wondrous thing?

I’m sorry. I just don’t want my streets running red anymore.
Nadya V Social critic and part-time gossip monger
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Nana | 12 years ago | Reply This is a wonder dialogue.Sacrificing is barbaric and plain EVIL. This practice was done in the medieval days, the Jews and Christians practiced it as well but as man grew so did his God ,wisdom and knowledge. Some Muslims are tangled with myths,culture and are shackling themselves with lack of there own spirituality and growth. Inbreeding has stunted spirituality and knowledge. People have become like mice following Pied Piper of Hamelin to there demise yet not question and take there own path. This is ignorance at its worse. I have seen nothing in Pakistan but dirt, filth, corruption and then the right wing fanatics. Why are people not questioning? By the way the meat most eat is Halal? Non of you question yet go on consuming it. Was the animal killed in a human way?Was it pregnant? Does it have a young one? Is it healthy? not killed in front of the other animal ? No trauma before being killed. Killing in a clean and sanitized way. All the above keeps me wondering you all are eating some thing that is haram, not questioning or you all are like mice? What is the difference between slaughter, killing or sacrificing?
??? | 13 years ago | Reply I wonder the writer is a non-muslim
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ