Marginally less invisible

Published: September 15, 2010

The writer is a former morning TV show host naveen.naqvi@tribune.com.pk

When I was invited by activist and political blogger, Sana Saleem to talk to women at flood relief camps set up in Thatta district, I was quick to accept. I went around eight camps in one day as part of a team of about 20 professionals including dentists from Baqai Dental Hospital and a military entourage to ensure security and organised delivery of sustenance. Some camps housed as many as three hundred survivors. Another was less of a camp and more of a community — of 30 survivors huddled on a dry patch of flat land, taking shelter under their charpais.

There was one large camp that struck me as distinctive. However, this was not because of the camp itself, made of a couple of hundred tents, but the people who were there. There was quietness about them, a despair that reached beyond a month of suffering. In previous camps that we had visited, women were eager to talk, tell us their stories, and take what we may have to offer. At this particular camp, the manner of the survivors was completely different. It was not just in the way they talked, or what they did not say, but also in the posture, how they inhabited their space, how little of it they took up, and the way in which they inhabited it. At the farthest end of the row of tents, an older man sat on his haunches.

I asked him his name, but no answer. When I asked where he had come from, he replied ‘goth’. From the bag of clothes I had been given to distribute, I took out a few items. Unlike the other survivors who were eager to take what I held forward, this man did not move a finger. These are clothes, I said. Do you want them? He continued staring, and gave an almost imperceptible shrug. Do you understand Urdu, I asked the man, having come across mostly Sindhi speakers along the way. Yes, he said, looking at me for the first time. His eyes were grey and watery, the whites yellow. I put the clothes on the ground at his feet, and walked to the door of the tent. I had some biscuits and clothes for children, which I gave to the woman who also hesitated to take anything from my hand.

“First, it’s because they’re not Muslims; they’re scheduled caste peasants,” our military escort, a colonel, said to me. “Second, they have not owned anything ever in their lives or over the generations. Everything that you saw there, including the livestock, the few buffalo and goats are owned by the landlord of their area. These people keep them for him.” The colonel went on to explain the process to me of how a calf is given to a family to raise. While the family cares for the animal, 50 per cent of its produce, such as milk and fertiliser, is given as interest to the landlord. Once the buffalo or goat is of age, it is returned.

I just wish the media would give the state of these peasants more attention. It may not be too late. As an employee at a foreign donor agency said to me the floods might be an opportunity for some of these people who are otherwise forgotten to become marginally less invisible.

Published in The Express Tribune, September 16th, 2010.

Reader Comments (9)

  • Muhammad Usman
    Sep 16, 2010 - 1:34AM

    Not so much impresive, its a same story that every one had..Recommend

  • Sep 16, 2010 - 3:03AM

    disturbingRecommend

  • Talha
    Sep 16, 2010 - 5:26AM

    The character of this nation can be described by the harrowing tales of it’s silence sufferers. It’s a shame that it took a disaster to highlight the plight of ‘Non Muslims’ in this country.

    This nation is not a place where ‘Non Muslims’ can live, it just does not offer anything to them.

    This is not what Jinnah promised our minorities. Recommend

  • Parvez
    Sep 16, 2010 - 12:22PM

    I like you as a TV anchor and I love you for writing this piece.
    It is so,so different from the other write ups on the floods. Very effective, very moving.Recommend

  • faraz
    Sep 16, 2010 - 12:24PM

    There are over 20 million landless peasants in Pakistan but our educated middle class is more worried about foreign policy and grand ideologies. We should first demand rights for these poor people before worrying about those living outside pakistan.Recommend

  • M M Malik
    Sep 16, 2010 - 12:33PM

    Exploitation of the weak and the meek is Un-Islamic.Recommend

  • Umar Farooq
    Sep 16, 2010 - 12:45PM

    This crisis provides a huge opportunity for the state to at last provide some type of assessment and relief to the silent oppressed masses of interior Sindh. There are millions of bonded laborers that have been shifted to relief camps, its the governments duty to make sure that these bonded laborers do not return to their former lives of slavery. Govt should register them and provide some form of settlement opportunities in more developed parts of Sindh. Its about time that slavery is eradicated from Pakistan.Recommend

  • Qirat
    Sep 16, 2010 - 12:48PM

    Jinnah…. who?Recommend

  • Mansoor Khalid
    Sep 16, 2010 - 4:07PM

    Natural disasters pose a threat to everyone but the already marginalized ones that is the minorities face much harder times. Due to the religious fanaticism, there have been incidents of aggression against them. As a nation we must support our countrymen irrespective of religious inclinations.Recommend

More in Opinion