Share this article
Print this page
Email a friend
- RSS
- Today's Paper
- Subscribe
- beta 2.0
High: 33°C
Low: 27°C
Alerts
14 arrested in Sialkot lynching case
10 people including four policemen have been held in the brutal public killing of two brothers in Sialkot.
The Butt brothers were killed and hung in Sialkot in the presence of police.
Interior Minister Rehman Malik has said that 14 people including four policemen have been held in the brutal public killing of two brothers in Sialkot.
Addressing the media in Sialkot, Malik said the culprits involved in the heinous crime would be duly punished. He appealed to the citizens of Sialkot to come forward and provide any information they had regarding the incident. He added that authorities have compiled a list of names of those under investigation and the federal government will be providing support in terms of intelligence and logistics as investigations continue.
Strike announced
Jamaat-e-Islami leader Liaqat Baloch also visited the family of the two brothers who were beaten to death by a mob in Sialkot. He said the party has announced a nationwide strike on Friday against this atrocity.
Updated from print edition (below).
Prime suspect SHO Rana Ilyas escapes from custody
The prime accused in the lynching of two brothers in Sialkot, SHO Rana Ilyas, managed to evade custody on Saturday and is currently at large. Ilyas, who fled from the office of the DSP Sialkot, was brought to the office so that he could be produced before a court for a judicial remand. The District Coordination Officer (DCO) Sialkot, Mujahid Sher Dil, has confirmed that the lynched youths had no criminal record. Sher Dil held the Sialkot police responsible for the incident as police officials witnessed the whole incident as silent spectators.
Police claimed to have arrested two police officers and five others who were present at the time the two brothers were beaten to death in public. Police contingents also stepped up efforts to apprehend six other officers who witnessed the murder but made little attempt to stop the mob.
DPO Sialkot Afzal Mehmood Butt said that five suspects involved in torturing the brothers had been rounded up and both of them were currently being investigated. “The culprits are still under investigation and we cannot release their names as yet. But rest assured we are doing all that we can to bring them to justice,” he said. Also on Saturday, a high-level committee, following the orders of Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, opened its investigation into the brutal murder of the two young men. The committee is headed by Deputy Inspector General Major Mubashar along with DIG Establishment Shoaib Dastgir. The committee’s officials visited the crime scene (Doburji Malhiyaan Chowk on the main Daska Road on the outskirts of Sialkot city) and gathered evidence.
The committee also recorded the statements of the grieving family. The committee has also recorded statements of senior police officials, Sialkot DCO Mujahid Sher Dil and local Rescue 1122 officials.
The investigators have assured the public of a transparent probe. “The TV footage confirms the presence of senior police officials on the spot when the youths were lynched,” Mubashar said. The grieving family of the lynched youths alleged that the senior police officials were protecting their juniors, adding that police had refused to register a murder case under Sections 302 or 109 of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC).
According to the family, the police registered a case against the SHO, a sub-inspector, four ASIs and eight other police officials under Section 155-C of the Police Ordinance. The section deals with misconduct by police officers when they are guilty of “any wilful breach or neglect of any provision of law or of any rule or regulation or any order which [they are] bound to observe or obey.” The maximum punishment under this section is three years in prison, with or without a fine.
After the chief justice’s intervention and a subsequent notification by the Punjab chief minister, an FIR however has been lodged in Saddar police station Sialkot under Sections 302 and 109 of the PPC (which deal with pre-meditated murder and abetment, respectively) against thirty people including 17 of those who were captured in the video footage. The other 13 accused are police officials, against whom a case – under 155-C of the Police Order – has already been registered. The 13 police officers include SHO Rana Ilyas Sub Inspector Gulzar, ASI Riaz Tariq, Sarfaraz, Waris Ali, Khaliq, Constable Rizwan, Nathay Khan, Mubarak Ali, Nawaz Salim and Abdul Razak.
While the family of the deceased boys and locals insists the boys were innocent, the family of the victim of a robbery, Bilal, contested this view. “You can go ask anyone, these boys were the robbers and they killed my husband. Why is my family being accused of spreading false rumours when we are the ones who lost someone? We didn’t kill those boys but they killed my husband,” said Bilal’s widow, adding that the media and locals had been threatening her family to keep quiet about the robbery incident that preceded the mob lynching of young brothers Mughees and Muneeb Butt.
President Asif Ali Zardari has also taken notice of the incident and issued a statement on Saturday, condemning the killing of the two young brothers. The president has also asked for an immediate report, ordering an inquiry into the murders. The presidential spokesman Farhatullah Babar said that the president was upset over the sad episode and firmly believed that “such an act of infamy, shame and brutality should not go unpunished.”
Published in The Express Tribune, August 22nd, 2010.
Correction: September 13, 2010
An earlier version of this article stated the name of the brothers as Mueez and Muneeb. The names are Mughees and Muneeb and have been corrected.
Read more:
sialkotlynching
Related Videos
Reader Comments (134)
Latest News
Shaheen Air: Fuel tank leak leaves passengers stranded
Officials say remaining passengers will either be sent to Karachi on another plane or will be directed to go home.
Bullet-riddled body of journalist found in Turbat
Express News correspondent Razzaq Gul had been kidnapped on Friday evening.
INTEL-ISEF 2012: Pakistanis take home prize at world's largest science fair
Mahnoor Hassan, Shiza Gulab and Bushra Shahed of Institute of Computer and Management Sciences take 4th prize.
Intel Isef: 3 Pakistani students make it to finals
Five finalists were named in Pakistan, but only three obtained a visa.
Italy "dog and cat tax" muzzled after uproar
The only thing that's left to tax are wives and children, says parliamentarian.
Recent Slideshows
More in Pakistan
Devastation and disease spread
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, redistributed or derived from.
Unless otherwise stated, all content is copyrighted © 2012 The Express Tribune News Network.
Technical feedback? webmaster@tribune.com.pk
we hope there is some concrete action not just a parade of wordsRecommend
Just 3 years of imprisonment for denying the right to be secured or aide to rescue … Brilliant! … Floods are rightly hitting us, for we are all insane to accept such inhumanity. The mother of the deceased calls for an eye for an eye. Those involved in killing the boys to death, should face the same wrath in public. This is the justice we require, so that fear sees through the eyes, and people become humans from animals. No wonder, Islam has such simple methodology to maintain a respectful society.Recommend
The profiles of the CRIMINALS; their photos, their families’ information, their professions, their addresses and their locations should be published and broadcasted to arrange a massive social boycott of these perpetrators.
The social society should gear up their reaction against such CRIMINALS.Recommend
“The main suspect SHO managed to escape from police custody ” says it all. What do you expect when commissions and committees are set up, in an case where the crime is recorded on film, you expect a travesty of justice.Recommend
Shame on all who stood there and watched the torture and murder. I would love to see all that crowd lined up and shot dead as an example!Recommend
As Per Sharia Law (if we have one in Pakistan) the family of the brothers has every right to order the same Punishment for those involved. Which would be Public hanging, stoning, or hitting with sticks till Death.Recommend
The incident might not have gained much attention if the victims were truly robbers. Even in that case, public shouldn’t be allowed to become jury, judge and executioner. I remember how our media glorified the incidents of robbers’ burning in Pakistan, something that needed unequivocal condemnation.
I smell anarchy in different parts of Pakistan. Be it reflecting in form of inhuman killings of innocents, or people breaching embankments to save their lands. In all its forms, it’s a very sad and disappointing status quo.Recommend
sometimes you get speechless and grub into the bag of dictionary to find out words that can voice yours feelings about the event you witnessed or heard of.we all have to rethink of function of institutions,our social behaviour and civic responsbilities to weave togather our social fabric once again.Recommend
This is extremely disheartening. and rightfully said by someone…”and we have the audacity to question why we are hit by natural disasters not one time but multiple times over!”
We really need a miracle from Allah to put some sense in our extremely ignorant people. They’re killing they’re own people damn it, and then they question why random countries come in and try occupying their lands. This is grievous beyond words!Recommend
Watching the censored video on TV was enough to give me sleepless nights. I wonder how so many people including the police men just stood their watched the whole episode. We want more transperancy on the case – this case should not go like the rest where everyone talks about it for a month or two and then no one knows what happened to the culprits. The killers should be punished in the same way. NO MATTER WHAT these two brothers had done – murder of these two brothers cannot be justified. Culprits should be murdered in the same way they murdered the two brothers.Recommend
Me,my wife and four children wept for several hours to see brutal incident of brutal killings. I personally knew these brother, they use to come to Fox Sports to play Cricket. We highly condemn their brutal killing and ask for justice. We also left Pakistan due to criminal people in this area of Sialkot when we had similar threats and our life was at risk. We express our condolences to breaved family. We also hate such muslims who were fasting and doing criminal acts. where was humanity. Solid steps to be taken not just paperwork and media should keep an eye until hanged the culprits-Prince Shahryar RanaRecommend
Can media stop showing the footage of brutally murder of two brothers please? It’s really throbbing for parents to see their kids killing, hanging upside down and dragging across the streets. Media done a great job by showing the real picture now stop hurting parent’s emotions by showing the footage again & again. PLEASE !!Recommend
Living in the UK i was once a proud British Pakistani, but when you hear, see and read about all the injustices that occure in Pakistan i now feel ashamed to associate myself with Pakistan. The way that the murders took place was horrific and the way that the public behaved was appauling the least. A country when many are dying, one would think that esspecialy during the month of Ramazan, that you would show compassion to one another but, hey this is Paksitan, compassion and love is clearly lost. Pakistan has protrayed it self in such a negative way with many of us now asshamed to be Pakistanis, the main cause being the useless goverment who is supposed to bring light to bad times. what a sad state of affairs!Recommend
shame on all those who did nothing to prevent the poor boys being slaughtered.the cops were a disgrace.i just hope the judge orders the same horrible painfull and slow death for the cowardly murderers.Recommend
This highlights the reason behind what is happening overall in pakistan. People have no humanity left in them, their all out to eat each other alive. How can them people just stand and watch, I could barely watch it on the tv and that was a for a minute. They all stood their for 4 HOURS watching this absolutely brutal killing. Lets also not forget that this was all during ramadan while they were all fasting. Its a shame but these are the reasons I would now be afraid to take my young children even for a holiday! When people have no humanity, they can do anything whether thats killing adults, teenagers or children. My heart goes out to their mother, none of us can even imagine her pain. May allah give her courage and strength to make her stronger.Recommend
To say that my heart bleeds for these two young brothers would be a huge understatement. Being a father myself, i cant even begin to comprehend how the parents of the two young brothers must be going through. May Allah give them the courage to deal with this.Recommend
Only after the chief justice took notice of the incident, the CM woke up, after that the lahore High Court and now after one week the President and Rehman Malik have risen to the occasion. Where have they been in the past week? I think if someone deserves to die like this its only our politician and they will die Inshallah one day when the masses finally realize that we need a honest government.Recommend
The family of these two boys belongs to Jamaat Islami who as we all know introduced and promoted this psyche of mob rule and brutality on streets and in educational institutions in the first place. JI should realise that the culture they have inducted in the society has come back to bite them. Hope this tragedy becomes an opportunity for Jamaat Islami to mend their ways and they in all sincerity try to undo this mob justice mentality. Although I’m not holding my breath.Recommend
Definitely this is a brutal and barbarious act and we should condem it. Unfortunately we tend to see and follow those things which media wants us to beleive.
First of all where was the media when it was happened first time in Karachi where people killed the docaits ??? Why media did’nt raise it
that time if they are really concerned about these type of incidents.
Secondly Why media is not highlighting the other side of the picture, there must be some reasons which make these people did this act, do somebody know what is that ?? definitely these people will not beat any pedistarian or stranger like that !!!! Media is just trying to hide the other side of story and putting lime light on the last episode as they manage to get a clip of that which they shoot themselves …. Question… why those media persons do not stop the people from doing so and keep on making a movie to get a high public rating …. so they are equally responsible
Thirdly even after notice has been taken by all the concerning authorities, why media is still showing those clips on channeles…to get the cheap publicity without taking care that what message is going to the world. They are spoling the name of Pakistan which already dont have a good repo.
Fourthly why suo moto notice has not been taken when poor labours from Punjab have been killed brutally when they were travelling to Balochistan just on the basis that they belong to Punjab. Why media kept quite on that incident, those poor labours were totally inocent, which is not the case in this incident …
Please think……Recommend
ALLAH ka INSAAF ho kar rahey gay INSHALLAHRecommend
We will have to ask ourselves why we are seeing this level of barbarity in our society on a day to day basis? as a society, we have a false sense of piety and split personalities. we call ourselves peaceful but we have qualms of supporting groups who attack sections of society who we think are not islamic enough or the “other”. I am afraid that the foundation of our society and country are flawed and we are paying the price for that.Recommend
Its such a sad incident nothing worse then this could be expected from Pakistani’s. For the first time I am feeling ashamed of being a part of this nation..How can somebody stand still and watch that incident..Even we can’t watch the video completely, I am unable to understand how those people of sialkot were watching that, wasn’t there a single person who could stop them? This is what we are going to give our youth? Shameful. And I fear the day media stops talking about this news, the culprits would be free. But I request all Pakistani’s to please stand against it, think as if they were our brothers..Recommend
I would say, this is most shameful event for all our muslim people, if this family did not get the justic than all pakistani will go to hell.
where is islam, is this islam teach, torture inccoent boys, Well my belive is dont say any body to anything, but these police officers shoulbe be hang till death. beacsue they are resposible for peace in area and making sure no crime happen, but as a police officer they were only stood as crowd, they didnt perfom their duty and this has been two murders which goes in them heads, so they deserve the punishment only ” Death”Recommend
I just can’t believe how the crowd was just staring like it was some drama, they didn’t even think what the brothers were actually going through. imagine yourself just cutting yourself on the arm. it is quite painful. but being bashed with a bat continously? astagfiruallah.
the two brothers will definately go to paradise(: and the people who slaughtered them will DEFINATELY get punished by allah.
Oh allah bless the poor brothers.
♥Recommend
i never forgive them who kill Inncoent boys :”( we most not give up :( N i Dua’s Allah .. that there killer never be live …We Want JustICe …Recommend
What investigation do they require. It is all on the Video. No matter what the boys were, it was not the problem of the mob to treat them like this. If they were suspected they should have called the authorities. But sorry what authorities…………… Only three years of imprisonment? Is this a joke. The authorities are going to do nothing….. We should unite and stand together so such incidents are totally eradicated.Recommend
innalillahi-wa-inna-alihirajioon
and they were only kids.y didn’t they just shoot them or slaughter them-i cannot imagine the pain of beaten to death…and they were ONLY kids!how does anyone torture kids to death?i cant say no more.
i hope everyone remembers the kids and their parents’ in their duas this ramadhan.(atleast their suffering is over inshallah-the parents will re-live it everyday)Recommend
Mai they get justice N Mai they Rest In Peace n They B granten In heaven AMEENRecommend
Mai they get justice N Mai they Rest In Peace n They B granted In heaven *AMEEN*Recommend
I am in still in tears today.How can all those people who just stood and watched the barbaric killings of those two brothers justify themselves.They are every bit as guilty of the murders as the animals who actual beat the poor brothers to death.
All this in a country where the timely intervals of Azan during each and everyday is a constant reminder to these people of Gods wishes,and for all this to take place during ramadan let alone at all is beyond comprehending.
All those animals that tied the boys up before their babaric act should to be tied up and left at mercy of such barbarianism,lets see how brave and macho they really are.Recommend
May Allah bless both brothers in heaven!
I have no words what to write and what not…
Do we believe that People will not forget this brutal act as previous cases? and there will be thousands of people to raise their voice for them…
But this is Pakistan dears, just a piece of land where there is no value of human life”
See Pakistani Caretakers what they do…waiting for their response & action!
Pray & Hope for the best that this would not be happened again!Recommend
ExtreMely…sad to see that two of our pakistani and most importantly muslim brothers had been beaten by foolish people….who are without any sense of direction….very shameful…..worst of all police was also present at particular moment….strict action should be taken against each one of the and should be handled by an iron handRecommend
hi. i am speechless, it is very difficult time for their family. May Allah bless them with jannah ameen. its would be a great favour if somebody give the contact of number of these two brother’s father or their home number.Recommend
Once again the private TV channels have shown a lack of moral ethics, when it comes to reporting such heinous barbarity on our screens. Why do they have to show videos of mutilated, decapitated bodies time and time again and I single out Geo TV in particular, who always seems to be the ‘first’ in ‘breaking news, often streaming live footage as it happens’? Have the deceased no self-dignity and respect? Can you imagine the anguish and harrowing ordeal of the brothers’ family and relatives on seeing the video of their loved ones being mercilessly tortured for hours, dragged through the streets, being lynched and no-one intervening?
Will such incidents prick our conscious and prompt a debate on the malady that afflicts many in Pakistan from all strata of society? Why do you think your leaders are silent over this or at best offer a muted response when they themselves are indifferent and callous to the sufferings of the average Pakistani? Your own MNA’s and senators are guilty of mob brawls and fistfights in your senate houses where acts and motions are passed.
I personally have witnessed incidents of brutality whenever I have visited Pakistan and on every instance that I have tried to intervene I was held back from onlookers.
By constantly airing videos of dead bodies people will be come desensitized, so much so that if a dead body was lying on the street you would just walk past it.
Our beloved Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him) who was the epitome of mercy, narrated that a time would come when a believer would pass a grave and wished that he was in that place too.
“Truly, Allah, Most Gracious and Most High does not change the condition of a people until they change what is in themselves.”
May Allah the Almighty grant eternal bliss and peace to the departed souls of the brothers – and may Allah have mercy on us ALL – Amin.Recommend
My two cents for the departed souls:
http://www.thetrueperspective.com/2010/08/they-got-up-one-day-to-play-cricket.html
May God bless them. I an ashamed Pakistani today. A sad, ashamed, miserable Pakistani. I don’t have the ability to raise my head and say Pakistan Zindabad today.Recommend
I cant even watch the video of the poor boys how could these people do this or stand there watching.There is no distiguishing between the lowlifes who battered those boys so brutally to death and the lowlifes who stood there watching.
If there was an issue regarding those poor children why couldnt the adults take it up with the boys elders??
It really hurts me to see how much pain and suffering those poor boys had to go through via the beatings,how can anyone inflict such a slow and barbaric death.These men and the audience of bystanders are not muslims i have called them animals but even animals show compassion.These people are shataans plaguing our earth.Recommend
This is pure brutality,
How low have some people become?
What were the officers thinking? How much did they get paid?
What were the people thinking?
Even if they were real criminals, you just dont take matters like this into your own hands, there are procedures.
I am ashamed to see that these are supposed to be muslims, celebrating the month of ramadan.
I pray all those animals get brought to justice.Recommend
Having watched the video on youtube, i sadden to say the least. But one fellow that really caught my eye towards the end of the video was a kid about 10 or 11 years old, he too was hitting the two brothers when they had no life left in them. Now, i would like to meet his parents and the idiot and see what the hell is going on in there household. Any normal 10 or 11 year old would most likely be upset at that type of violence or just start to cry out of shock, but i guess maybe he was used to type behavior. Shameful shame on all that were ….Recommend
I totally agree with waqar and km this is so shameful and i wonder why pakistan is in such trouble.Killing those boys whether they were criminals or not no one should be treated like that this is all happenning in ramadan.wow i wonder again when the west see this what they will think.ramadan is a month to forgive and charity and pray for others and help poor and here we see all jahil’s watching and doing nothing.COWARDS!!!Recommend
No Investigation , just killed them and hang them all on the same place where the innocents were being hanged.Recommend
May their soul rest in peace. Ameen !! Even if some ppl consider them robber,no law allow anyone to kill someone to death. We always blame others, why don’t we act as a society , at least chief justice took notice but what about public and police standing there,a strict action should be taken against them.How brutal one could be,you don’t kill an animal like this how could you do this to humans.plz people correct yourselves (including myself) and do self judgement first, and media please stop airing the video anymore.There’s nothing wrong in being Pakistani but the problem is we have no humanity.May ALLAH bless us n our country . Ameen!!Recommend
i will never go to pakistan…..where the whole nation is quite on this cruel eventRecommend
Aslamualaikum
i came to know about incident through newspaper and finally through video.i am very sorry to said this is sorrow incident for me because what our media is doing they just picked their videos camera’s and reached any location where they do not know what is going on they are just in the habbit of making videos that what was happning in sialkot they are struggling for their life and media and people are in the habbit of making videos o death because they want to get more fame through this video and get a new article no one left their camera and come for their help.they are just thinking of their fame and money (shame for those who involve to making a videos of such incidents)Recommend
Lot more to be done with FIR registration and Mahrar should be trained by law . Section imposing in FIR should also be law abide. Politician remain aside showing politic on this issue.Recommend
i dont trust the police investigating this case at all..3 years! are they joking..this has to be a joke..even if they didn do it and watched this happening..3 years is still a joke..they deserve alot worse..as for the animals that did it..they need to be beaten to death the same way..THATS JUSTICE..involve the army if you have to .. but WE NEED REAL JUSTICE NOT THIS 3 YEAR JOKE..WUTS WRONG WITH PPL HAVE THEY BECOME ANIMALS..ARE THEIR HEARTS MISSING..we need your help Allah!Recommend
This incident reveals lack of moral values,lack of trust on justice system,lack of courage,lack of rule of law,lack of humanity,lack of sympathy/empathy..Something is fundamentally wrong..I am sure anyone of us(pakistanis) would have done the same as all of those spectators.We are the same SILENT MAJORITY…who remain silent when corrupt and amoral people are being elected by handful devotees(jiallas,haq parasts,mullahs etc..who remain silent when minorities are killed for assumed blasphemy…who remain silent on hearing gunshot sounds in our neighbourhood..who remain silent when atheists/agnostics are announced WAJIB-UL-QATAL…We are all tamashbeens.But unfortunately now SILENCE OR TAMASHBEENI will not save us from pain..Fire is getting closers..Tamashbeens are going to break their silence soon…by last sounds of their cries before death either by suicide bombing,flood,earthquak ,drones, starvation,nuclear explosion… OUR MOTO….
PAKISTAN SAY ZINDA BHAAGRecommend
I saw part of the video and want to say..the young 9 – 10 year old kid, a kid, oh m God , who was so proudly beating the INNOCENT victims without any mercy, may Allah swt give you and do to you what you did to another human being.Recommend
Hang in front of public, those involve…simple….Recommend
it brings tears to my eyes to see the inhumane beatings of the two brothers.the people watching the beatings are just as much responsible for the murders of the poor boys as the people doing the actual beating.tie up the janvirs who did the beatings and throw them infront of a crowd and let them experience what they did to those 2 boys.then we will see how brave and macho they really are.Recommend
oh man i am shocked. Dont know what to say.I dont think it was a mob killing. Its our police. Well done guys keep voting for crooks like shahbaz shariff who is probably in charge of that part of low life area of pakistan.Value of a human life is so next to nothing. No wonder authorities are so proud with their rescue efforts in the flood hit areas as only about 2000 people lost their lives. Hope you understand what I m saying.Where is Imran Khan or Altaf Hussian who seem to protest about every other little things, may be its nothing major for them but to me it was a sad and gloomy day and my deepest sympathy goes to the parents of the victims irrespective of what they did or didnt do.what kind of people(pakistani) have we become no wonder we get a president like Zardari.
God help Pakistan
AtifRecommend
we strongle protest against the murder of the two innocent youngster aged 14 and 18 , who have been brutally beaten to death publically in sailkotand then hanged them upside down with blood running their face by those ppl . . . . . . . .this act is truely against islam and judiciary . no one allowd to create such a mess . . let ur inner self to behave as alive and condemn this actRecommend
my roots belongs to Sialkot and im from BUTT family as well,but thanks to ALLAH i have never been in Pakistan and i for sure i do not have any wish to go there since i m born and now less.regarding this sad action of people i can say that we cant expect nothing from illitrated people,who cant think,they r created just to eat,marry,gossiping,making kids and they cant see more far then their nose,PROUD TO BE MUSLIM,they r shame for ISLAM,and how many times during the video i saw even i dont know good punjabi i can hear the abuses next to the NAME OF ALLAH,shame really shame,in the HOLY MONTH OF RAMADAN our prophet MUHAMMED MAY ALLAH BLESS HIM AND GIVE HIM REST AND OUR MIGHTY ALLAH said we have to avoid fights and killiong of MUSLIM is a big sin,except if its by mistake,and again u have to pay ur guiltiness by keeping fast for few days or give freedom of any slave,so these brutal murderers they cant be muslims,to be honest i dont know did u guys saw that there is a kid like 12-15 years old who also hit one of the boys,so what kind of thinking is going in his mind at that time.and where r his parents,i know MIGHTY ALLAH will punish these bad people,but if i had a power i will cut their hands and legs and leave them to live a miserable life,that they cant put food in their mouth,that they cant even easily go to toilet,that they please for help that they depend of other people to live and survive,MAY ALLAH FORGIVE THESE BOYS AND GIVE THEM PEACE IN THE PARADISE,and its good for this country to be under the rules of BRITAIN or any other country again,coz for this time when they were occupate they didnt learn their lesson so its good if they r slaves,just bomb blasts,from where they learn this i dont know,killing poor kids and ladies,they r not terorists they r sadists,i dont know for what price thet sale their souls,but unfortunatly thats just a small example of the real life in Pakistan,things r more deep,u have to be clever to survive inthis jungle,where there is no law,no any protection,and human life doesnt have any value,so the story is very long,and there is no end to describe everythingRecommend
May Allah give these two brothers the comfort they deserve in heaven after that brutal act on them.I am so ashamed to be called a Pakistani right now,all those officers need to be hanged in public and the animals who were beating those tied up young boys shud b tied up at the same place and beaten to death by the mother of those boys.I beg to authorities have some Khudda ka khoof and don’t let this be just another story which dies after a while with no result. Mere dua hai, Ya Allah tujhe tere Rasool (PBUH) ka wasta hai en kateloon ko zalil o khawar kar ke kutte ke moot mar.Ameen.Recommend
I am ashamed to be pakistani …no one deserves to be brutallay and barbaricaly slaughterd in public… mob rule is the order in Pakistan .. the Law and order situation is non existant …The POLICE officers should have shot in the air to disperse the crowd instead they stood by and watched … my allah belss the 2 boys a plce in jannat ,and .. strike all those responsible and watching with DEATH ….
i am never going to Pakistan again …. pakistan should not be call PAK istan any more …. shame on our country and people …Recommend
I am ashamed benig Pakistani!
I am totally broken how cruel our ordinary people but our media show its all fault lies in Govt but why people did that? how shame less the ordinary poor people of pakistan always involve in prtotest by breaking thins.I personlay media is the responsible to provr people are very inocent but govt is not good.We should lodge FIR against media as it fail to show cruel face of Our poor people.Recommend
urghh i soo feel like killing da ppl..!!gosh if dez ppl evn onne of them came infront of me i wuld b in jail for murders!!!illitrate society!!perfect example!!!i cant stp tinking bout this terrible incident !!nd thoses horrible wild animals who were watching cowards!!!dunt deserve to live go kill ur self sumwhere maybe sumone will forgive u !!gosh !!i cant imagine that a human can do sumthing like this to another over this thing!! nd police m soo impressed i often use to hear such thingx bout tem gosh if i had the authority i wuld have done sumthing dat the world wuld have beenn shocked on..cowards+stealers+useless=police(that was there)killers of big times ..i tink ul evn spead ur dirt in the hell ..its evn too gud for u !!=ppl who did it ..nd illitrate+painduu+cowards+circus clowns=ppl watching …standing there ..!!i wish u culd have done sumthing!!its not one its all ppl watching ppl who did it nd police..never will u find place nywhere to bang ur head.!!..cowards…seriosulliii IF I WERE NY OF THEM I WULD HAVE KILLED MY SELF IN A WORSE WAY AFTER HAVING PPL TO HATE ME SOO MUCHH >>TO ALL THOSE PPL STADING THERE WATCHING ND POLICE ND THE criminals WHO DID IT >>!!!!i hope dat u neva find peace in ur life ..and after death !!nd ur probably the first ppl i am actully cirtisizn nd will for rest of my life..abosutly no sympathy..!!for these criminalsRecommend
well…i hope it doesnt go “nowhere” like most of our cases…though the situation of justice is like “mocking justice” an so much pathetic that we cant trust it but hopes are there as always…situation is damn serious and demanding but again we all know its not just in a few scenarios..we have a rich history of such incidents which went nowhere and another arisen isnt it????Recommend
i am extremely disgusted at the way these two innocent kids have been brutally killed in ramazan…. ALL of pakistan needs to unite in this case and protest (if it has an dignity left) for the murderers to be stoned and hanged to death…
The mother’s voice needs be heard ‘eye for an eye’… they need to be made an example of so it doesn’t happen again as these public killings are becoming common.
As Sharia Law states the family of the brothers have every right to order the same Punishment for those involved.Recommend
its not the fault of public who watched we might had done same thing because when law and order police man involve no one dare to stop that kind of events. people know what will happen if they tried to stop.
we need justice we need leadership we need to get rid of all police crime will finish from pakistan for ever.Recommend
I am a mother(Allhamado lillah). I have lost a son in a swimming pool accident about 17 years ago. It still hurts every time when he comes to mind or rather he never leaves the mind. I cannot even imagine the pain of the parents and the family.May ALLAH saws gives them sabar e jamil. For the policemen and the killers Islam has a simple rule of “an eye for an eye”. They should be killed in the same manner and hung.Recommend
The people involved in this are horrible disgusting animals. But equally horrible is the fact that this is what has become of the country. When each government has more corrupt than the last these are the results. We have been brandished as terrorists, thugs, and now definitely barbarians. The world has not only turned its back on us, but actively pray of the country to implode, which it is readily doing. We seriously need to oust our corrupt leaders and bring in people who genuinely care about the country and its people. The truth is staring us in the face.Recommend
this was inhuman, gruesome and most disturbing. the killers should be hanged in public. every one who has thrown a sinle stone is a killer and all those who watched this sordid act were their accomplices.
its a dark day for punjab police and people of sialkot.
i was always under the impression that people of sialkot are cultured and soft like general jahangir karamat.Recommend
May Allah bless both brothers in heaven!
I have no words what to write and what to say this is very very harmful incident in pakistan what will do for their family there is no any rules in PAkistan plz Allah Save us. am sure Allah wiil take revenge from that basterds AmeenRecommend
This entire incident shows the level of humanity left in us. If character of these boys and their family had not been a hurdle, the police and the mob would have been getting medals and appreciation. It is not the first such incident in this area, previously police has been doing the same with alleged robberers and getting medals (last two years and so). It is strange to learn through news that police has to conduct negotiations with the culprits for arrests of persons nominated in the case. Is our police so incapable and powerless that despite orders of President, Prime Minister, Chief Minister and Interior Minister, they are begging to culprits for giving arrests?? This is a question mark over whole administration.. Moral character of people of Sialkot is also questionable, whether there is a single human there or all of them are animals..Recommend
so saaaaad.why all the crulers have forgotten humanity eapecially in pakistan in the month of ramazan??plz i request all of political leaders to take urgently action to this incident and they shoud be punished all of such criminals that forget humanity.Recommend
we all are responsible ……….
we are living is a state of Animals.Recommend
I am shocked beyond measure as a mother my heart goes out to the mother of those 2 children. they were chilren being mercilessly beaten and not one person had the heart or the mind to stop it. If this is the punishment for stealing wat is the punishment for murder? broad daylight meriless inhuman horrific cold blooded murder.
what is the punishment for murder in muslin law someone please enlighten me.I pray to the Lord Jesus that he givs the parent of those poor kids the heart to go on with life. My god rest those poor defensless children’s souls.Recommend
ALLAH will do justice one day INSHAHALLAH for these innocent brothers,shame on all pakistani leaders and police men,may their children die like that ameen….Recommend
I am appalled by the level of ignorance and brutality shown in this incident. How can a human do this to another human being??? Its quite like living in the stone ages, where animal instincts would rule the conscious behaviour. However, I still dont get what provoked those people to behave like this??? What actually happened?? There is no way that this act of barbarianism could be justifed, but we need to get the facts straight. When this whole incident was happening (reportedly it took 4 hours) where was the family?? Why didnt they come to save the boys? How come there was no one there who would speak for the poor boys??Recommend
Shot them who all of involed in the beating
kill them make example for rest of humen!Recommend
butt brothers was killed police presence.i think ye ploice ke na ahle ha .in sab logo ko jo is me involve ha in ko hanged karna chahe.Recommend
this is nothing new in a country of selfish, nosey, corrupt, sly minded 2 faced people, infact this is a common type behaviour in most muslim countries. why would Allah look down with mercy upon such a dispicable ummahRecommend
Poori dunya may hamara mazaaq ban gaya. Government ko barpoor karrawai karky dunya ko dikana chahiyai k jahan p andy mojood hai waya par insaaf b mojood hai.Recommend
As a Muslim, I am ashamed of Pakistan and his people. You guys are shame to our religion, shame to ISLAM. You make us look bad, ugly in all around the world already and you have proven this once again. Thanks. Because of you i cant even go to the mosque my head held up high. You make our religion look bad. In this holy month of ramadan, You have proven that you guys are lover than animals. Even animals kill for food only, Not for whatever your reasons are.Recommend
I am really surprised that most comments here want the “eye for an eye” and want to beat and hang the killers.
Most of those who beat the brothers thought that the boys were robbers. So in fact, they were doing “eye for an eye”.
There is no difference between you and the killers.
A civilized society, which of course Pakistan is NOT, believes in courts system where courts decide and execute the punishment.Recommend
This incident is against humanity. May their departed souls rest in peace i request da whoe nation 2 pray 4 these 2 brothers and may the murderers get the punishment which they deserve.Recommend
its really really sad condition,,,, they both were telented nd hosnest boys may god give them place in heaven n peace in their family god bless them but its really bad……. they were beated badly…. :-(Recommend
Sallaam, i am a 2nd Generation British Pakistani born and bred in England and proud to be British. Growing up we were told to be proud of being Pakistanis by our parents. I think i speak for the majority of British Pakistanis who are all very patriotic to Pakistan i know i am, as we were brought up to love Pakistan. I dont know much about pakistani politics, but i know its always in a mess, always has been from day one! i have experienced first hand corruption in pakistan as allot of visting british pakistanis have, its actually quite normal and is a way of life there and has become a mind set. Which is exactly what needs to change….The people! there mentality and outlook on life! wake up you morons! and deal with these tragic events, the recent floodings and not to mention the poor international response should tell you something is not right! You have lost the whole essence of being a pakistani and with it a human! Watching the brutal murders of two teenagers in broad daylight in a public area whilst the LAW was present and did nothing shocked me and my family while we prepared to open our fasts in this holy month of Ramadhan were they say the devil is locked away, not before he twisted the sick minds of these people in Sialkot. I can only say every govt official, politician, armed forces, police officer and any other person in any agency in Pakistan should be ashamed of themselves and ask why and what they are really doing in their public posts, i mean really ask! I for one am glad that my parents made the hard steps and sacrifices to leave Pakistan!Recommend
innalillahi-wa-inna-alihirajioon
and they were only kids.y didn’t they just shoot them or slaughter them-i cannot imagine the pain of beaten to death…and they were ONLY kids!how does anyone torture kids to death?i cant say no more.
i hope everyone remembers the kids and their parents’ in their duas this ramadhan.Recommend
My eyes could not believe it!, such barbarism in the public places where from kids to old people, have been beating two innocent teens!
they should be punished STONE TO DEATH AT PUBLIC PLACES. three years punishment is a joke! I could see a young lad having cricket bat to beat one of the guys.
My heart is weeping! they have tortured the flowers of human race!
May Allah rest their soul in Peace, and bring justice to the day of Judgment. Whoever involved in tortured , will be witnessed life after death punishment. They might escape from the justice of Pakistan, but they won’t escape from the Justice of God Almighty Allah, when they die soon or later, will be brought for punishment in the Court of God!
May God give us patience and protect us from such barbaric people!Recommend
scum bags all the people that beat them boys and watch with joy will burn in hell.
and i hope thay get the same to them and there familys.
hang them high
and this was the month of ramazan we have seen your faces now wait and see iam from the same area money no problem and know alot of people from there and eye of an eye you will get yoursRecommend
Allah will not forgive us as a society for what has happened and what continues to happen. We need to take responsibility, stand up and identify the coward standing there watching these kids die, people of SIALKOT. Otherwise, Allah will send a very big punishment for you. No wonder we have floods that no one has seen in their lifetime anywhere in the world!!Recommend
While living in Gujranwala many years ago, I used to think there’s something evil in local people that I never seen anywhere else…and today watching this, no wonder I feeling was so true….Recommend
it is very cruel.it should be open trialed.The Supreme Court should take a historical decision so that none should dare in future to do such act in the society.Moreover the brave public of Sialkot should play a vital role on the issue and cooperate to the Supreme court and inquiring committies by recoeding their witness without any fear.Recommend
Violation of human dignity must stop now!it seems to me animals are far better than some barbaric human beings.Recommend
Those watching are just as guilty as the mindless brutes torturing the kids to death.
Wars are acts of state sponsored terrorism,but these acts defy definition!Recommend
#
Its such a sad incident nothing worse then this could be expected from Pakistani’s. For the first time I am feeling ashamed of being a part of this nation..How can somebody stand still and watch that incident..Even we can’t watch the video completely, I am unable to understand how those people of sialkot were watching that, wasn’t there a single person who could stop them? This is what we are going to give our youth? Shameful. And I fear the day media stops talking about this news, the culprits would be free. But I request all Pakistani’s to please stand against it, think as if they were our brothers..Recommend
the people who brutly beat the boys should be punished where is the president where r the leaders.now wat should be done to the culprits plze plze dont kill them dont give them death sentance instead cut off thir hands,cut off thir feet, cut out thir eyes, cut off thir tongs, cut off thir ears, cut off thir noses and let them live.that should be thir punishment,plze if u like this punishment for the culprits plze plze pass this on to as many as possible so that they get this punishment.ameen.inshallaRecommend
these killers belongs to village Gattal Teh Tala Gang,Distt chakwal
after killing innocent boys they ran away from the sialkot and now thy are in their villageRecommend
People, it has been several days now, that i am not able to forget the dreadful incident, that has numbed my heart and touched my soul… i will never be able to look back at our country and citizens the way i use to before…
Those brothers are gone to heaven for sure as Shaheed… but now my real concern apart from seeing the culprits being punished ASAP, is the mother, who lost the two jewels of her eyes… will anything on earth going to bring them back to her? she is left in pain forever… she will not only have memories of her beloved sons, but along with them the brutality that will hount her forever…
i am in greif, that till now, NO media has been able to reach the culprits? we want the media to show us their faces… tell us what they got in return of this dreadful act? what was their religion? what they use to eat in order to make their hearts, minds, and souls so evil??
if our nation has this passion, then why not bring revolution??? our country has been suffering from millions of desasters, but no one comes out on the street and raise their voice… but they did EVERYTHIN and ANYTHING possible or may be beyond possible to treat the two young birds with brutality that will never be forgotton, who did not even got streatched their wings to expereince the real world… they were still students…
The father, who lost his shoulders, his pillars, his motivation, his hope for support in his old age… the grandfather who in his old age had to see his grandsons departing in the way that world has never seen before… he kept saying “unhon ne imtehan diya tha… abhi result nahi aya… abhi result nahi aya” while holding the pictures of his grandsons in his hands…
I got my eyes filled with tears and got my heart burnt with fire… the ONLY justice would be to handover the murderers to the Mother… and let her do what ever she wants to do with them… this shall be the BEST way she might be able to find some peace…
Why, our nation has failed till now and not yet captured and showed us the animals who did this…. or are they waiting for these animals to go abroad? and escape forever… but in the Name of ALLAH, let me assure you, Allah’s Azaab shall hount them, and also to them who WATCHED…. and did not tried to stop them or even contact their relatives…
All my questions will be unanswered… I know… but i have NO other medium to express or to take out what my mind and heart is saying every minute and every day… even if this world will forget this horrible incident, but my heart will NEVER forget, and i will never see us PAKISTANIS the same way…
it was HELL ON EARTH!!!
ALLAH HO AKBAR – ALLAH HO AKBAR – ALLAH HO AKBAR – LA ILAHA ILLALAH…Recommend
Oh my God….. un-believable. In this case the police is the real culprits the police officials present there should be hanged only hanged not less than it so next no one try to do this like act. No doubt Chemma is a good police officer but police mis-use his orders. The existing of police on the scene proves there involvement. All the police we have is most corrupt and powerful and the politicians and other powerful uses it for there own interests. Anyhow, no one should be spared to stop future incidents. No concession with peoples and police involved. hand them on the spot where this happen. Please. GOD bless the two brothers and family.Recommend
how ar dis ppl sleep.. or iven liv.. wat ar you ppl anemalss!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! you disorv to die!!!!! dai dai….Recommend
Seriously!!! If we bring capital punishment to our streets… so many of these ghastly atrocities will just end. Public hangings should made. This is the only way to prevent further criminal outbursts. As for our security services and rescue operators… they are just one big Bah humbug. We are all left to fend for ourselves in a country that lacks law and order… nobody is willing to accept responsibility for their actions, or lack of. Saddened and disgusted. Makes one wonder, why are we facing so much strife? Terrorism, earthquakes, floods???Recommend
my sad very for ramzan and 2 brother killingRecommend
I think media and people have power to bring these guys on TV and just ask them to reply to two questions,
“Even if they were theives, is this the right way to do it”
“Should same have happened to their young ones or brothers what would they do”
Bringing them in public to speak is a must before some one says that they have been charged for so so many years. This should be a public enquiry rather than a police investigation. 1 out of 100 such incidents get on camera. There are others where people rape and kill and no one notice cause they hide bodies. Then others where people kill and threat families not to speak or they will be killed as well.Recommend
We want to see action against those criminals.. Yah Allah please forgive our mistakes.
My request to all the brothers and sisters to pray for the two brothers in every prayers.Recommend
Basically I belong to Gujranwala and there is trend to take revenge in this way. Now Sialkot issue is the continuity of all previous brutal and violent atrocities.And it is the time to start movement against these bloody wild trends. we should not expect justice from any one because now fake testimonies are being planned with the excessive use of money and power backing with political influences.Recommend
Basically I belong to Gujranwala and there is trend to take revenge in this way. Now Sialkot issue is the continuity of all previous brutal and violent atrocities.And it is the time to start movement against these bloody wild trends. we should not expect justice from any one because now fake testimonies are being planned with the excessive use of money and power backing with political influences.Recommend
Dont have words to describe what i feel and i cant bear to think what the parents of the two boys must feel. I hope no other parent in this world have to go through this. People i know refuse to watch this video as it makes them physically sick, wonder what the parents and family must think as they have no other way of looking. I dont understand the mentally of the crowd of animals standing and getting amused by the whole incident.There may have been another side to the story, and the boys might or might not have been robbers or murderers but we have NO authority whatsoever to brutally batter someone to death in such a inhuman way. I do see how the people carrying out the heinous crime were totally out of their mind and they might have had an reason to do this, however i just don’t understand how the heartless and mindless people standing there came to conclusion that the boys were the criminals. In my eyes people and so called police standing there are equally if not more responsible for the killings as the actuall murderers. No punishment in this world would bring peace to the parents of 2 boys so I pray to Allah to give the worst off all punishments to all involved in hereafter. Ameen.Recommend
All should be hanged involved in this incident, either wild beaters or supportive policemen. Our hearts are burning. Should we expect justice???Recommend
We immigrated to Pakistan over 1 yr ago. We also have 2 young boys and it sickens me to the core to see such events. I do not wish to be associated with Pakistan anymore and I am ashamed to call myself a Pakistani. What has happened is incomprehensible. I really feel sick and I grieve for these young boys. May Allah bless them and give them paradise.Recommend
We immigrated to Pakistan over 1 yr ago. We also have 2 young boys and it sickens me to the core to see such events. I do not wish to be associated with Pakistan anymore and I am ashamed to call myself a Pakistani. What has happened is incomprehensible. I really feel sick and I grieve for these young boys. May Allah bless them and give them paradise.
Bless to tha kaidiyanisRecommend
Other party in this incident is doing a false claim. As per investigations and their unmatched conflicting remarks any sensible person can judge a deep conspiracy behind this criminal act. Lets believe it for a while that those two young boys were highly skilled robbers and murderers, even then “Which law allows to beat them till death without the permission of judiciary?”
We have our poor law and order agencies but now its our duty to never let anyone forget this incident. We all have seen that such issues remains the highlights of press and media but after a month or so every one stops talking over it.
Dear All,
lets have an oath that we will keep this matter alive til the boys get their justice.
JAAG PAKISTAN JAAG…Recommend
THIS IS THE SICKEST THING I HAVE EVER EVER SEEN! shame on all the people who were standing there watching them get bashed to death, instead of stopping the crime scene people decided to take their mobile phones and started recording! MY GOD does ANYONE FEAR ALLAH ANYMORE even if those boys committed a crime that does not mean you beat them to death like, barbarics. i swear to god if i could punish those so called ”POLICE OFFICERS” i would give them the most painfull death of their life!!!!! they murdered children!!!! im disgusted makes me vomit blood, police officers are meant to make you feel safe there is something called a COURT or maybe justice. wether these boys were criminals or not they are in heaven now, they got shaheed in this (paak) month of ramazan. no offense to anyone or the pakistani people but pakistans police is corrupted its all about bribery there more corrupted than the criminals themselves. DEAR PAKISTAN GOVERNMENT PLEASE RETRAIN YOUR POLICE OFFICERS AND PUT SOME COMMON SENSE INTO THEIR BRAIN. for GODS sake.Recommend
I am utterly speechless!! I have only read in books about the jahilliyah of pre-islamic societies and also of the communities who were so steeped in immoral and unethical acts which were eventually wiped off the face of the earth through the wrath of Allah, but I would never in my life have imagined to see with my own eyes such inhumane acts of cruelty such as these.. I am a British born Pakistani and have strived to keep my culture and beliefs alive whilst living in a Westernised country but I am so ashamed and disgraced by the acts of these people that quite frankly I don’t want to be affiliated to this country or it’s people anymore.. Unless there is a complete overhaul of the whole system and political infrastructure of Pakistan I really doubt very much it will survive. I really hope and pray that a dynamic leader such as Imran Khan can lead this country out of this despair and turmoil. A radical reform of the mindset of the people needs to take place, what needs to be addressed is the psyche of the people – what is it that is causing so called muslims to behave worse than barbarians????Recommend
That was really something which should not happened .i just want to say that they are the wild animals not a human being if we said them a human then we just insult this word.they are innocent they hadn’t done any thing so why they killed them.Now I just want to said that they should have justice because they are not the brother of single sister ,they are not the son of single mother or father .they are the brothers ,son of us all.the people who are watching that terible situation they all are the killers .we should have to protest for our brothers,sons .just protes!protest!Recommend
they should have justice if we all are the muslims we should protestRecommend
some peoplesare just looking cant they stop that man.they are just the nkillers.and man is not a man they are killers.really they are not beleiving on day of judgement if they belive then they stop that wild animals.is this is a homeland which are seniors had gives us ,is this is the homeland where muslims are living? I dont think so there is no value of humans life.they just ashamed on their selves they killed that innocent brothers . just assume yourselves in the place of that mother ,in the place of that sister, in the place of that father.i want to make it clear that all that people killed their brothers.they can’t improve their mistakes by protest ,for justice.Recommend
i am sure that there will be a commission and the whole thing will be hushed. these policewalas should be hanged upside down in the public with zabardast chitrol and hanging at the end. i am waiting for the day when the justice will be served.Recommend
Very very shamfull and painful fou humans.Recommend
Asalam-o-Alaikum
No words to say. I just think tomorrow if i go some where and get caught by mistake and get killed. Actually this happend becuase of the police were there. Police was back support for these killers. I pray to ALLAH that these killers get caught and the punishment would be the same.Tie them up in the city and sangsar them. So in the feature no one just stand up in the street and start doing justice. I am father of two daughters. When ever i see my daughters i just feel about two brothers that what would be the situation about their parents. Just imagine a human being got killed in Ramadan A human being is killed where he is in Roza he is Hafiz Quran. I wish if i was a jinn i would have killed them the same way with the group of my kind and people would think what has happen with them where they dont see any one hitting them but still these killers are getting hit. My anger is so high that i could not sleep and in a day after hours to hours just tears come from my eyes for these two brothers.
After this incident i really felt that why Pakistani people are so rude,cunning, Horrible…….
INSHA ALLAH those brothers are enjoying in Jannat no doubt. and ALLAH give patient to their family and the killers get caught and killed.Recommend
I wish i was ther to stop it
no jokes
isnt the floods enough reminder of the fact that Allah is not happy with Pakistan
We as Pakistanis are supposed to set an example for the world as a muslim country
but i guess its not happening anytime soon
Pakistan has one of the world best armys i wish it was the same for the police force
May Allah grant them Jannat and May Allah give their family sabar. Ameen.
My duas are with Pakistan Inshallah everything will be better soon.Recommend
for God sake y every1 in da law is sitting so easily as there’s nothing been done n nothing has happened y they r not becoming conscious about that day when they’ll have 2 pay 4 their deeds. Those brothers let their blood shed but now its our turn if both of those shaheeds will not get justice humainty will b diminished 4m dis world 4ever n tht will b time 4 us 2 face da azab of Allah subhanutallah.if both of them r not going 2 get justice v should b ready 4 tht…Recommend
I have never ever seen such brutality before..it wasnt a movie…it was real and i could only bear to see a minute of the beating..that was enough to give me sleepless nights…Whenever i see young kids on the road i remember the Sialkot incident…Its a moment of grief and we should keep the pain alive until the boys get justice…its a shame that we live in such a country where so many people just stood as mere spectators and witnessed brutality without doing anything about it…the people involved in the vicious act dont deserve to be called humans at all…I wonder how they can live with it…I hope Allah gives sabar to the parents…May He give them strength and justice soon…i as a human share their pain…with all my heart and soul…and cannot help shedding tears when ever i see them on the news..May Allah give them the best place in heaven…thats what they deserve.Recommend
This kind of behaviour is expected by people who live by primitive examples set by primitive religions,and those unable to think and act for themselves,but live by sheepish behaviour following each other,not questioning anything.
I could not watch the video,to even say it was disturbing is an understatement.
I am an X muslim,I have left the whole thing behind me, the country and the religion and never been better.Recommend
Seing these brutal killngs is a reminder to all in the western world that Pakistan should change its name to something more suited to its predicument. How the police allowed these two brothers to be murdered by a mod is unbeknown to many. Pakistan is suffering it’s own fate. I am truly ashamed to be associated with Pakistan. All those involved may to have an equally brutal end and all in the government of pakistan, past and presnt. You ashame humanity at a time you are holding your hand out to the world for aid.
Sickening is too soft a word to use to describe the state of pakistan and may the government, police and officals rest in their fancy homes and live their fancy lives in this short world, my prayers are with the mother and family of the two brothers only and not with the rest of pakistan.
behold the month of forgivness is here!Recommend
May GOd rest their soul in heaven. God will do justice with them.Recommend
very sad.. i even cry .. what police for.. they watching wtf is that..Recommend
The decision by the IG to assign the duties of OSDs to the DPO, SDO, etc involved in the brutal lynching of two innocent brothers is a slap on the face of the justice. Is it the justice – why these police officers must not be tried in the case as they were directly/indirectly involved in this inhuman act of publicly murdering young teenagers in the presence with the support of policemen watching the death with batons by the cruel and wild criminals? It is not a justice to make them OSDs. We protest on this act of IG too. The culprits must be brought to justice at any cost by all means.Recommend
salam to that great mother who said that they were my lions. may allah give her strength to bear this unrepairable lose.youth of pakistan is the only hope for a new pakistan.those boys were among those who were geting good education and were involved in healthy activity of playing cricket if justice wil not be provided to the family of accused then allah may have mercy upon all of us a sad pakistaniRecommend
Aslam o alaikum,
I was shocked to see the video and could not sleep for the whole night.
And I might seem strange to you people but I think our MEDIA was also involved indirectly. You know how? Remember the Karachi incident where criminals were burned alive and what role our media played in that case? Do you remember? Now media is playing different role. Like anyone else Media is also doing a KAROBAAR. They are selling HOT NEWS Only. No one helped those brothers INCLUDING the camera man because he could see his money for making this video and giving his channel some material to trade.
Our people should be aware about how to behave like a Human Being. This is not Jungle. Now, some people are saying that they were Criminals. Even if they were criminals, this was not the right thing to do. Public shouldn’t be allowed to become jury, judge and executioner.
May Allah give Sabar to thier families and Justice to Pakistan.
AmeenRecommend
what have the Pakistanis come to? irrespective of what the brothers did or did not do, they did not deserve that. i am so ashamed. once a proud pakistani, now a dare utter the name Pakistan to anyone. there is no question of the love i feel for Pakistan but it is being destroyed by mobs Like the ones who mercilessly killed the two brothers. how can i take my child there and not fear for her? how can i show her the true Pakistan without her questioning all the injustice? i fear the generations to come will distance themselves from their roots. Fear Allah please i beg of you..Recommend
Dear All,
I have recently been told by a residential of Sialkot that the case is transparent and the two brothers were completely innocent… they were not engaged in so called robbery or murder… it was a setup plotted by the person who was somehow invovled in a argument during cricket match with these two brothers a week earlier to this incident. He pointed fingers at them and claimed they were robbers while they were returning home from the ground… (Allah knows the best)
I have seen other pictures of these brothers, (http://www.zurmat.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/sdfgsdtyhurtyuty.jpg) and interview of their mother (http://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=437500471192) that clearly indicates their background… the both were Hafiz Quran!!
The elder brother is said to be a lion who resisted the terrible torture for more than an hour… whereas a normal person could have died in minutes after horrific merciless crowd initial beatings… one can hardly resist such a shock…
They were Shaheed! and YES, Karbala once again got refreshed! i have never seen such madness before..
But now what? We ALL must demand the media to publish pictures and videos of ALL the criminals who were directly involved in this brutal torture… if the media is reporting that they have captured x-number of people, then SHOW US!!! we want to see their faces for GOD SAKE!
WE NEED JUSTICE!!!Recommend
What taking supreme court to do justice? When they will hang their killers?Recommend
ALL MURDERERS ARRESTED:
See the link below and …. plz plz plz comment on youtube that wt in your opinion should be done to the murderers…it would be a token of love towards two brothers.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TRhi4hvRSh0Recommend
Hasan should bring proof accusing workers of Islam. These boys were killed like Hussain and his family faced brutality in karbla. Now Hasan is favoring Yazid.Recommend
Shame shame on pakistan..
Pakistan is one of the worst country in the world…
There is no law.
All government agencies and politicians are totally corrupt..
Majority of pakistani people are callous, criminals and stupid to allow
zardari to be elected..
Allah wrath on Pakistan will get worse and worse.Recommend
GOD destroyed the pakistan if that kind of thing is hereRecommend
What are the latest update on the case? please share if you have got any information??Recommend
A.O.A
When I saw this incident. I did not take meal. In Short, I will request to authorities, criminals should be given punshment of death on that place where they killed the two innocent brohters in the month of Ramzan. Murdred will go to the hell, Insha Allah. Lanat on murders.Recommend
The person who posted the link of the arrest of the culprits, if it is true, Allah Bless you my brother.
Trust me, tonight I am going to pray to Allah Heaven for you….Recommend
i think it is not way of punshing some one .because in our country law exist and must punish any one according two lawRecommend
It is really disgusting to know that nothing has still been done in justice for the two brothers. we feel no action is being taken, for some reason it is always pakistan that cannot take quick actions and give justice to the people there. Other countries give justice as soon as.It is a shame to the nation god knows why the PM is not doing much about it. But worse is the police stood there while they have been killed. I am ashamed and its any wonder why english people say we are terrorists because we behave worse then terrorists even they dont give people that much pain when they kill people they blow them up in one go but these brothers had suffered and died a really bad death that nobody deserves.Recommend
This is exactly what’s wrong with Pakistani people. The killers are spreading a story that sounds right out off a bad Indian movie. First kill them then cook up an unbelievable story to protect your heinous acts.
How believable is that; a hafiz, also leading nightly travih prayers, and not to mention both brothers were award winning students were actually women stealing robbers? And specially robbing Milkmen, of what, milk?
No wonder Allah is sending Floods, earthquake, Taliban, Al Qaida, and drones attacks your way. As my wife usually says “ab Allah khood aa ker lathy to marnay say raha.”Recommend