- RSS
- Today's Paper
- Subscribe
- beta 2.1
Alerts
Rimsha's lawyer says medical report terms her as minor: Report
Lawyer says report investigating the age and mental state of the girl determined she was between 13 and 14.
Lawyer says report investigating the age and mental state of the girl determined she was between 13 and 14. PHOTO: ISRARUL HAQ/EXPESS/FILE
The lawyer contending the case of the arrest of a young girl from Islamabad on charges of blasphemy revealed that the medical report pronounced that the girl was a minor, reported Associated Press on Tuesday.
The girl, Rimsha, was arrested for allegedly burning a Noorani Quaida, a booklet used to familiarise children with Arabic as written in the Quran.
The lawyer, Tahir Naveed Chaudhry, said that the report by a medical board investigating the age and mental state of the girl determined she was between 13 and 14.
He said that this suggested that Pakistan’s juvenile court system will hear Rimsha’s case, which is generally more lenient toward defendants.
The lawyer revealed that the medical board’s report determined that her mental state did not correspond with her age. However, he said that it was “not clear whether that meant she was mentally impaired.”
Read more:
blasphemy
Reader Comments (37)
Pakistan Latest Stories
Sindh CM slot: For Qaim Ali Shah, third time may be the charm
PPP sources say loyalist Shah front runner for provincial top slot.
Language training: Chinese delegation visits NUML
Lin met NUML Rector Maj Gen (retd) Masood Hasan and DG Brig Azam Jamal.
Tragedy: Motorcyclist killed in head-on collision
Police have registered a case against the driver.
Crime: Taxi driver shot dead
The incident came to light when a local found the body in a Suzuki van in Thalla and informed the police.
Summer retreat: In Neelam Valley, guest houses brimming with activity
Approximate 0.5m tourists visited Neelam Valley last year including PML-N chief Nawaz Sharif.
Seminar: Experts call for macroeconomic stabilisation, economic growth
Discuss a pre-budget checklist for incoming government.
New Initiative: AAUR, Italian govt join hands for olive farming promotion
The move is aimed at producing enough olive oil to meet domestic demand and export quotas to foreign markets.
‘Mess at campus’: Staff at FUUST threaten to go on pen-down strike
Claim mismanagement, illegal appointments forcing them; admin cite embezzlement investigation.
Confusion: ‘Polio cell chief became victim of departmental scuffle’
Dr Bosan was unavailable for comment.
Measles strikes again: Fourteen cases reported in two days
Around 510 cases reported in Pindi district since Jan.
Recent Slideshows
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, redistributed or derived from.
Unless otherwise stated, all content is copyrighted © 2013 The Express Tribune News Network.
Technical feedback? [email protected]
Its a question of the girl not being a minor. Pakistani nation is a minor as far as ethics are concerned.
Recommend
The whole world is watching you on this.
Recommend
Thank you ET for highlighting this case consistantly and neutrally!
Pls continue that till the girl is released and her family is safe! PLEASE!
Recommend
I don’t know why non-muslims are abusing the holy books of muslims whereas muslims never abused books of other relegions.Recommend
A mob of adult muslim men attacking and beating up a defenseless child with Down syndrome.Is this what we have made islam into? Is this what we have reduced islam to? beating up mentally ill chidlren,how brave are our mujahideen now.This persecution of non-muslims at the hands of the 97% majority must stop.
Recommend
Thank you so much ET for this information hope it will silent many people.
Recommend
She is a kid…..must be released ASAP
Recommend
@Aryabhat:
Talking about minorities, what happened to the Indians that shot dead 2 Muslims on 16th July?? Were they arrested or not??
Recommend
RPEAL THE LAW regarding blashphemy in on strock and don’t establish Islam as an out dated religion any more .
Recommend
whether she’s a minor or adult should be judged based on Islamic law ie Shariah and not secular english common law.
Recommend
@Omar
This is Pakistan and the girl is Pakistani, go to India if you are so concerned about their issues.
Recommend
@Omar: How does comparing things to India make things better in Pakistan? Get a life, Pakistans sole goal isnt to be benchmarked against India. Just because something is happening in India does not justify things in Pakistan.
Recommend
@bangash
remember bamiyan buddha statues which were destroyed by taliban
Recommend
Ofcourse she is minor ! One does not need medical reports to verify the fact ! Stop wasting time and release her as its really showing up this Country in the World’s eyes as most ridiculous intolerent society full of hypocrates ! Recommend
Only enemies of Islam can support this sort of animal behavior. ANYBODY can go and beat a minor girl , try some body higher up
Recommend
Killers kill children and the rogues support them. that is all.
Recommend
Can we get a word from the girl herself? Wether she burned the Qaida intentionally or it was un intentional?
Recommend
@Omar: Omar Sahib, let us clean under our own MUNGI ( bed) Do we know who slaughtered and BEHEADED our very own Sheas in videos posted around the world?
Recommend
Your President, PM and virtually every major leader in Pakistan haven’t lifted a finger or made a public speech to defend this child. Shame on Pakistan.
Recommend
If 13 or 14 years girl had sense to pass religious differences and atrocities by burning Noorani Qaida on fire( Nauzbillah) then it means she is up to the state and isn’t child anymore.
Recommend
All these tests are just further humiliating and traumatizing her. Release her already and arrest the imam for inciting hate.
Recommend
Spare the kids plz. Everyone is reading this issue in the world. That’s all we have to share?
Recommend
Continue this comment colum open till the black law is intact ,Plz.
Recommend
@Bangash:
I do not think Ghauri and Ghaznvi were too bothered about books. I wonder if they were even literate.
Recommend
To all those saying RELEASE her:
Are you kidding? The girl is basically dead already. If she is released, then Muslim vigilanties are most assuredly going to track her down and murder her, and probably the rest of her family. This is a no-win situation for the poor girl and her family.Recommend
@Nand:
The whole world is also watching U.S Drones killing innocent civilians..
Recommend
Why this innocent girl will receive the wrath of clerics.Some month ago a person arrested for blasphemy has been forced out from custody by fanatics and beaten to death.We all pray to Allah this is not happened with the girl this time
Recommend
Just kill the baby inside prison. It is giving Pakistan a bad name. We are Muslim and do not have these oppressive laws, it is a propaganda! There is no Blasphemy law and none in prison!
Recommend
@Bangash. “I don’t know why non-muslims are abusing the holy books of muslims whereas muslims never abused books of other relegions.”
yup, pakistani muslims have time and time again proven that we are entirely peaceful people and have never done anything wrong or discriminatory in our lives. In fact does discrimination toward other religions even exist in our country? I mean, we are just innocent victims 24/7 right??
ps. there is no solid proof that she burnt anything..Recommend
Kill the girl once out of prison and for sure virgins they meet in heaven will be happy to offer them their services. These sick people are spoiling the name of Isalam. Pakistani brothers please speak up.
Recommend
Nayla
I am scared now. You’re possibly right. Ours is the society full of people with no sense of reasoning and logic. I am a muslim. I wish she stays safe from those ignorants.
Recommend
One word for people who want to prosecute and kill this girl. You will ALL burn in hellfire both in this world and the world after Inshallah.Recommend
Release this young girl and stop making islam look evil in the eyes of the world. Pakistan muslims you are shaming the ummah. Go and protest for her release.
Recommend
People here are forgetting that the blasphemy law is not shariah and in fact it was imposed by general zia. Have we not heard of the story of the people of taif and the holy prophet? There were so many who oppressed upon him but even when he commanded the largest armies in arabia he only forgave those people. If he forgave them then who are we to punish this girl?
Recommend
The question is not about the mental ability or the age of the girl.
The big question is about the abuse and misuse of the Blasphemy Law. “Let us make it clear that abuse/misuse of this ‘Law’ will not be tolerated
We want an action taken by the accuser.Recommend
@Shamy:
u doesn’t make sense
Recommend
Kevin – I hope she stays safe too, but realistically, the only way she can be safe is for her to and her family to leave Pakistan.
That mob that beat her were calling for her death. They wanted to BURN HER ALIVE. It is so saddening to think that there are so many people in this society that actually want to murder a child for burning the page of some book. She’s a CHILD for crying out loud. Children do stupid things. It’s not like she hurt anyone. Plus, if she’s ILLITERATE, how the heck would she have even known what she was burning? It wasn’t even a page of the Qur’an, it was a page from a book used to teach the Qur’an.
Can you imagine how heartless, soulless, devoid of empathy and caring, and full of hate an adult must be to want to burn a child alive just for burning the page of a book? I fear for the future of Pakistan. It makes me SICK to know there are so many people like that in Pakistan.
Recommend