Reliance on few markets, products restricting export growth

Published: July 28, 2013

This year, Pakistan is expected to fare badly in fruit exports to Dubai and the UK as consignments have been rejected due to infections and substandard goods. PHOTO: FILE

ISLAMABAD: In the face of massive economic challenges, a burgeoning population, energy and water shortages, and a huge and growing number of unemployed workers, especially youth, Pakistan needs to look for ways to steer itself out of the economic quagmire by diversifying exports not only in terms of commodities but also in terms of markets.

Heavy concentration of exports in few commodities and few markets can lead to instability.

According to World Bank data, Pakistan recorded a trade deficit of Rs213.55 billion in May 2013. The balance of trade showed average deficit of Rs184.082 billion from 1957 to 2013, with the surplus reaching the peak at Rs5.457 billion in June 2003 and the deficit hitting the worst at Rs215.020 billion in December 2011.

Pakistan runs a regular trade deficit primarily because of heavy imports of energy products. Main import goods are fuel (40% of total imports), machinery and transport equipment (18%) and chemicals (16%). Major exports include cotton and knitwear (28% of total exports), bedwear, carpets and rugs (8%) and rice (8%).

This year, the country is expected to fare badly in fruit exports to Dubai and the UK. A consignment of 50 tons of fruit sent to the UK has been rejected on the grounds that it was infected with fruit fly. Until June 21 in fiscal year 2012-13, 28,700 tons of fruit had been exported, but much of this was destroyed because of quality issues.

In the outlook for 2013, continuous weak global growth outlook and heightened uncertainties lead to expectations that world trade will continue to expand at a moderate pace of 4.3% in volume, compared to 3.3% in 2012 and 6.8% from 2005 to 2008.

Recent trade data reflects the spill-over effects on the growth of Pakistan’s exports. Geographically, the EU and the US represent the most important destinations for exports and their markets absorb 31% and 23% of shipments from Pakistan. Therefore, slowdown in US and European economies and weak demand have significantly impacted export growth.

China is the third most important destination for Pakistan with an 11.5% share. Recently, UAE, Afghanistan, Oman and Turkey have also become important destinations.

Despite focusing on a limited number of markets, Pakistan has seen some diversification in exports in the past few years. A few years ago, around 43% of exports were concentrated in five markets (US, UK, Germany, Hong Kong and UAE). This share has been going down continuously and it now stands at 36.3% whereas the share of other countries has increased to 63.7%.

This improvement came mainly on the back of the Strategic Trade Policy Framework (STPF 2009-12) and the resulting increase in exports to China, Afghanistan and Bangladesh.

In 2012-13, the export target was set at $24.8 billion, 4% higher than the previous year. The moderate growth target was set in the wake of energy shortages and slow growth in developed economies.

Exports in the first 10 months (July-April) reached $20.147 billion, up 4.2% from $19.329 billion in the same period of previous year. Of the total, the export of food group rose 12.3%, textile group 6.1% and other manufactures 8.7%.

However, exports are restricted to a small number of items such as cotton and cotton products, leather, rice and few others. Jewellery has recently become another significant export item.

Cotton and cotton products, leather and rice accounted for 63.7% of total exports in the first nine months of 2012-13 with cotton products alone contributing 51.4%.

The share of major export items has come down over the years as they earlier constituted around 70% of total exports. However, compared to the previous year, the share has not improved. Further data assessment shows that most of the export earnings have come from textile manufacturers.

If a country’s exports depend on a narrow range of products, then its export earnings will fluctuate with international price changes and shocks. But the country with a more diversified portfolio will find that fluctuations in prices of some products will not have any significant impact on total earnings.

The lack of diversification in Pakistan’s export markets exacerbates the vulnerability to economic shocks. This leads to volatility and instability in export earnings, which in turn has adverse effects on growth, employment, investment planning, export capacity, foreign exchange reserves, inflation, capital flight and debt payments.

Therefore, Pakistan is required to diversify its export portfolio by adding new products to the export basket. This will enable the country to avoid the risks associated with production and distribution of different products and also reduce reliance on one or few geographical destinations for exports.

For diversification of export markets, Pakistan should develop trade linkages and introduce products in leading markets like Canada, Japan, South Korea and the Netherlands.

The writer is a researcher at the Economic Growth Unit of Sustainable Development Policy Institute

Published in The Express Tribune, July 29th, 2013.

Like Business on Facebook, follow @TribuneBiz on Twitter to stay informed and join in the conversation.

Reader Comments (5)

  • Zain
    Jul 28, 2013 - 11:18PM

    Good observation and analysis by author. The exports can be enhanced by included more manufactured, engineered products, which are locally made in Pakistan such as Motorbikes, and parts for motorbikes, auto parts like brake pads, batteries, tires, seats, etc. There is a lot of demand of auto parts all over the world, and vendors of auto parts in Pakistan can earn a lot more profit and much need money in form of foreign exchange for the country. Currently the auto parts makers only rely on the auto assemblers.

    Recommend

  • Jul 29, 2013 - 2:49AM

    @Zain:
    Except that Pakistan produces obsolete auto parts that no one is interested in except people from even poorer countries like Afghanistan. This is entirely the result of the protectionist policies of the govt. By restricting imports of auto parts you’ve protected the local industry from competition and that has kept them backward.

    Have you seen the bikes that people drive here? All 1970s models. Outside of Pakistan no one uses kick starter and carburetor based engines anymore. And, LOL, there are no scooters made in this country.

    Recommend

  • Batool
    Jul 29, 2013 - 8:27AM

    Pakistan should focus on export of secondary goods and diversify its export basket to avoid periodical shocks which it faces annually on the face natural disasters…if Pakistan will continue to depend only on export of its agricultural products then future of Pakistan export industry is dark.

    Recommend

  • Abbas
    Jul 29, 2013 - 9:00AM

    Policy makers should seriously focus on this otherwise in near future this limited concentration will further deteriorate Pakistan’s BOT

    Recommend

  • unbelievable
    Jul 29, 2013 - 9:12PM

    If you want to diversify products you need to attract foreign investment to build factories/mines etc to produce the new products – security, xenophobia, and corrupt judicial system have to be fixed before that happens.

    Recommend

More in Pakistan