Unimpressed and unmoved by Bilawal Bhutto's speech

Bilawal's uppity demeanour and outright ridicule of all rival parties smelled of feudal haughtiness.

Jalal Awan October 19, 2013
Bilawal Bhutto's speech at Karachi's Karsaz on the sixth anniversary of the unfortunate Oct 18, 2007 bombings has created quite a stir. As a son who lost a brave mother to rabid radicalisation, one feels that the emotionally-charged display of passion in front of an audience of die-hard jiyalas was all but natural, and perfectly anticipated. 

Towing the line of populist politics introduced by Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, Bilawal did a good job with a crowd that seemed to be only following half of what their 26-year-old chairman conveyed. His body language apparently conveyed the remaining half, complete with waving fists and suggestive eye-balling. Bilawal's script-writers did what they were paid to do; sensationalised the return of the Chairman, now officially eligible to contest a seat in the National Assembly.

The speech itself somehow reminded me of the 2010 British historical drama film The King's Speech. 

And it reminded me of how dynastic politics still rules the roost in Pakistan. Democracy might have found its footing but electoral politics in Pakistan still remains a family enterprise, under the stranglehold of a few, mostly feudal families.

As an Oxford educated youngster entering the realm of politics dominated mostly by fake degree holders, I would've expected a shift from realpolitik and a more mature approach towards the teething issues Pakistan faces today rather than the usual lambasting of rival political parties.

Referring to PML-N, for example, Bilawal stated that PPP would defeat the ‘lion’ and that “the belly of the lion is filled with the blood of poor people!”

It seems as though populist politics in Pakistan  comes with the condition to verbally assault political rivals to establish supremacy. Living up to his Twitter persona of a born-with-a-golden-spoon college grad, Bilawal was determined to settle scores with long-time tsunami-swept rivals. He stated that PPP “will liberate the people from that storm,” and even pledged that his party was not ‘cowardly’ like the PTI.

The chairman's  remarks contradicted the party's official friendly opposition stance but we still expect PPP zealots desperately try to justify their Chairman's position, even if it makes zilch sense.

This is not new in personality-centered politics of Pakistan where an intellectual like Asad Umar of PTI has had to backtrack on his statements multiple times to appease party leadership.

Pakistan's political landscape has largely remained an oligarchy, with industrialists and feudal landlords ushered in with patronage of military rulers. However, now it seems to be slowly transforming and untangling itself from the stranglehold of a narrow power elite, which is heartening to see.

Bilawal and others of the clan should realise that their diatribes are now understood and debated upon in a completely different perspective, where rationality rules and sensationalism is out-ruled.

PPP's stance on extremism and rejecting terrorism has, beyond doubt,  always been unwavering. However, action and not mere jingoism can restore peace in the country. Zamurd Khan's heroism in Islamabad does not relieve PPP of its inability to draft an effective counter-terrorism policy in its 5 year rule. Banning telephone and internet services every now and then is not a long-term solution, and the 'pappu bachas' Bilawal refers to are not naive either.

Bilawal's uppity demeanour and outright ridicule of all rival parties smelled of feudal haughtiness.

Sporting Sindhi t-shirts and badmouthing rivals gets you a few re-tweets at the most, and alienates you from the rest of the country. We do not expect a 26-year-old to jump into policy making and constitutional reform, but a knowledge of the country's dynamics and a sense of entitlement for the country is the least we expect.

The sense of dynastic entitlement that has been dominating Pakistan's political culture is slowly diminishing and the youth of today no longer believes in political idol worship. This year's election outcome should have made it clear!
Jalal Awan The writer is a PhD candidate at the Pardee RAND Graduate School. His thoughts do not necessarily reflect those of the RAND Corporation, Pardee RAND, or RAND’s research sponsors. He tweets at @jalal_awan (https://twitter.com/jalal_awan)
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Abdul Rafay | 7 years ago | Reply although he did a very good script speech but how could we think that we choose a person who has lived his 98%time period in foreing country and he can understand the culture,affairs and thoughts and taste of pakistanez...he can`t be good sincere leader but he can be sincere popit and toy of our dynstic politician.....?
Abdul Rafay | 7 years ago | Reply although his speech was good but how could he understand the culture,thought and taste of pakistanezzz after he has lived his 95% life in foreign country. he can`t be a true and sensior leader but he can be a best popit and toy of our leader for dynstic politics
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ