Cost of production: PSMA urges revision of duty on ship-breaking

Cites unjust price advantage of scrap steel sold by ship breaking industry.


Our Correspondent September 09, 2013
The current price of shredded scrap from smelters is Rs69,645 per ton, compared with the ship breaking industry’s billets of Rs54,509 per ton – a difference of Rs15,136 per ton. PHOTO: REUTERS/FILE

KARACHI: Pakistan Steel Manufacturer Association (PSMA), a newly formed lobbying group of steel makers, reiterated their stance on Monday, asking the government to revisit duty structures on the ship-breaking industry to provide a level playing field to all players in the steel industry.

PSMA members have become vocal recently following the government’s decision to increase electricity prices in the country which, according to them, has further widened the price difference between their steel products and those created by the ship breaking industry, which they see as their rivals.

“The government should take notice of the increased of price difference because it is badly hurting steel melters,” Chief Executive Amreli Steels, Abbas Akberali, said while speaking to a group of journalists at Pearl Continental hotel.



Akberali, whose steel mill is also a member of PSMA, said that the recent increase in electricity prices has pushed up end prices of steel billets in the formal steel sector by at least Rs5,000 per ton. That has taken the price difference of their final products to over Rs12,000-14,000 per ton.

PSMA members want the government to revisit the rate of federal excise duty (FED) on the ship breaking industry. They are asking the government to impose an FED of at least Rs10,000 per tonne on ship-breaking products to cut down the price difference of their billets to Rs2,000-3,000 per ton.

They argue that according to a previous agreement signed in the year 2000 by all major steel associations, the price difference between the two should not exceed Rs1,200 per ton.

The current price of shredded scrap from smelters is Rs69,645 per ton, compared with the ship breaking industry’s billets of Rs54,509 per ton – a difference of Rs15,136 per ton.

MFN status to India

“It is my considered opinion that Pakistan should have given most-favoured nation (MFN) status to India some 16-17 years ago,” Amreli Steels Chief Executive Abbas Akberali said while commenting on government assurances to the International Monetary Fund (IMF) that it will eventually grant MFN status to India.

Published in The Express Tribune, September 10th,  2013.

Like Business on Facebook, follow @TribuneBiz on Twitter to stay informed and join in the conversation.

COMMENTS (2)

Adnan Farooqui | 10 years ago | Reply

Why should the State protect an industry that drains substantial electricity from the country's feeble power supply. Why not promote an Industry that drains little to no electricity and provides consumers with a cheaper end product. We cannot afford more strain on our power sector and further inflation is intolerable. Increased Steel consumption is an indicator of a growing economy. No sense in straining the ship-breaking industry with unwarranted duties and taxes, more importantly this sector is also the largest industry of Balochistan paying annual taxes worth billions and providing direct and indirect employment to several.

Sidster | 10 years ago | Reply

They argue that according to a previous agreement signed in the year 2000 by all major steel associations, the price difference between the two should not exceed Rs1,200 per ton. The current price of shredded scrap from smelters is Rs69,645 per ton, compared with the ship breaking industry’s billets of Rs54,509 per ton – a difference of Rs15,136 per ton.

Competitive Commission of Pakistan should investigate PSMA for collusion inside Steel Industry.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ