Is Sur Kshetra in line with Aman Ki Asha or is it just Atif vs Asha?

Sur Kshetra may be getting high ratings but the clashes on the show are causing hatred to grow among the two nations.

Roshanay Asif Sheikh October 23, 2012
Lights, camera, action!

The music starts.
 "Fateh suron ki, jeet sangeet ki!"

(Triumph of melody, victory of music!)

Yes, you might have guessed that I'm talking about "Sur Kshetra", a music reality TV show where participants from India and Pakistan contest against each other. Each team brings six contestants from their respective countries to fight against each other in a singing competition. Their mentors are the sensational Atif Aslam (for team Pakistan) and Himesh Reshammiya (for team India).

The jury members consists of Abida Parveen from Pakistan, Asha Bhosle from India and Runa Laila from Bangladesh. Their job is to mark the contestants either with a zero or a ten.

Sounds tough, doesn’t it?

The promotional campaign of the show was huge and auditions were held in big cities of both the countries ─ Lahore, Islamabad and Karachi in Pakistan, and Mumbai, Kolkata, Lucknow, Indore and Delhi in India. The shooting was held in Dubai and now the show airs on weekends (Saturday and Sunday) on Geo TV at 9pm and Colours and Sahara TV at 7:30pm.

The basic idea of "Sur Kshetra" was to unite both nations by bringing them together on the similar platform. Since India and Pakistan have had great triumph in the music industry it is definitely a great idea to unite them to produce polished future artists.

Pakistani music has travelled a long way in India, with top-notch artists like Atif Aslam and Rahat Fateh Ali Khan often doing projects there, whilst India’s Bollywood playback singing is quite popular in Pakistan. With such accomplishments, one can expect a great show to be put up.

The design of the show appeared to be in line with "Aman ki Asha" which is a project started by two leading media houses; Jang group in Pakistan and Times of India in India. This venture aims to achieve peaceful and cordial relations between the two nations.

"Sur Kshetra" was supposedly supporting "Aman ki Asha", but has it really been doing this?

This is the fifth week of the show and viewers have observed elevated clashes between the two teams. We’ve hardly seen Atif Aslam praising an Indian contestant or Himesh Reshammiya finding a flaw in his team's performance.

Though it’s a show, and good and bad performances are inevitable, never has it happened that the two captains agreed on any decision. I believe that this disrupts the ambiance of the show.

Moreover, serious arguments are often witnessed between Atif Aslam and Himesh Reshammiya, and even Atif Aslam and Asha Bhosle. Not only this, but rumour has it that Asha Bhosle walked out and expressed the 'do or die' concern that either she or Atif will remain on the show.

I understand that much of the content is scripted on these reality shows so could it be that these conflicts and arguments are scripted, too?

The audience does need masala otherwise the show will be considered boring. "Sur Kshetra" is surely fulfilling that criterion, but it could adversely affect Atif Aslam’s popularity in India since his Indian fans might deem his attitude as biased towards Pakistan.

In addition to this, there is growing dislike for Asha Bhosle and Himesh Reshammiya in Pakistan now as our audience thinks that they are unfair toward Pakistani contestants.

Furthermore, on "Sur Kshetra’s" official Facebook page, Pakistanis and Indians are fighting over the show and abusing each other. One person said, and I quote,
“I watched this show for the first time this weekend. All I saw was hatred, taunts, and biased behaviour towards each other. I will not watch it again. This is a hate-preaching programme. I think it was disgusting. Even the most senior member of the jury, Asha Bhosle, was passing on indirect taunts at Atif Aslam and vice versa. No one was better than the other.”

I do believe that if harmony between the two nations is what the show was going for, it is failing miserably!

Atif Aslam, on his Jazba Generation tour press conference on September 28, 2012, was asked about his attitude on the show and the response he is getting regarding it. He replied saying that when he goes to India, he has to represent the whole country and thus, has to behave and judge with neutrality because at the end of the day, it’s all about Pakistan’s impression. Nonetheless, it is less likely that either of the captains will ever judge neutrally.

A contestant of Sur Kshetra said,
“Atif Aslam supported us in every way. He never let anyone say anything against Pakistan or us.”

Well, that makes him a great mentor, all right. But the question remains: Is "Sur Kshetra" supporting "Aman Ki Asha" or is it simply deepening an already profound divide between the two nations?

Follow Roshanay on Twitter @RoshanaySheikh 

[poll id="221"]

Roshanay Asif Sheikh A student, a social activist, a writer and a debater, Roshanay tweets as @RoshanaySheikh
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


sc | 11 years ago | Reply the whole show is such a shame. already there is a lot of tension between india and pakistan. nothing can ever make things right between these 2 countries. the producers are not doing anything good either. they are simply just bringing the hatred between the two countries on national television for the whole world to see. atif aslam should be kicked out of the show. he should be ashmed.
mysore gopalarao | 11 years ago | Reply if it is not for merit why have it?the audience is not fools to feel the totally biased opinions of does not depend on what planned teqnical reasons they give. what.people feel from their heart matters.not who sings whose god etc.,if i say some dud is good fast bowler than imran khan as he is from our place?here it is open for all to see the truth in open.if sara sings for indian films unidentified she will impress above all .neutral judges not possible here nor world competition.but it is useful in exposing .learn from the majesty of runa laila.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ