Agent Vinod: Another sign of Pak-India tensions?

Whatever the reasons for Pakistan’s decision to ban Agent Vinod, we will have to wait to see what the fuss is about.

Tom Wright March 21, 2012
This post was originally published on the Wall Street Journal. To read more by Tom Wright, click here. 


Showing a Pakistani army general watching a courtesan dancing? Using shots of Karachi airport without permission? Or generally portraying Pakistan in a bad light?

Whatever the reasons for Pakistan’s decision to ban Agent Vinod, the latest Khan-Kapoor offering, most of us will have to wait for Friday to see what the fuss is about.


If earlier bans are anything to go by, it’s probably a storm in a teacup, more indicative of the parlous state of India-Pakistan relations than the content of what looks to be a pretty lightweight action flick.

An officer from Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence Directorate military spy agency said he had no knowledge of the ban, reported widely by Indian media today. He denied there was a military  intelligence presence on Pakistan’s film censorship body, as reported by the Indian media.

Despite mistrust of India, many Pakistanis love Bollywood and billboards across the country feature the big Indian stars. Yet scores of films from India get banned each year, including Dirty Picture (too lewd), Tere Bin Laden (might annoy Islamists) and now Agent Vinod (unclear).

One could guess (admittedly without yet seeing the film) that Agent Vinod likely caricatures Pakistan in some way or other (Ms Kapoor plays a Pakistani in the film).

On the other hand, it’s equally likely that Pakistan’s censor board is too prickly about these things. Tere Bin Laden, an oddball comedy which starred Pakistani singer-turned actor Ali Zafar, was widely praised by critics. The ban in Pakistan looked like kowtowing to extremists.

Criticism of the armed forces is off-limits in Pakistan. Last year, the military itself produced a drama called “Beyond the Call of Duty,” which featured real soldiers and saccharine story lines about Pakistan’s war against the Taliban.

Agent Vinod apparently doesn’t follow that script.



[poll id="131"]
Tom Wright A WSJ reporter covering South Asia, mainly India, Pakistan and Kashmir. Tom tweets @TomWrightAsia.
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


The Real Reason of Banning | 10 years ago | Reply Extremely stupid movie actually its a conspiracy theory one. The plot ends with the some j/g/geo/jew group wanting war between India and Pakistan, its good that Pakistanis don't watch it they are already bugged by such theories an Indian movie doing that would be like..huh even some Indians have finally awakened..
s | 10 years ago | Reply its good this movie is banned and all other bollywood movies and channels should be banned too!! Indians please go comment on your own news paper (no rudeness intended). You are only spreading hatred!
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ