Sialkot lynching: Roots of extremism run deep

With popular religious opinion by people's side, perpetrators found good reason for subjecting the two "filthy dakoos" to sanctioned justice.

Asadullah Qureshi August 22, 2010
I first heard the news on Facebook - I caught a friend ranting about a video of two boys in Sialkot getting brutally beaten to death in my feed. The internet has done its fair share of damage to most people's minds morbid curiosity drove me to see what the video was about. It wasn't exactly hard to find since violence has the potential for instantly going viral on the net.

The video depicts two kids getting beaten up by almost everyone that could fit into the view of the camera. Around the end, there is even what appears to be a 9-year-old child, who takes a shot at one of the wounded bodies. The video itself did not really affect me but what I found most disgusting is the train of thought that led to an instance of brutality that would put all of Fred Vogel's filmography to shame.

Apparently, the two boys in question had gotten into a fight over a cricket match the previous day and just as they were headed out for another match after Sehri the following day, they were ambushed and once the townsfolk and the police noticed, the perpetrators blamed them for theft so they could get out of it. The police and townsfolk, in a fit of moralistic glory, decided they would let it continue and join in. The video probably originates from one of those knights of morality.

It is not hard to make random generalizations about the whole of mankind and philosphise that humanity has breached yet another boundary seeing how most people reacted to the video. Right there in the comments section on both Youtube and Facebook, I could see people questioning things like whether Pakistan deserved independence at all. Some people went as far as to chalk the recent floods up to our alleged immorality.

Although, I will refrain from making any meta-narratives out of this myself, I will say this; the video really does put things like the recent bombing of the Ahmadi mosque in Lahore and the tide of religious violence in Southern Punjab into perspective for us. We have  always been quick to ostracise anyone that demonstrates the weakness of our perfect little world and branding the perpetrators animals will not solve anything. We need to own up to the fact that the perpetrators arose from amongst us.

As I mention earlier, we must consider the train of thought that led to the incident. With the media projecting on to people that all hell has broken loose and that there is no law, it is not surprising that people would react this way. The conduct and the subsequent images of the police does little to help things, of course. With popular religious opinion by people's side, I think the perpetrators found good reason for subjecting the two "filthy dakoos" to divinely sanctioned justice. After all is said and done, as long as a majority of the country, willingly or unwillingly, shuns reason in favour of this extremist sense of morality and justice, it is likely we will see such a tragedy again.
Asadullah Qureshi A student who plays for metal band, Berserker and blogs at The Iron Markhor.
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


muyyu | 13 years ago | Reply I did not say that Indonesia has such a law, but that it's moving in that direction starting with its province of Banda Aceh, please check it up. And you are right, Saudi Arabia follows Islamic Sharia more closely than any other country and because of this stoning to death IS there in its books. However it has not actually enforced this, as saudi is the US puppet & the US will not allow this. And for the person who spoke about the requirement for 4 witnesses, are they still required if the woman falls pregnant? The issue is not whether all Islamic countries have such a law or not but that there is such a law in Islam and countries which faithfully adhere to sharia (as they should) will end up brutalizing their populace.
Allah Ditta | 13 years ago | Reply This incident same like wild animal.i deeply heart it.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ