It’s the law, stupid!

The premier's sentence was symbolic; the court has now left further dialogue to take place in the political arena.

Hassan Khan April 29, 2012
Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani’s conviction for refusing to reopen a corruption investigation against the president consequently made him the first serving prime minister in Pakistan’s history to be convicted by a court.

In a country like Pakistan, the list of firsts seems never ending. Regrettably, most firsts don’t give our people an opportunity to gloat. And yet yesterday, the Supreme Court gave us a first we can, or let me rephrase, we should take pride in.

Some would question my assertion of believing that we have good reason to revel in our prime minister’s conviction. But this is bigger than that. This is not about a ruling party that is widely perceived as corrupt and unpopular, it’s not about the government allegedly conspiring against the military establishment, it’s not about the president’s immunity and nor is it about a conspiracy to derail democracy.

It is though only about the rule of law – the foundation for both our liberties and for order. If anything, the court should be applauded yesterday for showing restraint in the premier’s sentence, which was detention lasting no longer than a minute until the session was adjourned.

It was symbolic. If anything, the court has now left further dialogue to take place in the political arena. In the face of adversity, primarily due to being accused of attempting to overreach its jurisdiction and derailing democracy, the court has served its primary function in a constitutional democracy by protecting the constitution and essentially left the punitive aspects of the case to others: the parliament, the media, the opposition leaders.

Whether the prime minister turned the contempt case from ‘catastrophe to triumph’ yesterday should not be in question in regards to the court’s orders.

Quite to the contrary in fact, the only question that should be raised is whether the judiciary has protected its constitution and subsequently preserved the nation’s respect while the entire world is watching. Not the premier.

And to that, I gloat endlessly as the supreme law of the land has triumphed.

Read more by Hassaan here.

Hassan Khan The writer holds a BA in political science from the University of California, Santa Barbara and is a sub-editor at The Express Tribune
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


yousaf | 12 years ago | Reply Last line of the article is where supreme court has given real meanings to the word HOPE.God bless the "land of the pure"
Umer | 12 years ago | Reply @Karachiwala: This question goes to the heart of the issue ie whether justice is being served or is it just a political game being played by players behind the scene to eliminate non pro-establishment forces as has been the case in the past. If worst crimes are ignored by a judiciary then this can hardly be considered justice and supporters of such judiciary are not in any position to dispense moral sermons to anyone.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ