Malala Yousufzai is globally considered a youth icon, an activist for women’s right to education, equality and liberty, and is yet seen with suspicion, mistrust and doubt by some in her own country. For many, her story starts when she was shot point blank on her way home from school in a mini bus in Mingora. The news spread like wildfire and the world held its breath as she struggled for her life at hospitals in Peshawar and then Birmingham. Miraculously, she survived. Since then, she has been internationally recognised and presented with a number of awards and prizes, leading up to being considered a favourite for the Nobel Peace Prize.
Despite her international acclaim and recognition, many in Pakistan believe that she is being given unnecessary coverage in the media and promoted by the West for its ulterior motives. They point to the double standards of the West and claim that many others who died or got injured as a result of terrorism in Pakistan and other troubled areas in the world are not given anywhere near the attention that Malala receives. Furthermore, there are those who see this whole episode as being orchestrated or used to malign Pakistan and Islam.
Malala’s story, however, did not begin when she was shot. On numerous occasions, since writing her famous diary for the BBC, she has presented her thoughts on issues such as girls’ education, women’s place in society, social justice, equality and liberty, dangerous notions in this part of the world. She exposed those, who in the garb of religion, were trying to restrict women to their homes, closing doors not just to the outside world, but also to their self-emancipation, and to their material and spiritual wellbeing. Malala’s crime was that she raised her voice against this — but importantly, she was the only one to roar like a lioness among the silence of the lambs.
It is not, therefore, because she was shot, but why she was shot that makes her worthy of the admiration, reverence and respect bestowed upon her. Those unable to understand this distinction merely demonstrate their own lack of emotional intelligence and cluelessness. There are, of course, other very emotive and pressing reasons why Malala invokes emotive sentiments. Attacking a child is considered grotesque in even the most violent of cultures and in Malala, a young, middle class girl from a small town, most Pakistanis can see one of their own. Furthermore, I shall argue that there are also deeper ideological underpinnings to the reaction that Malala evokes, both of astonishment and of banishment.
The confusion over Malala epitomises a primeval struggle between the forces of enlightenment and obscurity in this region that over the centuries, evolved a particular understanding of religion. Religion was supposed to free the mind of the believer from the lust of petty gains and the fear of repercussions for following his/her dreams. The prophets that have gone by, one after the other, challenged the status quo, against great odds and liberated humans from the chains of slavery, both mental and physical. Yet today, in the name of god, people are being subjugated and atrocities are being committed. Those like Malala, who challenge the demi-gods of the era, the fascists who accept none but their own interpretation of the scriptures, are termed apostates and traitors.
Malala is accused by some for promoting western values, but she is not the first one in this region, who raised a voice for her basic rights. Despite the stereotypical perception of Pashtun culture, there has always been a desire for peace, enlightenment and education. The greatest Pashtun leader of the 20th century, Khan Ghaffar Khan, started his nationalist Khudai Khidmatgar movement by establishing a network of schools and insisted on education and non-preferential treatment for girls. The thousands of followers of the Khan amply demonstrated yearning among Pashtun society for non-violence, equality and liberty and this is why, many today, especially females, look up to Malala to continue this struggle.
Malala is not necessarily drawing inspiration from western philosophy, heroes and history alone, for she is the torchbearer of traditions going back millennia that were nurtured and kept alive in our own land by the likes of Bulleh Shah, Rehman Baba, Shah Latif Bhittai, Khushal Khan Khattak and many others. It may come as a surprise to some, but the truth is that despite decades of social engineering and the turn to conservatism, somewhere, even if ever so slightly, the light of the more tolerant teachings of Islam propagated by the great Sufi saints and mystics in our beleaguered land, flickers and Malala is the embodiment of that.
Faced with conflict and strife along the lines of religion, ethnicity and caste, these great social reformers presented humanism as a cure for social ills. It is this great lineage of thought, still embedded in our historic, cultural and social heritage that holds the key for resolving the problems we face today. This shared inheritance is what connects us with Malala, even if we cannot find the courage to do what she did.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 10th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (15)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Omer Ali Khan: You should go and live in Wazirstan with your family,parents and sisters,among TTP for a year,and then come back and advise us(if you go or come back)
Mr. Writer you have answered your title questions in article.
Malala raised her voice against Taliban's policies at the cost of her life. She got almost killed, but for god's intervention. How many Pakistanis came in open and faced Taliban head on ? Still there are conspiracy theorists Pakistanis who think Malala was planted by western powers. How many Pakistanis are willing to risk their lives like Malala ? Anyone in Pakistani government who has the guts of Malala?
Excellent write-up - very eloquently articulated and hits the nail on the head!
Malala is the beacon not only for Pakhtoons but whole of humanity. If we can't keep her then let her become an Universal citizen.
Malala has already done more for the tarnished image of Pakistan than all the politicians, bureaucrats, clergy, soldiers and media put together. In my view Malala has already achieved a status that the Nobel Peace Prize, if awarded, would just be a confirmation of this young icon's bravery and determination...........and Pakistan needs to be proud of this.
Mr. Rafiq,
You are absolutely right. A nation needs right examples & role models to emulate. Unfortunately Pakistan has had wrong ideology and role models. It's been shunning a good path, and embracing the bad.
Even if 20-30% of Pakistan regards Malala as a western agent, they'd have repeated the same folly they did with Abdus Salam - Not embracing their best, brightest. I see people wanting to embrace Afia Siddique instead!! How horrible.
Malala is being respected worldwide, not just because Taliban shot her (though that gave her publicity & recognition). She is respected more for her outspoken support for the right of women to do what they want to do - as an equal of men.
At the bottom of it all is the recognition of humanity, craving for equality that is universal. Nothing specific to Pakistan. World finds a great icon in Malala because she is the most visible and impactful speaker on the subject.
If she wins a nobel for that - it is only just.
Mr.Rafiq Very nice to read about Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan in a piece about Malala. Ghaffar Khan and Maulana Azad are amongst the greatest of our heroes.
Malala the drama queen is Nayira of this decade. Only media persons love her in Pakistan and every one knows why
Malala is a symbol of courage and enlightenment. Only the forces of darkness, and the apologists who somehow side with those forces, are maligning the status of this innocent girl. I have also seen many people from her area who r simply against her out of jealousy, linking her to either CIA or ISI. They may be justified in their jealousy, for Malala did what most of the people of swat could not have even thought of; i.e challenging the cruel militant mindset.
Malala Yousufzai is the pride of the nation. An epitome of courage and bravery like no other.
Malala should inspire because there are too many impotent men around,hiding behind the veil of fear of terrorists.Because a little girl has taken on monsters that they should be fighting instead.
A great young girl that I would love to call my daughter. God bless her and lead her to greater things.
Beautiful article and well written. Malala is a symbol for all who wish for progress, enlightenment, and education. Social regressivism is not a tenable position in the long run, and hopefully the recent push-back against decades of indoctrination will start bearing fruit in the coming years.