Malala Yousafzai. PHOTO: RASHID AJMERI/FILE
A senior representative of Tehreek Taliban has said that the Taliban has no symphathies with Malala Yousafzai, and that she would be targeted again if she chose to return to Pakistan, BBC Urdu reported.
The representative said that neither was Adnan Rashid a senior commander of the Taliban nor did the Taliban have anything to do with the letter that Rashid wrote to Malala on Wednesday.
He said that Malala had been targeted because of her efforts in promoting secular education in Pakistan and her becoming a part of the West’s propaganda, which though reflect what Rashid mentioned in his letter.
The Taliban Council had obtained the actual draft of the letter that Rashid had sent Malala, and whether it had any content that went against the rules of the Taliban was being assessed, he said.
The council will also look into the purpose for which the letter had been written to Malala, the representative said.
Taliban’s prominent leader in Pakistan Adnan Rashid said that he was ‘shocked’ after Malala was attacked by the Taliban in October last year.
Rashid had been convicted in 2003 by the state of Pakistan for trying to assassinate former president Pervez Musharraf. He was also one of the many inmates who escaped from Bannu jail in April last year.
He wrote to Malala Yousufzai advising her to return and join a religious school for women in Swat. He wrote to Malala a day after her address at the United Nations General Assembly, criticising her speech in his two-page letter written in English.
COMMENTS (39)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
can any one tell me what does secular education mean?? what are they going to remove from our education?? well in my humble opinion, islimait book is the target(not physics, maths, civics, etc). Christians and jews want that..
Adnan Rashid's motives are difficult to pin down but his letter is just a piece of trash. He perhaps wanted a much desired publicity that has been acrued to him. His purpose is served. At the same time, he will pamper the Taliban by saying, "Look I did it for you". A great cheap stunt.
@Someone: I hope you are aware that Indian Punjab has a population of just 24 million with an area of 50,000 sq Km compared to Pakistani Punjab's 91 million population on an area of 205,000 sq km.
come on guys taliban vow to target Malala on comeback - What kind of an organization this is literally im laughin my head off. I seriously doubt this is an official response. If this is trust me you don't deserve to be a Terrorist Organization (LOL). I have a funny feeling that Tehreek Taliban's all official responses come from the Media Itself. One word saray milay nae. They are all one just twisting the people.
@Babloo: The economy of Pakistani Punjab is three times larger than Indian Punjab. Go check the stats. I don't know where you got your figures from.
@Water Bottle: What has India got to do with this news item. You Muslims always have to bring India into anything that happens in Pakistan and abuse India. Clean up your mess and save your women.
Taliban version of Tolerance - Give someone a day to agree with you.
taliban are kafir for money they can do nay thing.
So now the Taliban employ the good cop bad cop strategy.
The Taliban are bullies and that makes them cowards...........and for every bully there is a bigger force to counter him...........and who would have thought that that force would be a 16 year old girl armed with a pen and her voice.
Threatening to kill a 16 year old girl once again? These people disgraced themselves by their (fortunately) failed attempt to kill her earlier. These aren't human beings they are worse than wild animals. And yet we find imbeciles everywhere who want to negotiate with them.
@Ahmed: another topi drama by foreign paid agent Taliban to make a permanents place for malala in western world.
Once Malala get a permanent place in the western world, the West will win and Islam and Pakistan will lose. Please grow up a little and open your heart and mind just a little bit to see some light.
@Muzaffar, The biggest lie is Pakistan started from Zero in 1947. Remember Punjab was the most prosperous province of British India. Pakistan got most of Punjab and all the wealth of the Hindus and Sikhs of W Pakistan, who were the rich people of Pakistan.
Today Indian punjab, Haryana, Himachal, Delhi etc are among the most prosperous region of India and per capita income of Indian Punjab, Haryana, Himachal in India is more than twice of Pakistan Punjab.
E.T, Please start showing the latest picture of Malala, atleast when people see the disfigurement in her face, they will realize what she has gone through. She is just a child and is being bullied by world's biggest bullies!
@Water Bottle: Sewage or septic tank ..nice, I would call it overdose of religion and lack of individual space or freedom ,that's what it made sewage or septic tank. We waste too much time in discussing things of little importance. Malala a genius or very noble soul born in Pakistan is hounded by shameless fanatics. Why would she return ? And for what ? And for people of India and Pakistan , let's fight over who is better but then keep a hand on your hearts and ask yourself, what difference does it makes? In the end we all will be exploited by blood sucking political and religious class ..
Where is the argument now that, "the Taliban do not exist"?
Cowerds.
@Water Bottle: This is hypocrisy? Your post is irrelevant to this ET article. My comment is relevant to your useless comment. Makes sense? So i did not waste my time.
where is the stupid poll now asking "whether she should return to Pakistan"?
@bharatvarsh:
"mate this malala vs taliban match not india vs pak."
Mate, in case you haven't noticed, everything w.r.t. subcontinent boils down to Hindu vs. Muslim. Or India vs. Pak.
another topi drama by foreign paid agent Taliban to make a permanents place for malala in western world.
@Aschraful Makhlooq:
"I have no doubt that Pakistan is better than India in rape cases’ matters because in India mostly teenage girls are victims of rape cases and India’s near past has proven it true….. "
You should have doubt. Because Pakistan is, without a doubt, worse than India, even in terms of rape.
Have no doubt.
In Pakistan fewer rapes are reported than in India.
Be open and honest. Or we both are doomed.
@Dr. Yes:
"You just wasted your minutes on that. Your post is totally irrelevant and disgusting."
You see the hypocrisy here?
You call my comment irrelevant and take time to respond to it. Why don't you grow up to be a man.
Water Bottle. Seems when you wrote that ''I have no doubt that Pakistan is worse than India in almost all aspects'' probably you were under the influence of some other type of bottle. In 1947 Pakistan started from Zero and India had all in its plate -even the money which was Pakistan's share, And when you see the progress made till now - Pakistan having developed its industry from inception is presently one of the major global market player in textile, agri , surgical instruments, sports items etc etc, has the ability to produce aircrafts, is a nuclear power, has produced some of the best sportsmen/women, musicians etc etc. Interestingly the one thing - infrastructure you talk about is one of the major basis of any development.........
Bottle ji come out of the bottle into reality and in Pakistan you will not see more people sleeping on streets then under roofs - like Mumbai, you will not see the government killing its own people by orchastrating Mumbai/Parliament attacks, you will not see destroying its own culture by producing so called modernized/westerinized entertainment stuff.
Malala is safer abroad than Pakistan because Taliban the barbarians and wild beasts now this time shall kill her.Therefore Malala has never to come back to Pakistan because Taliban have been totally untrustworthy and incredible now because Taliban have shown on many occasions/places hypocrisy and credibility gap......
apart from all the nonsense being discussed... i could't help noticing seeing medical science has advanced a lot in my mental absence... There's is't even a rough "bullet" mark on her forehead.. ;) MALALA has been in "good & caring" hands ofcourse ;)
@Water Bottle: I have no doubt that Pakistan is better than India in rape cases' matters because in India mostly teenage girls are victims of rape cases and India's near past has proven it true.....
@Water Bottle, mate this malala vs taliban match not india vs pak.
I guess Taliban regret the fame Malala got after all the tragedy. They would have thought that Malala's case will go down the drain like a lot of similar cases! I strongly condemn what has happened to her by so called Allah's Army (Na-uz-zubillah), endorse her as Daughter of Pakistan, a true future leader and last hope of female Education in Pakistan. @ Ali, you wouldn't feel it non sense if (God forbid) a similar situation has happened to your daughter or sister.
@Waterbottle
By infrastructure , if you mean
Railways : Well Pakistan has less working railway lines today, than in 1947. The railways stand destroyed. In many places railway employees have sold rail lines for scrap . No match to India's.
Air Traffic : No match to India's, not even close on a per-capita basis.
Power : Far worse than in India. They want to buy power from India.
Roads : Except a few show-roads built by US money or Chinese, they are as bad as any in India.
"He said that Malala had been targeted because of her efforts in promoting secular education in Pakistan and her becoming a part of the West’s propaganda, which though reflect what Rashid mentioned in his letter."
this is all because of the drone attacks isi mossad raw conspiracy zzzzzz....
@Water Bottle: Do you think accepting Pakistan is a septic tank( I totally disagree with you on that) will do any good? Pakistanis/Pakistan have a much higher potential in all fields waiting to be tapped. You just wasted your minutes on that. Your post is totally irrelevant and disgusting. Find something else to waste your time on.
Real tough guys eh?
Enough Malala already guys please give up this non sence.
Wondering what all those "Oh-it's-drama-she-was-never-shot" and "She-should-return-to-Pakistan" people have to say now? And bravo to the Taliban for threatening a 16 year old girl! How much more manly can you get?
Lets see the reaction of Taliban apologists who were falling head over heels over the pathetic excuse of a letter.
As an Indian, I have no doubt that India is a sewage. Most Indians won't agree to this. They will be angry with me. Because they are in denial just like Pakistan.
Why can't Pakistanis see that Pakistan is a septic tank.
I have no doubt that Pakistan is worse than India in almost all aspects.
Perhaps one thing in which Pakistan is better than India is the infrastructure. Apart from that...
This is what exactly I have tweeted two days ago on tweeter @syedamateen
The request of Takiban for Malala to come back home was a trap which was laid down to kill her if she return home, as Taliban cannot kill Malals abroad.