Pakistan's animosity reducing, India needs to change attitude: Aiyar

There is a belief that since Pakistanis have been hostile in the past, they are necessarily hostile now, says Aiyar.


Afp June 04, 2013
Indian MP Mani Shankar Aiyar speaks at the Atlantic Council in Washington on June 3, 2013. PHOTO: AFP

WASHINGTON: A senior lawmaker from India's ruling Congress party said Monday that Pakistan's historic animosity toward New Delhi was fading and called for his country to change its own attitudes.

Mani Shankar Aiyar, a diplomat turned politician known for his dovish views, said he saw a shift as Pakistanis who remember the subcontinent's partition in 1947 – and defined their identity accordingly –grew older.

Aiyar, speaking on a visit to Washington, said that Pakistanis had increasingly suffered themselves from violence by extremists and that the neighbouring country had economic and cultural interests in better ties.

"The visceral anti-Indianism of a previous generation is almost out of the picture now and will be totally out of the picture about the time that they lower me into the grave," Aiyar, 72, said at the Atlantic Council think tank.

Aiyar said that "nothing similar has happened in India," which has fought three full-fledged wars against its neighbor since independence.

"There is a kind of clinging to the belief that since the Pakistanis have been hostile in the past, they are necessarily hostile now, and therefore Indians should behave like housewives who heard on the radio that a convict has escaped for the nearby jail and start putting up more and more barricades."

His optimism comes despite concerns by India and the United States over extremist groups in Pakistan such as Lashkar-e-Taiba, which investigators blamed for the November 2008 siege of Mumbai that killed 166 people.

Aiyar, who was close to slain former prime minister Rajiv Gandhi, said that India should pursue "uninterrupted and uninterruptible" dialogue with Pakistan to deprive extremists of one perceived benefit of launching attacks.

Aiyar praised overtures by Pakistan's incoming prime minister Nawaz Sharif, while conceding that Sharif's record on anti-India violence "is not a very happy one" during his previous two stints in office.

But Aiyar said that Sharif apparently believed that building a better relationship with India "will pay him huge domestic political dividends."

Sharif likely sees "that the best way of doing this is not to take the Lashkar-e-Taiba on absolutely upfront, but to try and restrain them" and stop support to the group from within the Pakistani state, Aiyar said.

COMMENTS (52)

Mohsin | 11 years ago | Reply

@Naresh:

I gave you a lengthy answer wich probably got sensured. But ill try again.

Youre questions are legitimate. The main point is: Many pakistanis look up to India. But that does not change the fact that people are more equal in PK compared to India. The rich are more settled and stable in India compared to PK. That means our rich, clever and famous seeks an audience and facilities more suited for them. The one that is not fully functinal in PK yet. India has a bigger heritage, It has more history and it has had many institutes running long before Pk became a country. India has come so far that they can think in long terms while many in Pakistan think short term profit. Also the fankars go whereever theyre are liked. They have no boundries. Sadly many indian fankars dont visit their fans in Pk cause of political pressure.

Vivek | 11 years ago | Reply

@mohsin

Who is talking about the army here ? Read the whole material again and come back.

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ