CSS: When we allow cheats to be Civil Servants

Why should students in Faisalabad get a second chance to take the CSS exam? Why should cheats be glorified?

Sidra Sheikh June 07, 2013
In 2012, there were a total of 10,066 candidates who appeared for the Central Superior Services (CSS) written exam. Only 800 of these candidates managed to pass the test; in other words, just 7.95 % of the students who wrote the exam were successful.

These stats clearly show that passing the CSS is no piece of cake.

Thus, when the news broke that some of the students of Faisalabad center were given open access to sealed answer booklets and were helped by the GPO staff members, many were rightly appalled. It was discovered that the papers had been tampered with and some students had unfair advantage over others.

However, amidst the entire furore and vociferous demands of investigation, The Federal Public Service Commission (FPSC) has taken us by surprise by announcing that they will  re-examine the candidates of Faisalabad.

Why should cheats be given a second chance? Why shouldn't honest candidates be offered the same?

If re-examinations were to be held, they should be held across Pakistan otherwise it is unfair to those who get the golden opportunity to prepare for and re-take an exam they are already familiar with.

People are livid primarily because they had faith in the transparency, impartiality and exactitude of this examination.

What everyone expected here was the immediate detention of the culprits, banishment of the tricksters and a lesson so explicit that it could have served as a warning for the rest of the deviants.

The CSS is an exasperating journey; it is said to be an exam of nerves, and rightly so, as the aspirants are made to take two exams in a single day! The mental and physical strain far surpasses that of any other exam, and only if a candidate is able to curb and control this anxiety, he/she will go to the next step of the ladder.

The second test is that of patience. Once a contender has written the exam, he/she is forced to forget about the results. The exams are usually conducted in the month of February or March, but the announcement of result takes up to 6-8 months and till then the aspirants keep on playing the game of probabilities and chances.

The next test that follows involves an even higher degree of trepidation; it is the declaration of the written result when the proud and triumphant candidates are given an interview call but they never get to know their score in the written part, so they stay engaged in a blind match where they are usually shocked with their cumulative score, that too at the end of about a year and a half of waiting.

Most of them are left with no way but to start from scratch.

It is a highly competitive examination that decides the bureaucracy of this country and makes up factions of those who become strategists and ambassadors of this nation.

After the conception of Pakistan in 1947, the term ‘Central Superior Services (CSS)’ was accredited to these services. The Central Services included the Pakistan Foreign Service and a broad category of Finance and other services. The Finance category included the Pakistan Audit and Accounts Service, Pakistan Railway Accounts Service, Pakistan Military Accounts Service, Pakistan Taxation Service and the Pakistan Customs and Excise Service.

The Central Services, other than these, included the Pakistan Postal Service, Pakistan Military Land and Cantonment Service, Central Secretariat Service, and Central Information Service.

Do we really want cheats to be on this list?

I urge the FPSC to ponder upon its decision and take stricter action.

Follow Sidra on Twitter @sidraSheikh1
Sidra Sheikh A pro-modernization but anti-westernization educationist whose sole aim is to enlighten minds. Currently working as a corporate relations officer. She is also a CSS aspirant, a coffee addict and a bibliophilic.
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


salman qureshi | 7 years ago | Reply thats the reason the bureaucracy is the big evil of this country.....
A. Khan | 10 years ago | Reply What hope is there for a country where people aspire to do CSS and become a Customs Inspector or join Income Tax, as their primary choices. These people should be straight away rejected as their intentions are not noble but greed is driving them. No wonder this country has gone down the hole.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ