Balochistan law and order case: FC will not go scot-free, warns apex court

Published: July 25, 2012

FC says insurgents dressed in their uniforms commit acts of terrorism, CJ rejects reply. PHOTO: APP/FILE

ISLAMABAD: 

With a back and forth between the Supreme Court and the Frontier Corps (FC) having continued for months over the Balochistan law and order case, it seems things are finally set to wrap up – and the FC is not likely to get off lightly.

The apex court is likely to conclude the case today (Wednesday), and the police and bureaucracy are just as likely to come under fire. In Tuesday’s hearing, FC Inspector General (IG) Maj Gen Obaidullah Khattak in particular faced the court’s ire for failing to comply with orders in the case.

A three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, rejecting the FC IG’s report, stated that “We will give a negative report about the officers (in the verdict), but then it will be up to the government to take action.”

Later, the Balochistan home secretary informed the bench that insurgent groups are behind the recent mining blasts, but assured the court that forces have been deployed at various points to control the situation and keep an eye on insurgent activities.

But even the mention of such deployment further angered the chief justice, who said, “We gave you details about each and every person, gave evidence against the FC’s involvement in abductions – was it a futile exercise?”

In the middle of this, it was unlikely that the FC IG would be granted police powers by the court to conduct a door-to-door search of missing persons in the province – and when advocate Raja Irshad sought these powers on behalf of Maj Gen Khattak, Justice Jawwad S Khawaja dismissed it, saying the FC was already enjoying police powers.

“Neither the FC, nor the Military Intelligence (MI), the Inter Services Intelligence (ISI), or the defence authorities are doing the right job. So it’s fine for the court to dispose of this case and set you people free to do whatever you want,” the chief justice said ironically, adding an early verdict of sorts: “It is a total failure and a constitutional breakdown because no one is willing to deliver.”

The court then told Irshad to submit in writing that the FC was in no position to maintain law and order adding that they should let the law take its course. It also asked the FC to surrender people nominated in FIRs of murder and abduction, saying that they would be set free if they were found innocent.

Meanwhile, Maj Gen Khattak continued to deny any FC involvement in the case of eight missing people. The list of the eight people had been provided by the SC, which asked the FC to present them before the court.

Justice Khawaja remarked that the list had been produced after carefully examining witnesses and circumstantial evidence. He observed that civil society and media had to visit Dera Bugti and submit a report about ‘no go areas’ but that no such report had arrived before the court as yet.

Meanwhile, Balochistan Advocate General Amanullah Kanrani at this juncture submitted the contrary statement that though the visits could not be arranged, “There is not a single no-go area in Balochistan.”

A sceptical chief justice, however, said that if the provincial government was so convinced, it should give in writing a statement that it has not failed to establish the writ of the state.

“We are left with no option, we want to avoid it, but since you are not delivering, we will now pass a negative order against all stakeholders,” the chief justice said.

Later adjourning the case till today, the CJP directed the inspector general of police, the FC IG, defence authorities, and federal and provincial governments to submit statements indicating that they have failed to ensure law and order.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 25th, 2012.

on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook

Reader Comments (8)

  • gp65
    Jul 25, 2012 - 3:37AM

    ““We gave you details about each and every person, gave evidence against the FC’s involvement in abductions – was it a futile exercise?””

    If he the CJ or prosecutor? Is it his job to give evidence?

    Recommend

  • FAN
    Jul 25, 2012 - 3:48AM

    it look’s like that the SC has no power against the Boots. . . ;-(

    Recommend

  • Jibran
    Jul 25, 2012 - 5:21AM

    “SC says it will leave it up to govt to take action against involved officers.”

    Shameful! The CJP pounces on civilians, and for military officials he throws the ball back in the court of the civilians. Once a PCO judge, always a PCO judge.

    Recommend

  • Voice of Baloch
    Jul 25, 2012 - 7:27AM

    Bold move by CJ but still I don’t see any hope in any institution in Pakistan.

    Recommend

  • afzaalkhan
    Jul 25, 2012 - 9:25AM

    @jibran

    You guys ask SC to let govt work, when SC let it in govt hand u still have problem LOL

    Recommend

  • Ismael
    Jul 25, 2012 - 2:04PM

    So that is it? CJ helpless in Balochistan!

    Which forum is now left for the families and relatives of missing persons? Their agony and wait will surely end when the tortured and mutilated bodies of their loved ones are thrown on road sides!

    Recommend

  • Judgal Baloch
    Jul 25, 2012 - 11:54PM

    All of them knows that who is the supreme power in Pakistan but its looks like SC wanted to make bleave the World that no one above the Law,,,,,But Law himself become helpless to those families who were haveing last hope on SC,,,,,SO what NOW?

    Recommend

  • Adnan Sarparrah
    Jul 26, 2012 - 12:01AM

    All the efforts of Supreme court are praiseworthy and should be seen with a encouraging view. In fact Supreme court is the only institute who is doing anything for missing people. However a lot more is yet to be done. Supreme court disqualified the chief executive of the country when he failed to comply with courts orders time and time again. Now a two star general, IG FC, who is servant of people is defying orders of Apex court again and again and Court has not taken any action against him. Court can ask govt. to dismiss him just like it ordered dismissal of DG Rangers Sindh, after rangers personnel killed an unarmed boy in cold blood.

    We hail the efforts of out honorable chief justice and hope that he will take action against the strong paramilitary forces bosses in the best interests of Pakistan…

    Recommend

More in Balochistan