In what appears to be a close-to-reality assessment, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has said that Pakistan’s expenses will exceed its income by Rs1,13 trillion this year- an amount which is Rs276 billion higher than what the government claims.
The Fund, in its latest World Economic and Financial report, also warns that economic activity will remain weak due to devastating floods and recent urban riots and there are entrenched expectations of high inflation.
However, Finance Ministry’s official spokesman was not available to comment on the latest IMF assessment that has put a question mark on economic indicators of the financial managers. Presently, Pakistan’s two top economic managers, Finance Minister Dr Abdul Hafeez Shaikh and Deputy Chairman Planning Commission Dr Nadeem ul Haque are on leave and in the United States on a private visit.
There has been inordinate delay in reforming the power sector and revival of Pakistan International Airlines and Pakistan Railways. These two economic managers are responsible for ensuring reforms in these areas.
According to the IMF report, this year Pakistan’s budget deficit is expected to remain at 5.3% of the total national output or Rs1,126 billion. The Finance Ministry has assessed that the budget deficit would not be more than 4% of the national output or Rs850 billion.
However, independent experts term the 4% projection “underestimate” that does not reflect natural budget deficit in the aftermath of the 18th Amendment in the constitution.
An $11.3 billion bailout package had been terminated in September after remaining suspended for 16 months due to Pakistan’s inability to deliver on budget deficit and revenue targets and failure to reform the power sector.
The IMF has said that Pakistan’s official reserves may fall to $12.9 billion from $14.8 billion of the last year. These reserves include $9 billion of IMF loans and $1 billion of Saudi Arabia and China ($500 million each) parked in the central bank.
The IMF has clubbed Pakistan with Libya and said these are the territories having the most difficult business environments.
It further has said that the Pakistani economy will grow at a rate of 3.8% against official estimates of 4.2%. Inflation is expected to remain at 14% for the consecutive fourth year. The growth in money in circulation has been estimated at 18.3% against last year’s level of 15.9%.
On the external front, the IMF has projected that exports of goods and services would remain even below last year’s level but the imports would further surge. It has estimated $30.2 billion exports, both goods and services and projected imports at $46.1 billion against last year’s imports of $43.3 billion.
The Fund has estimated the current account deficit-gap between external receipts and payments at $3.9 billion or 1.7% of the Gross Domestic Product.
The IMF’s assessment comes just a fortnight ahead of the IMF delegation that is arriving to assess the country’s economic health and to suggest remedial measures for putting the economy back on track. The IMF mission would hold talks under Article–IV of the Pak-IMF relationship agreement.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 27th, 2011.
COMMENTS (3)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
We have never had a budget deficit lower than 5.5% of the GDP in this govt's era
Mr Rana,
I apologize. The OFD is estimated at 5.3% of GDP. However, I don't know what that assumes for the provinces. I recall 4% became 4.6% the moment the provinces came out with their free-spending budgets.
But if you subtract total revenues (excluding grants) of 12.4% of GDP from General Government Expenditure (including net lending) of 18.7% of GDP, the deficit works out to 6.3% of GDP.
But grants should be included. Don't know if there are any.
Mr Rana,
Your fiscal deficit estimate for this year is incorrect. Please read the IMF report again. It is saying it will slip to more than 6% and many others think it will go higher.
IMF policy recommendations under the Article IV consultation discussion are not binding on Pakistan since there is no arrangement. Most, even in the Ministry of Finance, will not bother to read the report, far less understand what it says.
The IMF can say what they want to say and we will ignore them until we run out of foreign exchange (again!) and they grab us by the throat. Then we will make some false promises, the economy will turn around and we will abandon the program mid-way. The whole cycle will start all over again.