Must Indian films be shelved for local box office success?

Published: May 13, 2013

Censor board seems to be shielding local films by banning those across the border when a release coincides. DESIGN: SAMRA AAMIR

KARACHI: 

Pakistan’s first political film Chambaili did smooth business, scoring back-to-back housefuls even with pre-election violence in several parts of the country. What made it garner such revenue? Was it the expansive marketing strategy, with trailers frequenting television screens, or was it the apt release date of the film, during the pre-election buzz that roped people in?

“People have always underestimated the local audience’s passion for cinema,” well-known film critic and box office analyst Nawab Huzurul Hasan Siddique tells The Express Tribune. “Whether the roads are flooded with water or there is a strike in the city, hordes of people come to watch films and there was a similar situation during the pre-election days.”

Siddique believes that people, especially Karachiites, have become so habituated to violence and uncertainty that they no longer think twice before stepping out for a film in volatile moments — unless an untoward incident takes place right before them. A testimony to this is the smooth sale of movie tickets for Chambaili, which was released at a time when shutter-down strikes and days of mourning were being observed. “Whenever cinemas were open in those days [strikes], the films screened — Chambaili and Aashiqui 2 — received housefuls,” says Siddique.

Analysing the box office success of Chambaili, the critic says that it performed above expectations wherever it was released. According to sources, the film had crossed the Rs20 million mark before the elections and managed to gross Rs4.5 million at Atrium Cinemas alone. The figures would have been higher had the screening of films not been suspended on Election Day.

Interestingly, the screening of Bollywood flick Aashiqui 2 alongside Chambaili proved fruitful for the latter. “Chambaili got a higher viewing because there were no seats available for Aashiqui 2. So people who would not get tickets to Aashiqui 2, would stay back to watch Chambaili instead,” explains Hassan. “As expected, the decision of releasing a local film with an Indian film helped the former and this trend will continue in multiplexes throughout the country.”

Aashiqui 2 did not harm Chambaili’s business prospects, but there is no assurance of a solid competition and constant business, primarily because only four Pakistani films will be released this Eid sans any Indian flick.

However, neither Siddique nor any other box office analyst is willing to compare Chambaili’s business with that of Bol, a film that grossed Rs110 million in Pakistan after running for more than 15 weeks. But if we look back, Bollywood actor Imran Khan-starrer Delhi Belly was banned in Pakistan when Bol was screened. Much similarly, Shootout at Wadala and Go Goa Gone have been banned for Chambaili.

Censor board’s covert support

Although this trend does not downplay the massive response Bol received, the dots are worth connecting, since the censor board’s role in prohibiting Indian films may not be clear in the case of Bol, but is pretty clear in with Chambaili.

The argument that the films are being banned owing to controversies — Shootout at Wadala is based on the downfall of Dawood Ibrahim, wanted in India for terror bids, and Go Goa Gone is rife with profane language — falls flat, because in the past, a film like OMG Oh My God! that questions blind faith and Emran Hashmi-starrer Raaz 3 with its racy scenes, made it to screens.

The noticeable trend of banning Indian films at the time of a Pakistani film release signifies an underlying intent of shielding the business of local films — an act which impedes healthy competition at the box office.

Published in The Express Tribune, May 14th, 2013.                    

Like Life & Style on Facebook for the latest in fashion, gossip and entertainment.

Reader Comments (9)

  • saad
    May 13, 2013 - 10:21PM

    yes i too was irritated with the ban on wadala and go goa gone,for the last one month,only aashiqui 2 and chambali have been running with oblivion,i was eagerly waiting for some new releases every friday,but no new movie was released,this is getting irritating now

    Recommend

  • Optimist
    May 14, 2013 - 2:39AM

    A baseless report.
    .
    Films were banned for the reasons mentioned in the last paragraph. There is hardly any film made that needs protecting! Mostly Pakistani films don’t even get cinemas. Bol and Chambaili were too good and that is why they got more audience than Indian films competing them.
    .
    You should criticise the censor board and encourage it to be more bold in allowing Indian films with topics that maybe taboo in Pakistan (Such as Dawood Ibrahim). Pakistan censor board even WRONGLY banned Tere Bin Laden. They are too scared to experiment with liberal topics, but the reason is not ‘business acumen’.
    .
    Criticise but don’t misinterpret the reasons. Pakistani govt and Censor board never cared about Lollywood.

    Recommend

  • Ashraf P
    May 14, 2013 - 8:13AM

    Are you crazy? Life will be unimaginable without Kareena and Katrina. If anything needs to be banned, it is violence. As the great Michael Jackson said, make love not war.

    Recommend

  • kray
    May 14, 2013 - 9:21AM

    it seems that this film has been a topic of negativity for you since the first day.

    Recommend

  • hasan
    May 14, 2013 - 10:38AM

    we continue to live in fear.. every industy in this coutnry is living in fear, either from chinese, indian, US, japanese… its fear everywhere. No country can progress from a point of fear and this is what is happening today…. we are sinking

    Recommend

  • King khan
    May 14, 2013 - 11:54AM

    One thing is for sure, pakistan fears compition, just competing in cricket is not enough, thats why lollywood is light years behind bollywood. fact!

    Recommend

  • Stranger
    May 14, 2013 - 12:53PM

    No. The more things you ban the more the contraband market will grow , the more pirated DVDs will grow.

    Recommend

  • May 22, 2013 - 12:13AM

    I have been reading only one, and persistant man, irritated with Chambaili, becuase I guess, his first review right after Karachi premiere (to whih he was somehow not invited) took it personally…. and wrote as negative as he could, and not that I am linked with the film, but his comments are biased, and not credible, as he’d be proved in the next days, and weeks (to this day as Chambaili continues to run in cinemas), and blatantly negate all that he wrote! I tend to agree above with the statement of one ” Optimist” above, ‘it seems that this film has been a topic of negativity for you since the first day’.

    I couldnt agree more. I wonder if the scribe has any personal issues with me (whom he does not know, or ever met), or Ismail Jilani (under whom he had indirectly worked before). But if he was such a prudent journalist, he should have had the courtesy to write our point of views as well, and should have then also had the moral courage to print those! However, I do rememebr having sent him a text after he had written the only ‘;negative’ review in entire Pakistan for a nascent newspaper like Tribue… and I did tell him, t\’time will prove’ wether his review holds true, or our film! I need not say more! :-)Recommend

  • May 22, 2013 - 12:18AM

    MY ONLY WISH FROM THIS NEW-JOURNALIST:

    As the writer, producer, production designer, art director, lyricist, publicist and strategist of the feature film CHAMBAILI, I feel that if only, instead of guessing, assuming, and wondering why CHAMBAILI has been a hit and resonnated with them poeple, if only he could shed his ego, and try and find out why and how it worked! It would be better journalism! He needs to understand that people in Pakistan are equally professionals, and smart! This film has had a hit status, and most critical acclaim, not by fluke… but by applying knowledge, heart & soul, science and craft!

    Recommend

More in Life & Style