The repercussions of being a working woman instead of a mother in Pakistan

It is frustrating when a woman commands more respect simply because she has a child.

Natalia Tariq December 17, 2013
Recently, I posted an article on Facebook titled, ‘Sorry but being a mother is not the most important job in the world’ only to be faced with the wrath of many women, both with and without children, about how insensitive this article was and how I would never understand the importance of motherhood until I had my own child.

The reaction I received to the post points to two things.

First, perhaps understandably, the reactions seemed to be based on emotions rather than a critical reading of what the article actually says. The author is in no way trying to deride or ridicule the importance of motherhood but, on the contrary, says that motherhood is more than simply a ‘job’ and is a permanent relationship that one cannot quit, take a vacation from or earn a salary out of.

The other point of the article is that by classifying being a mother as ‘the most important job in the world’, it takes away from the importance of other relationships such as gay parents, single fathers, grandparents or other guardians. Making such a statement has a tendency to reduce women to just that, ‘a mother’, when her aspirations and identity should extend much beyond that.

What was more disturbing than the misinterpretation of the article was the notion that since I had no children of my own, I wasn’t entitled to have an opinion about motherhood. While I might not have given birth or raised a child yet, I still do have the capacity to think, reflect and formulate opinions. Such patronising statements are not only offensive, but they make little sense. It’s similar to saying,
“Since I have never been hit by a drone, I have no right to have an opinion for or against drone strikes”

“Since I am not African American, I have no right to support the civil liberties movement.”

Such statements also shed light on the deep seated bias and stigma our society has against women who are single, childless and dare to prioritise a career over marriage and parenting. So much value is placed on marriage and reproduction, and next to nothing on a woman’s professional or other achievements.

While the birth of a child is celebrated with great fervour and the new mother finds herself more respected by society and her family, especially if she ‘it’s a boy’, a woman’s promotion at work is hardly recognised. I am not saying that one should be valued over the other, but that women’s professional aspirations and achievements are so undervalued that it actually makes life for a young, single, working woman incredibly difficult.

Even though many single, young women work full time, live on their own and take full financial responsibility for themselves, society assumes that they are still being taken care of by their fathers or guardians. The 40 hours, or more, of work they do every week is treated as a hobby and a way to bide their time until they find a suitable match and thus, are ‘truly fulfilled’ in life.

It is frustrating when a woman commands more respect simply because she has a child as opposed to one who has successfully published a paper, gotten a salary increment or reached any other sort of professional landmark. Again, I am not saying one is better than the other, but they are both life choices made by individuals and that they should both be equally respected in their own right.

I want to live in a society where marriage and children are not seen as a necessity to living a meaningful life, but rather a choice that women and men make because it is something that they want.

I want to live in a world where a young woman’s promotion at work is applauded with the same enthusiasm as her engagement. A world where the respect and acceptance you command from a society comes not from your marital status or how fertile you are, but because of the person you are and aspire to be.
Natalia Tariq Manages the Transparency Program at Open Society Foundation Pakistan and is an MSc from the London School of Economics and Political Science. She tweets as @NataliaTariq87 ( Facebook profile: (
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Nobody | 10 years ago | Reply With respect to your opinion, I'm inclined to disagree. First off, you're one of the lucky few Pakistani women who actually HAS a choice to work or not work. Second, not ALL women in the West are forced to work; they CHOOSE to work. Society doesn't push them either which way; they just want to work and be self sufficient (plus, today's lifestyle generally requires two incomes and that, too, is a choice made by people). Furthermore, their male counterparts (particularly among younger generations) contribute to the household so having a family is not as unattainable or overly burdening. However, this of course doesn't mean your experiences or observations have to be identical to mine. Cheers.
Nobody | 10 years ago | Reply Having a working mother does not mean you will be neglected any more than having an at home mom means you will have a perfect childhood. I have an aunt and uncle, both roughly in their late 30's, both work very hard and earn a very comfortable living. They have two little children and although the parents work hard and the children are watched by nannies part time, neither child is neglected or unhappy. It requires more work on the part of both parents but balancing a career and children is very possible as long as BOTH parents take on the role of childcare.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ