Say no to Salim!

Besides Sachin Tendulkar, no one mastered Shane Warne the way Salim Malik did. But we don't want him back!

Umair Qazi November 02, 2012
The man was an artist. I think he was one of the shrewdest minds to have played the game; one of the smartest batsmen ever; a man who made batting look like art.

Besides Sachin Tendulkar, no one mastered Shane Warne the way Salim Malik did. His 237 runs against Australia in Rawalpindi in 1994 still remain one of the finest knocks by a captain. The score is the second highest score, behind Wally Hammond's 240 runs, by a captain against Australia. Malik's 92 runs average, in Tests that he captained against Australia is still the highest average amongst captains in Tests against Australia.

Moreover, Malik's record as Pakistan's captain is exceptional with a Test win percentage of 58.33%, which is only bettered by Waqar Younis and Rashid Latif. While his ODI win percentage of 64.7% is also one of the highest amongst Pakistan captains topped only by Intikhab Alam, in three matches, and Shoaib Malik, majority against minnows.

But all these reasons are not why I believe that Salim Malik was an artist or the shrewdest batsman to have played the game.

It is because of his single handed ability to dictate terms on the pitch, direct an entire innings, and orchestrate the outcome of a match. Salim Malik was impeccable. Typically batting at number four or five, Malik would more often than not score a healthy 40 to 50 runs or even higher than that.

He was even more efficient in chases. While Malik was at the crease, Pakistan always remained at par with the required run rate; at times above it, but never really too far below it. He would ensure that he batted for a good part of Pakistan's innings, scored at a reasonable rate, and hogged the strike while stealing singles of the last ball of every over. It was as if he was toying with the opposition's bowlers and fielders.

Little did anyone know that he was toying with his own team.

During the course of his well grafted innings, Malik always ensured that he got at least one batsman run out. He also skilfully ensured that the batsman at the other end took over the responsibility to get quick runs, while he remained at the crease saving his wicket for the end. Since he was captain and also the senior most members of the side, he easily demanded that.

While Malik would continue with his knock, batsmen at the other end would perish while trying to up the tempo, or would get run out due to calculated calls made by Malik. He would continue to bat till most of the batsmen were back in the pavilion, and with a 50 odd runs still remaining; he would also throw his wicket away leaving the task of finishing the game on the tail enders.

He did this repeatedly over a period of three to four years in the mid 90s.

Salim Malik was the best orchestrator of a loss the game of cricket has ever seen. He was a true artist who had perfected the art of batting and controlling an innings. The game has yet to see someone like Salim Malik.

And now he wants to become the coach of the Pakistan national team. I can't help but think what that would do to the extremely talented batsmen that are Pakistan's future. Azhar Ali, Asad Shafiq, Umar Akmal, and Nasir Jamshed definitely require grooming, but do we really want them to be coached by Salim Malik?

Do we want more selfish players? Do we want batsmen who master the art of losing games for Pakistan?

Definitely not!

There is absolutely no reason why the PCB should pay any heed to the application put forward by Salim Malik.

Keep him away please!

Follow Umair on Twitter @WellPitched

The original version of this post can be seen here.
Umair Qazi An investment advisor in Dubai who blogs at and tweets @WellPitched
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Dr. Asad Sadick, Germany | 11 years ago | Reply If he can deliver why not. First get rid of Zardari who has put your country in a FIX.
Babar | 11 years ago | Reply I read the first line and it made me realise that you need to work on your analysis a bit more. How can you forget Lara let alone KP.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ