The political positions of the two leading parties in the country have come full circle since the 1990s. In a letter written to the eponymous leader of the Pakistan Muslim League Nawaz, President Asif Ali Zardari asked Nawaz Sharif not to criticise the army or the government.
The letter, which was highly critical of the PML-N leadership in polite but pointed language, was made public through a press release by the Punjab government’s information department.
Using references to the highly divisive politics of the 1990s, the president appeared to be playing the role of an elder statesman, asking the leader of the country’s largest opposition party to focus on helping the people of the one province that the PML-N governs rather than concerning themselves with criticising the federal government’s every move.
“The nation does not need provocative speeches, but rather a treatment for dengue fever,” the president’s letter was quoted as saying, in a reference to the dengue epidemic that has plagued Punjab over the past few days.
(Read: Alarming proportions - ‘Dengue out of Punjab government’s control’)
Teaching hospitals in Lahore, the provincial capital, report receiving as many as 600 dengue fever patients a day. A Pakistan Peoples Party spokesperson in Punjab claimed that 10,000 people had been affected by the disease so far.
The president also asked Sharif to spare a thought for the flood victims in Sindh, Zardari’s home province.
“If you do not want to visit Sindh because of me, visit it for the sake of the poor, marooned people of the province,” the president was quoted as having written.
The president even offered Sharif his personal residence in Nawabshah for his stay in Sindh and implied that his hospitality would be a repayment in kind for Zardari’s stay in Kholi (a prison), a reference to the time that Zardari was imprisoned on corruption charges (that were never proven) during the Sharif administration in the 1990s.
“Let’s come together to support the nation and get her out from the clutches of natural calamities,” the press release quoted the president as having said.
(Read: President visits flood hit areas, ensures relief and rehabilitation for affectees)
Allusions to plots
Yet the main thrust of the president’s letter appeared to be to convince Sharif of the need to support democracy in the country and not take any actions to destabilise it. In veiled terms, the president appeared to be referring to reports that have emerged in recent months that the PML-N is planning to seek early parliamentary polls before the March 2012 Senate elections.
Zardari reminded Sharif that the ouster of the PPP government in 1996 by then-President Farooq Leghari gave the PML-N a two-thirds majority in the National Assembly but did not secure democracy in the country, leading ultimately to the military coup by General Pervez Musharraf.
“Democracy requires a hundred years to take hold in a nation but it can be destroyed in an instant,” the president was quoted as saying. “Come out of the world of imagination, idealism and adventurism or else there will come a time when neither you will be able to call me in Kholi nor will I be able to call you.”
That veiled reference to the possibility of another military coup was accompanied with the request to Sharif to stop criticising the army, something that the PML-N leader has been doing very frequently and publicly since the May 2 US raid on Abbottabad.
(Read: ‘Zardari conspiring to create Nawaz-Army rift’)
Zardari asked Sharif to remember what the president considered to be the achievements of the PPP-led government, including the restoration of the 1973 constitution, freedom of expression, and the institutionalisation of the supremacy of parliament and the independence of the judiciary.
Published in The Express Tribune, September 9th, 2011.
COMMENTS (20)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
What is this about this guy Sharif? His obsession with yellow cab schemes!!!
The only answer of PML-N to the financial woos of Punjab is the out-dated scam-of-the-century Yellow cab scheme. Mr. Sharif, is this the best your financial gurus can come up with? In other countries, governments undertake economic recovery by proper taxing, industrial growth, and infrastructure investment. In Punjab, you approach has been diverting resources from development projects to building the Raiwind Estate, without increasing the income of the province. Then you asked the Federal government to foot your bills (with money taxed from the Sindh). Is this how provinces are run? Yet you and your cronies have the nerves to shout the rhetoric of good governance!
The country doesn't prosper under PPP or PML-N. Both parties have been shown up by Workers party in Brazil and AKP in Turkey who did well as novices. The key difference is that they learned how to address basic problems by first governing at local level. Pakistani political parties do not understand that local government is essential for their own improvement. If they do not deliver the goods, the people may demand the army to return. Already one can see Musharraf's popularity lasted much longer than that of President Zardari. Mr Nawaz is only higher in popularity than the president because he is not leading the government.
Mr president if u investigate last flood how your members safe there land and allow to go water where poor people live.
Mr President appoint NAB chairman to investigate all these cases
Mr President implement all decision of supreme court
Iam sure these lives are safed if proper investigation is allowed for last flood and proper investigation are not delibratelly made by your conduct by not appointing NAB chairman and by not implemented Supreme court
Good reply by President Zardari, Pak Army is relay patriotic
The "National" leader of Pakistan is distributing Yellow cabs in Punjab, bought with taxes collected in Sindh, when Sindh is drowning under floods.
Wow this Zardari guy is now the best friends of the Army, wonder what he has to do
You both just leave us alone .......... Go to your home countries Saudi and Switzerland and let us live in peace ............
Instead of bashing and blaming each other we should all help the victims in Sindh. The richest and largest province of Pakistan should help the poor flood victims of Sindh. By doing so, PML-N would increase its popularity in Sindh and become a more national party rather than the party of upper Punjab. There is no reason or excuse not to speak with one voice for the poor people of Sindh. After all they are Pakistanis too and more than 60% population of the country should not have an indifferent or selfish attitude at this time. The irony is all Pakistanis accepted the aid for flood victims last year from abroad. Now only one province is affected and nobody seems interested!
The democratic bubble is about to bust.
Yellow cab scheme in the past totally failed and many were seen on the roads in Afghanistan and some were also smuggled to India. Mr. Nawaz Sharif simply wants to fool which we already are and as such will again vote for these used cartridges. It is time to wake up in the coming elections and try to bring in those from all political parties who have never been tried. It is a gamble but this is what we are used to. Here I don't mean to gamble on Mr. Imran Khan due to his rantings of comedy type in talk shows. I agree with the advise of the President to these technical tugs though he himself is not clear on many issues.
As said by Mian Sb: He accused President Zardari of promoting his “own and party’s interest” and also went on to saying that Pakistan should be saved from Zardari’s corruption.
Instead of Zardari sb Mian sb's capabilities should be considered..
And being a Punjabi I must say that as far as dis integration and / or division is concerned our province is already socially, morally, ethically DEAD thats why acts of ethnic, religious killings and abductions are seen!!
And what was th e President doing last year when their were mega floods in Pakistan?Press reports at that time stated he was touring his to his family's chateau in France and touring Europe.. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/08/06/AR2010080606404.html
Having stated the above, it is for the local administration to help the people affected by floods
Conveniently nawaz sharif forgets to mention how his chief ministership and assumption of PML's leadership was also due to another more notorious military dictator
Did Zardari say this on a special short visit to Pakistan?
My dear President!!! Instead of seeking help of Leader of the Opposition Party, please come forward and help victims yourself. Rather get some of your gold encashed and spent out for the well being of Flood victims and save their lives and valuables.
hmmmm Zardari what are u doing for the Flood Victims ???
Ohhhhhh Flood Tax yes yes u did alot already so leave the rest to telling others what to do or WAIT for United nations .