Can masjids and laboratories co-exist?

Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy, Isolating science and religion is one way, but what if one believes in both?

Sarah Munir November 05, 2012
At a small gathering of students and science enthusiasts in Karachi, Pervez Hoodbhoy was asked why he lost his temper at Agha Waqar- the scientist who claims he can successfully run a car engine on water.

Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy responded that nothing irked him more than bad physics. He went on to say that we had become so disgruntled as a society, that we were constantly looking for short cuts and miracles to solve our problems. And he was completely justified in making that claim. Very few, if any can question Dr Hoodbhoy’s work and consequentially his authority on the subject.

He later made a statement saying that science and religion cannot go together. If both were allowed to function in isolation, without constantly seeking Divine truths in science and vice versa, it would save our society a lot of trouble. To me, that seemed like a short cut in understanding religion.

The debate between the incompatibility of science and religion is not a new one. And it is certainly not an easy one either. There are extremes. One extreme believes in discarding everything, which cannot be explained by religious principles and truths. The other extreme believes in discarding everything that cannot be explained by logic, reason and a scientific method. Both these extremes are becoming increasingly prevalent because extremes are easy. What we tend to forget is that, they are also exclusionary of other viewpoints. It is finding a middle ground, a meeting point between faith and logic, a union of miracle and discovery, a consensus of science and theology, which is the main challenge in our society. It is unfortunately also missing from our academic and public discourse.

Yes, isolating science and religion is one way of doing things. But what if one is a believer of both? Is it necessary to pick sides?

One look at Islamic history will tell you otherwise. In the words of the famous scholar Ziauddin Sardar, "Muslims have been on the verge of physical, cultural and intellectual extinction simply because they have allowed parochialism and traditionalism to rule their minds." The solution he suggests is to break free from the ‘ghetto mentality.’ The problem with our society today is just that  - we have lost the courage or spirit to extract the real essence of Islam from the version that we see being practised around us today. We shun the ‘West’ and their methods but at the same time have become lazy and unwilling to form our own unique world-view. A world-view that allows us to evolve, to look ahead and embrace the challenges of the modern world without loosing grips on our history and Islamic principles.

Instead we turn to quick fixes and easy solutions. We dabble between extremism and escapism.

Unfortunately, a look at our history will tell you that it has not helped us become better at neither religion nor science. Not only has Muslim civilization watched from the sidelines while the rest of the world made exponential progress in scientific realms, we have also lost the essence of our religion to militants and extremists who have now become the poster-children of Muslim identity globally. In this tug of war between the ‘Islamists’ and the ‘liberals’, we have forgone the opportunity to produce thousands of potential Ibn-e-Sinas.

Something needs to be done to end this polarisation of faith and reason, which begins at academics and eventually seeps into every aspect of our lives. Something needs to be done soon before the path to the masjid and the path to laboratories become mutually exclusive of each other. And the first step towards achieving that would be to stop propagating and endorsing short cuts in both science and religion.

[poll id="226"]

Read more by Sarah here or follow her on Twitter @sarahmunir1
Sarah Munir A graduate from the Columbia Journalism School and is currently heading the Magazine Desk at The Express Tribune. She tweets @SarahMunir1 (
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


ashfaq | 11 years ago | Reply @Anthony Permal: please read a book by a french scientist Maurice Bucaille . may be in your religion you have doubt but if you read islam. you will definitley find the right way. or watch dr zakir naik videos
ashfaq | 11 years ago | Reply @p r sharma: no you are totally wrong . may be questioning religion be frobidden in your religion. you can always ask question about islam. but making statements with out knowing islam is not the right thing. you can read a book on islam and science by Maurice Bucaille (french scientist) hope then your mind will be clear or can ask question about islam from a real islamic scholar like zakir naik, ahmad deedat etc or watch videos on yoouytube Mr i think you do not know much about religion. you should comment then if you did not get the answer about the religion from a good real religious scholar. you are blindly following people such as hoodbhoy i know him much than you. you should watch videos of scholars like zakir naik, diddat, etc . also read a book by a french scientist brocellori (name could be a bit wrong) , i think if you read with out prejudice thinking you will got so many answers.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ