Hamza Ahmed and the urban feudalism in Karachi

It is tragic when power is given in the hands of 16-year-old boys whose minds are still foaming with hormones.

Maheen Usmani April 30, 2013
Karachi gives off a palpable sense of fear which stems not just from menacing robbers, kidnappers and terrorists, but also from haphazardly driven tinted four wheelers by boys with a plethora of armed guards at their beck and call.

What is this worrying trend of urban feudalism in cosmopolitan Karachi?

The nexus between power, money and brutality in Pakistan is nowhere as evident as in the crass behaviour of these pampered youngsters.

A friend visited a designer’s house in Defence where she was introduced to her smiling teenage sons. After leaving the place, the friend’s car was nearly pushed off the main road by a menacing black Pajero with tinted glasses which bore down on her out of nowhere, with engine at full throttle and guards with guns pointed. Her driver had to swerve to avoid being hit. Shaken, she asked the driver who on earth these rascals were, only to be told that they were the very same kids she had greeted half an hour back.

Khayaban-e-Ittehad bears witness to many a traffic jam as Karachi groans at the seams with creaking infrastructure and an expanding population. On one such day, a young boy in a Land Cruiser came from the opposite direction on a one way road, nearly hitting a car or two en route and raced away.

On Karachi’s major arteries, ubiquitous four wheelers of government ministers with party flags displayed prominently like a badge of honour straddle the road with stony faced moustachioed guards holding guns held between their legs or pointed at hapless cars as they attempt to navigate around them or fall into line.

The mantra is,
 “Oh ji, yeh Pakistan hai, yahan sab kuch chalta hai!

(This is Pakistan, you can get away with anything here!)

This VIP culture has now permeated to the urban elite who are modelling themselves on the “might is right” mindset. The kind of education many of these kids are imbibing in the laps of their clueless parents is that no one is more important than them.

Other people are like ants, easy to mow down, if they come in your way. Youth is a time for adrenaline and quick spurts of anger. Surely it is the job of parents to guide them through this maze of hormones? Whither conflict resolution, anger management and effective communication?

Are these kids taught about the virtues of patience, community service, charity and empathy with those for whom every day is a struggle?

When Shias are getting daily butchered in Karachi, but the only concern of many well to do mothers is “Goodness, where will my kids hang out now that Dolmen’s has had that kidnapping attempt? Where will I send them to chill?”, then what kind of empathy or compassion for other people can we expect from their offspring?

Recently, 16-year-old Hamza Ahmed was allegedly gunned down by his friend Shoaib’s guard over an alleged girlfriend issue. Hamza’s friends, who had accompanied him, said Shoaib ordered his guard to shoot Hamza. Shoaib’s family says that the guard fired of his own volition, because he did not want to see Shoaib insulted. The guard, who shot Hamza four times at point blank range, was hired from a security agency and was thus not a wadera’s lackey. Why then would he kill a young kid in cold blood?

In Pakistan, lest we forget, the hired underlings are at the lowest rung of the ladder and are the puppets of their masters. The tragedy is when such power is given in the hands of 16-year-old boys who may be on the cusp of adulthood, but whose minds are still foaming with hormones. Naturally, the guard, who is an ex Pakistan Army soldier, is on the run while Shoaib’s father protests his son’s innocence.

Instead of looking seriously at the issues brought bobbing to the surface in the murky waters of the fabric of our society, people have seen it fit to be self righteous and point fingers at Hamza’s “westernised” ways. Western values are not distorting the minds of youngsters here.

Instead, it’s the prevalence of guns and the sweeping under the carpet of the peccadilloes of rich kids by their doting parents. When it needs a Supreme Court suo moto notice to nab Shahzeb Khan’s killer who was spirited away by his influential family to Dubai and whose trial is still in limbo after constant changing of statements by witnesses; when a killing car at Boat Basin can take a couple of  lives in a drunken stupor and it’s teenage driver is whisked away abroad in the blink of an eye by his industrialist father; when kids at elite schools think it’s kosher to rob or kidnap just to have a cool lifestyle and keep up with the Joneses, then there is something very rotten in the state of Denmark.

If we are being judged by the cars we drive, the handbags we carry and the designer ensembles we sport, it means that our society is not being corrupted by the West, but we have allowed materialism to erode our respect for others less privileged. In case we forget, there is respect for rule of law and other people in the West and there is accountability.

In Pakistan, the moneyed and the powerful pulverise others to get ahead, secure in the knowledge that they can get away with murder. The tragedy is that they do. And now these very same corrupted values have taken seed in the minds of their kids.

Read more by Maheen here or follow her on Twitter @MaheenUsmani
Maheen Usmani A freelance writer who has covered subjects ranging from socio-political issues to women's rights to counter terrorism, sports, travel, culture and music. Maheen tweets @MaheenUsmani (https://twitter.com/MaheenUsmani)
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Mutual Friend | 11 years ago | Reply Hi, Im a friend of Shoaibs and of the late Hamza, and you really need to get your story straight and not go on hearsay! You say in your article: "Hamza’s friends, who had accompanied him, said Shoaib ordered his guard to shoot Hamza. Shoaib’s family says that the guard fired of his own volition, because he did not want to see Shoaib insulted. The guard, who shot Hamza four times at point blank range, was hired from a security agency and was thus not a wadera’s lackey. Why then would he kill a young kid in cold blood?" You say that witnesses state that Shoaib ordered the guard to fire. That is completely inaccurate. The police issued a statement to the press and stated that all the witnesses including Hamza's friend and one witness who was a mutual friend of both say that Shoaib did not order the guard to fire. Please get the facts! As to why the guard shot Hamza no one can be sure till he is found but WITNESSES, REAL WITNESSES say that the guard yes started off because he did not like the client of his security company slapped BUT Hamza then got into a fight with the guard. After that he lost control and held a gun to his head to "intimidate" him. When he did that Hamza is reported to have said, reported by WITNESSES to have put the gun down to his chest and said "mar ke dekhao goli" The guard acted on impulse and fired. The police in the statement ALSO said that the ballistics report claims the gun to be such that it fires in bursts. Not a bullet at a time hence there being four bullets involved in this shooting and not one. So please, kindly refrain from calling another 16 year old child a murderer when you clearly do not even know what happened. No point in assuming that all rich kids are spoilt and like to throw their weight around. Today Shoaib is lamenting in jail for a crime he did not commit. Is that justice? How come no one is talking about that in the media.
Sick of these punk youngsters | 11 years ago | Reply Maheen, this is a very good piece and you are spot on. Giving all these armed guards to young hothead teenagers is simply shocking. I saw this phenomenon rise during my days as a teenager in pakistan and it has gotten worse. These kids just have poor parenting - their parents do not teach them proper values. instead, they equip them with armed guards and fancy cars with carte blanche to do anything. Shocking! Thanks for this piece.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ