Iran’s lack of cooperation irks Pakistan


Sumera Khan June 09, 2010
Iran’s lack of cooperation irks Pakistan

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan is developing serious concerns about the lack of cooperation from Iran regarding the investigation into the assassination attempt on Islamabad’s ambassador to Tehran M B  Abbasi, says a high ranking Foreign Office official.

“It’s been more than a month we’ve been issuing Tehran with reminders but Tehran is yet to get back to us with even a plausible explanation for the delay,” he says. And this lukewarm response, he confides, can unnecessarily raise suspicions in Islamabad and create a trust deficit. “We’ve always cooperated with Iran vis-a-vis Jundullah so obviously, we expected them to reciprocate,” he complains.

So grave are the reservations developing in Islamabad, the official is expecting Pakistan to get tough. However, Foreign Office spokesman Abdul Basit insists that Islamabad is “confident” that Iran will share its findings with Pakistan as soon as the investigation is concluded. Meanwhile, Iran’s ambassador to Pakistan did not respond to The Express Tribune’s requests for information about updates on the investigation.

Despite the Foreign Office’s professions, say foreign policy experts, the relationship between the two countries has not been hunky dory despite the many agreements inked by the two to improve border security. Iran has long held Jundullah chief Abdolmalek Rigi responsible for over a dozen terrorist attacks inside its territory, the last being the attack on Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps in October last year, which killed more than 40.

While Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmedinejad was guarded in his response at the time, the Iranian Foreign Minister was not so circumspect. “[The group responsible for the attack] cross into Iran illegally; they are based in Pakistan and the hands of those behind the crimes in southeast Iran must be cut,” he said at the time. In a subsequent visit to Pakistan, Iranian Interior Minister Mostafa Mohammad Najjar demanded Pakistan handover Rigi. But Islamabad’s assurances that Rigi was not in Pakistan and that Jundullah was not using Pakistan as a springboard for attacks in Iran fell on deaf ears. Even so, the Foreign Office kept insisting that “forces” were out to “spoil” Islamabad-Tehran relations but that the ties were strong enough to survive such attempts.

Rigi was finally arrested in February this year, an arrest both countries attempted to take the credit for. March saw the release of Iranian cultural attaché Heshmatollah Attarzadeh who had been kidnapped in 2008. Islamabad insisted that Attarzadeh had been taken to Afghanistan and that Pakistan had used its resources and intelligence network to recover the abducted diplomat. But Iranian ambassador to Pakistan Mashallah Shakiri told the Pakistani media that Attarzadeh’s release was secured by the Iranian security forces and that Pakistan had not helped a jot.

Published in the Express Tribune, June 10th, 2010.

COMMENTS (1)

Neutral Pakistani | 14 years ago | Reply Irks Pakistan? Wow, that is now something. Several dozen Iranian diplomats haven been KILLED in Pakistan, while their killers are still roaming around in the country and now Pakistan is irked on an incident which all public evidence shows it to be of a private nature. The ambassador in question had run into a fight with an Afghan over their turn to use a sports machine at a local body building and fitness club. The fight got sore and the Afghan attacked the ambassador as he was exiting the club. Furthermore Iranian police was apt enough to arrest the attacker and he is right now in custody and being interrogated. Any kind of interrogation takes time and effort and Iran is very good at it, if you look at their history of security work. They have been successful at places others can not even dream eg. against terrorism and counter intelligence against CIA. So Iranians can be trusted to pursue the investigation and get to the bottom of it. The same can not be said about Pakistan. While dozens of Iranians have been killed in Pakistan, not much has been done by the government of Pakistan to bring the groups and individuals responsible to account. It is very selfish if Pakistan goes and demands of Iran what Pakistan has consistently denied to Iranians. But Iran is a much more mature country than Pakistan can ever be. While Iranians were being killed in Pakistan and even under Taliban controlled Afghanistan, Iranians never retaliated against Pakistanis living in Iran. Such is their hospitality. Pakistan should not make itself anymore shameful by pointing fingers at Iran. We are already deep in shame from having become a terror house to a hypocrite. Losing the few friends we have in our neighborhood is the last thing Pakistani government would want to do. They should be thankful of Iran for arresting the assailant and should request Iran for sharing the result of the investigation whenever the investigation is over. Being "irked" certainly does not help. Iran is fighting a larger game here than Pakistan can ever comprehend. They have take into account whether the attack was an innocent fight or a bigger conspiracy against Iran Pakistan relations. Iran has alot of enemies and they are big and powerful and while Pakistan might be just a client state, Iran is not and they work for their national interests. I am sure involvement of Pakistan in the investigation process would ruin everything since Pakistani officials and leaders are extremely corrupt and incapable of running a good investigation at all. We have seen the result of such an investigation for the murder of Benazir Bhuto. And at the end I have one question for those irked by Iran: put yourself in their shows and ask yourself, how would you have felt if dozens of Pakistani diplomats and hundreds of Pakistanis had been killed in cold blood in Iran by shady groups? Because that is how Pakistan has treated its Iranian guests. So this foreign office official should first go and complain about US interference in Pakistan and the damage it has done to our country before alienating another friend of Pakistan on the order of his masters. In fact this official should be investigated if he really is working for Pakistani interests or that of some other powers who want to see Pakistan an isolated and weak state. Such allegations coming out of Pakistan at a time when the gas pipeline deal has been signed really should be of concern. As for as Jundallah goes, Iranians are still very much Khaffa for they believe it was Pakistan which has provided CIA the ground for training Jundallah. An allegation not proven but totally plausible. And remember that there many numerous anti-Iran groups with violent ideology working in Pakistan while there in no anti-Pakistan group in Iran.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ