Mani bashes ‘Big Three’ draft

Raises governance issues including lack of transparency, conflict of interest .


Fawad Hussain January 24, 2014
According to Mani, the ICC should discuss the Woolf Report with a view to implement its recommendations as soon as possible. PHOTO: ICC

KARACHI: Former International Cricket Council (ICC) president Ehsan Mani has warned boards against the draft proposal that pushes for dominance of the sport’s governing body by India, Australia and England.

In his note, shared with The Express Tribune, Mani said he had reviewed the draft proposal and analysed that it would adversely affect the sport if it was to come through.

“The authors of the Paper (Board of Control for Cricket in India, England and Wales Cricket Board and Cricket Australia) benefit significantly in financial terms from their proposals and promote their own self-interests,” noted the former president.

“The directors, president, chief executive and ICC management have had no role and input in the draft.”

Mani observed that the three boards said they will provide greater leadership and stability to the ICC and its Members in return for powers of the ICC Board. However, they failed to demonstrate how they will do this in any meaningful way.

“They plan to make significant financial gains and control the working of the ICC to the exclusion of the other members.”

He noted that the objectives and challenges identified in the paper are not new and can be dealt with by the existing ICC Board.

Proposal ‘fundamentally flawed’ 

Mani added that the proposal of revenue-sharing that is suggesting more for the three boards ignores the Woolf Report.

“The proposal put forward in the paper is fundamentally flawed.“It assumes that the members have proprietary interest in the money their countries’ economies generate for ICC events.”

He also drew a comparison on the basis of proposed distribution model for 2015-2023 that significantly reduces the amount the Full and Associate & Affiliate Members will receive apart from the BCCI, ECB and CA.

He felt the Associate and Affiliate members would face the biggest loss under the distribution proposed in the Paper and also called for clarity in revenue distribution to ICC regions and the Asian Cricket Council.

“If cricket is to grow and develop around the world, more investment is required in the Associate and Affiliate countries — not less.”

Mani called for the paper to be withdrawn and “referred to an external independent panel to review and comment on”.

The proposal by the ICC Finance and Commercial Affairs (F&CA) Working Group will be presented to the ICC Executive Board during its quarterly meeting in Dubai on January 28 and 29.

Published in The Express Tribune, January 25th, 2014.

Like Sports on Facebook, follow @ETribuneSports on Twitter to stay informed and join in the conversation.

COMMENTS (11)

the BC in BCCI | 10 years ago | Reply So ure saying that every time there is an India Pakistan match..Indians are primarily responsible for paying for it with no Paki spectators in it?what a joke How about India keeps all its money and shuts up. Game before business..how was the ICC making money to keep the sport alive prior India's corruption laden IPL money. I am sure there must be alternate money generating avenues and sponsorships BT maybe its laziness and too much reliance on India's money to run cricket..it has survived as a 200 year old sport way before India was performed..it sure can now!
PakistanCricket | 10 years ago | Reply

It is true that India is a power house in world cricket right now and the ICC and other boards have bended backwards to appease the BCCI. Even now the BCCI has thrown peanuts at the PCB saying that they would invited the Pakistani team to India. Now how in the world would that help the PCB and Pakistan except for more money for the BCCI.

If the PCB is going to sign on the draft for reasons every one knows then it should at least try and bring cricket to Pakistan. Get other teams to travel to Pakistan!!!

This should be an eye opener for Pakistani businessmen as well. They should see how money is dictating everything now. If they support Pakistani cricket we may get cricket to come back to Pakistan and we may even get some really good players.

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ