Learning a lesson in Khairpur

No amount of theory can prepare one for the real deal - closed schools, girls pulled out of school, or trying to convince men that education will not impact values.

Morial Shah August 11, 2010
Empty classrooms, vacant desks, books unopened and lessons not learnt – Khairpur’s schools are screaming for attention. Interning with some local NGOs gave me the opportunity to visit and compile a report about girls’ schools in Khairpur Mir.

I was struck, in a harrowing way, by what I saw.

When most people think about the state of education, especially female education in rural areas, a gloomy picture comes to mind. Let’s just say that I wasn’t expecting everything to be hunky dory either. I had gleaned enough details about ghost schools, absenteeism, and general dissatisfaction with government schools. But no amount of theory can actually prepare one for the real deal – seeing closed government schools, meeting young girls pulled out of school, or trying to convince gentlemen with a religious bend that sending girls to school doesn’t compromise religious or traditional values.

Whose territory is this school on?

My conversations with community members and students helped to shed light on several problems. In all interactions with members of rural communities, the first issue raised was territorial. An intrusion of people from other villages, especially people from other clans, threatens social fabric. I was taken aback by how important a tiny thing like that can be. Allah Warrayo, the wada (elder) of 70 houses of mithari, specified that none of the teachers, or doctors for the clinic should be from another clan. But here’s the problem: no girl in his clan had schooling beyond fifth grade. Nevertheless, Warrayo remained adamant on this point as he painstakingly explained the way an inter-clan marriage between a girl from his Metalo clan, and boy from the Kalhora family, ignited a controversy over land distribution which spawned into an inter-family feud claiming 13 lives.

Why should she go to school?

The second problem seemed to be the lack of tangible incentives and poor marketing. Warrayo thought that paying for his sons’ education in the city was a worthless expense. Both were engineers – but jobless - and so they were tending to his family’s farms. Although he neither expected, nor wanted any financial benefits from educating his daughter (he baulked at the idea of her working), he felt that having some incentives such as teaching girls to stitch, cook, or learn about basic healthcare would improve attendance rates.

What if she writes love letters?

Syed Mohammad, a father of two girls studying at Sobhodero’s Model School voiced similar concerns. He said that while the more urbane people in Sobhodero welcomed the idea of women’s education, a common, and absurd, argument put forward by detractors was that learning to write would enable girls to write notes to boys, and in typical Bollywood fashion, elope. To me, this strange rendition seemed to belie the latent fears about girls thinking for themselves, marrying according to their choice, demanding their share in property and so, weakening the socio-economic power of their parents and exposing them to the possibility of receiving a taano (insult).

What the girls want

Interaction with students, my age or younger, left me stunned. Some girls surprised me with their resilience, fortitude and spirit, and others with their docility and lack of drive. Aspiring astronauts like thirteen year old Ameerzadi were juxtaposed with submissive Zareen highlighting a glass that was both, half-full and half-empty - a few girls were willing to fight social pressures and go to school, but others found school boring and irrelevant.

More disturbingly, I was introduced to ubiquitous cheating trends. I met high achieving chemistry students, from Khairpur’s best, and most expensive, private schools who had never seen the periodic table, and couldn’t explain the difference between atoms and molecules to me - underscoring the way cheating kills the purpose of investing into schooling these kids.

Through the days I spent in the field, one thing was clear. Until underlying socio-economic problems, local politics, obscurantist propaganda and cheating trends continue, efforts to recuperate Sindh’s lost generation will be futile.
Morial Shah A student of International Politics and Security at the Walsh School of Foreign Service, Georgetown University She tweets at @MoruShah.
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


zainabedi | 13 years ago | Reply Its dilemma of our nation and our time that we are not sincere with our country and moreover the purpose of our creation. Khairpur was considered an intellectual state as far as education was concerned in Mirs era. Now no leadership and no pride in oneself has destroyed the infrastructure and progressive thoughts among people. God bless us and give wisdom to leaders and nation both.
Sarah B. Haider | 13 years ago | Reply Cheating is surely prevalent all over the country, but i have seen people coming from Lahore all the way to Jamshoro to appear in their exams to get a degree without having to go through the 'hassles' of studying. Cheating is common in Quetta too, but not as openly as in Hyderabad as I have spent quite sometime working for educational institutions in both the cities. Perhaps the scenario is worse elsewhere too, but I have observed that Sindh is more popular for its cheating trends.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ