A growing sense of maturity may finally be pervading the fraught Pakistan-India relationship. On October 23, an Indian Army helicopter accidentally crossed over into Pakistani airspace. Naturally, Pakistani officials, not knowing the cause of the incursion at first, forced the plane to land and detained the four Indian officials on board. Thankfully, sanity prevailed. The hotline that exists between the director-generals of military operations for the two countries was employed and it turned out that the Indians had strayed into our territory by mistake, most likely because of bad weather. The Line of Control, which demarcates the border between the two countries, can be easy to cross given that it is not a straight, dividing line. Accidents like this are bound to take place and by swiftly releasing the Indians, Pakistan has made it far more likely that its soldiers will be released if they accidentally cross the line in the future.
Heartening though this episode may be, it should also serve as a wake-up call to both Pakistan and India. Both are quick to seize on men who have mistakenly crossed the border, both by land and sea. Fishermen in particular are detained for an indefinite period and often denied consular access. If there is one thing this incident has taught us, it is that not even hi-tech radar systems can stop all incursions. Poor fishermen in rudimentary boats will make the same mistake far more regularly. For them, mercy not incarceration should be the order of the day.
Let us hope that the quick resolution of something that could have turned far uglier were it not for the level-headed thinking from both sides will serve as a model for the future. Incidents like this have the potential to spiral out of control as accusations about spying fly back and forth. Peace between Pakistan and India still may not be at hand but initial baby steps have been taken, with foreign minister-level talks and agreements on trade. The speedy resolution to the chopper incident can only help build trust and enable the process to inch forward. And that is far more important than boasting that we have Indian military personnel in custody.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 25th, 2011.
COMMENTS (7)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Pakistan has blundered by returning helicopter in hurry. After all what was the hurry?Has India ever reciprocated in this manner. Even the camels and vaccines they go across border never returned. It takes months to negotiate with Indian yonder back civilian who by mistake cross the border. We should not forget such acts are basically come under surveillance .Pakistan will soon realize that there was no hurry to return the helicopter
Promptly returning the chopper was a nice gesture -- unfortunately ruined by breaking/stealing security data from their on board computer.
The soldiers shouldn't have been released without a full civilian government investigation. The fishermen on the other hand, need to be let go so they can return to their families and provide a livelihood for the millions that depend on them.
Fishermen should be told of their mistakes and let go there and then to go back to the waters of their country, to detain these poor people is a crime in itself!
You rightly point out the plight of poor fishermen in your article.The helicopter incident is a good opportunity for the Pakistan government to use the goodwill gesture shown by having immediately released the chopper and the crew.Hundreds of innocent fishermen on both sides are kept prisoners without giving any trial or reason of their detention,therefore they all deserve an early release,removing a useless contention between the two countries.