Identity crisis: For lack of a surname

Published: August 25, 2013
Thousands of children can’t go to school because they do not know their father’s name.

Thousands of children can’t go to school because they do not know their father’s name.

LAHORE: 

A few rays of sunlight creep into in a small, dark room hit earlier by a spell of load-shedding. In this room, one of two that form part of a makeshift school, 9-year-old *Akmal sits on a rickety desk with a second-hand Urdu qaaida.

This is perhaps his first encounter with a book. One of the many vulnerable children born to commercial sex workers in Shahi Mohalla Lahore, his reason for never having been to school is not just poverty. The reason is darker and more complicated. Akmal does not know his father’s name and so does not have a B form.

Thousands of Akmals are unknown, unregistered and invisible. Registration laws are a tightened noose not just for the children of sex workers but also orphaned or abandoned children, making options of a better life limited for them.

“I want to be a teacher when I grow up,” says the naive boy. In absence of a legal identity, the probability is less that he will be able to go beyond the initial Jugnu Literacy Program taught at this small centre in the infamous Heera Mandi. “We have been trying to sensitize nearby public schools to admit these children so that they have a chance at a better life. But in absence of a B form and with the stigma attached, they are not readily accepted,” says Lubna Tayyab, founder of the NGO called SHEED running the small program, herself born and bred in Shahi Mohalla.

“Since generations, women of my family have been in the flesh trade. I don’t want my daughter to have the same life. If she doesn’t get an education, how will she get out of here?” says *Samina, a sex worker and mother of three.

Of identity and crisis

“Unregistered children, whether of commercial sex workers or otherwise, can be at a highly disadvantageous position in several ways, especially those belonging to socially excluded communities.

They don’t figure in government planning. For all developmental purposes such as education, health and social welfare services, without birth registration and due to the inordinate delays in census, most government planners are unaware of certain population groups and demographic changes, thus, they are more likely to miss out on social services,” says Sohail Abbasi, Child Protection Specialist, Unicef.

As Abbasi rightly points out, without birth registration, these children lack credible identity and age determination.

The children who come into conflict with law, or are trafficked internally or externally, or are married at an early age, or are exposed to hazardous labour will all face difficulties as they cannot legally prove their identity and/or age. A similar fate awaits unregistered children claiming their rightful inheritance or facing custody determination by a court of law.

“The government links certain services, such as, admission in schools, issuance of domiciles, proof of citizenship and later CNICs, with birth registration. Therefore, children without legal identity and determination of age are in a highly disadvantageous position,” points out Abbasi.

NADRA’s version and the way forward

The National Database and Registration Authority (NADRA) says that it has facilitated registration of such children at a policy level and eased the condition of providing a guardianship certificate.

On a Rs20 affidavit, NADRA says, any supposed name of parentage can be given by the orphanage/guardian so that the same may be entered in the father/mother field. For this NADRA acquired  fatwas from Saudi Arabia and Iran which support the idea of giving any supposed name (which cannot be called a fake name), giving the benefit of doubt that the names cited are indeed of the father/mother or guardian of the child. No birth certificate is required from abandoned or fatherless children for registration with NADRA.

NADRA encourages orphanages to register themselves with the authority. They have so far 31 orphanages that are registered with them, and as per their given record there are 6,045 children residing in these orphanages.

Through these orphanages these children can apply for issuance of CNIC/NICOP/CRC. Recently, NADRA chairman has also ordered the issuance of SMART cards (free of charge) to these children.

The answer, then, may very well lie with policymakers to not just facilitate registration of every Pakistani citizen but also work on sensitisation of masses so that they realise the importance of becoming registered citizens and not unnumbered just shadows lurking in the dark.

*Names changed to protect identities.

Published in The Express Tribune, August 25th, 2013.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (3)

  • ignorantways
    Aug 25, 2013 - 12:52PM

    2 , 3 points

    why not we should try to reduce identity crisis in parallel with registration of such children ?

    of course we cant or say we dont want . . not only Heera Mandi Lahore but Multan, Sargodha and Karachi also participating equally in this identity crisis.

    Democratic and Army Governments yet failed to provide education to say legal (halal) children who living with families, even Capital of Pakistan having thousands of children who aren’t going to school, they cant afford even primary education regardless of plus point that they are registered citizens of Pakistan . . . .those children working for pathetic elite and upper middle class of Islamabad , cleaning their homes, washing their cars, going markets to buying goods for those honorable literate people etc etc . .

    so dont expect and dont recommend any thing to Government of Pakistan.

    yes individually we have lots of examples but unfortunately no positive change at large grounds, and they will suffer more !

    Recommend

  • A. Khan
    Aug 25, 2013 - 3:40PM

    This is a ridiculous policy on the government’s part. Its not these children’s fault that they don’t have a Form B. But it is the right of every child to get an education. The government should change this archaic policy.

    Recommend

  • Aug 25, 2013 - 3:47PM

    Really a big issue. Government and Non Government orgs should launch awareness campaigns to sensitize for registration

    Recommend

More in Pakistan