DALLAS, TEXAS: This is with reference to your editorial of July 5 titled “Non-Muslims and our textbooks”. The definition of a secular state is that the government does not interfere with people’s lives based on religion. Individual bigotry, while undesirable, may exist in a secular state. By that definition, Pakistan is clearly not a secular state. Consider the following facts which show state-level discrimination based on religion:
1) Pakistan calls itself an ‘Islamic’ republic. By this identity itself people of other faiths are excluded
2) Blasphemy against Islam is punishable by death as per law. Blasphemy against other religions is treated differently.
3) By law, the president and the prime minister must be Muslim.
4) Recently, a lower court ordered that the dome of an Ahmadi ‘place of worship’ be destroyed. This is not consistent with guarantees regarding freedom of worship.
6) There is no process for registering Hindu marriages under Pakistani law.
7) Pakistan’s population of minorities has been reduced from a healthy proportion at the time of independence to two to three per cent of the population now.
Ayesha Khan
Published in The Express Tribune, July 9th, 2012.
More in Letters
Women’s vital link with the environment
so what is new?
Recommend
Pakistan was created on the premise that a Hindu-majority India could not be trusted to ensure the rights of its Muslim minority. It is therefore ironic that Pakistan itself has abjectly failed its own minorities. In other words, Pakistan has done exactly what it once feared India would do.
Using the same logic that was behind the creation of Pakistan, can’t these minorities demand that their own country be carved out of Pakistan?
Recommend
Minorities will disappear in Pakistan in a few decades. People in Pakistan will start turning on themselves. Today its the Ahmadis, tomorrow its the Shias, day after god knows what divide.
Lesson: You don’t create a country based on the ideas of division. Somebody will come and just try to redraw that line.
Recommend
“By law, the president and the prime minister must be Muslim.”. What about the UK? Can the King or Queen be a non-Protestant? So, even the UK is not a secular country!
Recommend
@Shakir Lakhani: King or queen are not head of state. They have no political power. You are comparing apples to oranges as a desperate measure.
Recommend
@Char Laten: Excellent. Well said. I think a day will come when a single or a group of minorities may get together to form an alliance against the majority “Muslims” of Pakistan. That day the long and miserable silence of peaceful Pakistanis will also join them in their struggle and may be there’s a change.
Recommend