Sunny
High: 33°C
Low: 27°C
Alerts
 
< >

We can all be Mandelas

Published: July 16, 2010

The writer is a barrister and a public policy graduate from Harvard University mahreen.khan@tribune.com.pk

For me there was only one hero in the World Cup 2010. Nelson Mandela — the man responsible for galvanising South Africa into a nation and a country capable of hosting such an impressive event. His life and leadership have all the answers we in Pakistan are seeking. He has shown us how to salvage a country ready to fall apart.

Let me remind you how dire the situation in South Africa was. The British and Dutch had been brutal colonisers and apartheid was installed as an inhuman form of institutionalised racism and segregation to perpetuate white rule. In their own homeland, black people were barred from owning land, using public utilities reserved for whites, marrying of their own free will. Every day they were stripped of their humanity and degraded — they lived and died like animals in impoverished shanty-towns. If ever there was a crime against humanity, if ever retribution was warranted and would have gone unquestioned and unchallenged, South Africa was that case. If ever the path for exacting justice would have been nobly led, then Mandela was the man to lead it. Yet he made the decision not to.

Mandela’s greatest act of leadership was renouncing the policy of retribution. He chose not to seek justice for his 27 years of confinement, humiliation and torture and asked his people to forego their right to vengeance. No white police officer or prison guard was tried or imprisoned for rape, murder or torture. No white legislator or politician was targeted. An entire race that had been humiliated, disenfranchised and brutalised went un-avenged.

Instead, a genuine process of truth and reconciliation was instituted. A clean slate and a fresh start were opted for as the sins of the past were buried. An entire people who had been subjected to an undeniable, unmitigated injustice forgave their tormentors. Not because Mandela is a saint but because he was a statesman who knew that this was the only way to achieve peace, unity and progress. His decision averted a bloody civil war, prevented economic ruin and forged a nation out of forgiveness.

So my fellow countrymen and women, we have to take the same road as South Africa. As painful and as shocking it may seem we, the people of Pakistan, must forgive our leaders and politicians. All of them, for everything they have done. Ours is a case where the guilty and innocent are not so black and white (pardon the pun) as was the case in South Africa and the crimes they are accused of are not as heinous. Many are guilty and others complicit. Sorting it all out will be a colossal task and the probability is that the stolen money will still be stashed away in Park Lane apartments, Swiss accounts and offshore companies. Justice will be elusive, expensive and possibly irreparably destructive upon our fragmented national soul. Justice cannot be done when so many of those who claim to seek it are tainted themselves.

Let us not stay shackled to the past, decimating our meagre resources and valuable time in a futile and divisive journey. Yes, I hear your cries. How can we forget the billions stolen from a poor nation, the corruption and the lies, the broken promises, the unashamed attacks on law and property, on life and liberty? Well, if Mandela could forgive 27 years of incarceration, if ordinary South Africans could forgive the torture and murder of their children, then we Pakistanis can choose to forgive corruption, legal transgressions and bad decisions. This is the only way to end the whole sorry mess that surrounds us.

Mandela has shown the way. We need to follow that proven path instead of praying our hearts out for a messiah. Our Mandela will not be written in the stars or be delivered from the heavens. Our Mandela will not be one man; it has to be a movement and a change in national consciousness. This is one thing we, the people, have the power to do. Let us start afresh and harness our energies for building up our country. Let us choose to write off the past and write the future instead.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 17th, 2010.

Reader Comments (7)

  • zahid ali
    Jul 17, 2010 - 6:48AM

    well, nodoubt This good efforts to show the solution to all Pakistani messes…but u might have analysis the pakistani issues for the last 2 years our nation cannot afford such corruption, torture and murders as u mentioned which was happening in South Africa. Our nation is intolerable revengeable. we do react immediately what we see or face. If someone has done corruption in his department then many from same department will follow him and lead corruption. If someone is tortured by any party. Then we react with same action. The nation which has zero toleration can be compared with South Africa or any tolerable countries.

    I am also TV journalist recently visited Iran and Iraq.I went with a group of 50 to 60 people simply called with karwan or qafila. Our iran’s Iraq’s aim was the same. This was our entirely spiritual journey in spite of that we 50 people were not agree with any point. Some time i saw the intolerable attitudes with minor issues during travelling.
    After touring this I perceived that we Pakistani are intolerable nation.Recommend

  • Jul 17, 2010 - 8:34AM

    mahreen:

    if wishes were horses….

    unfortunately, giants like mandela are rare … almost extinct breed

    this is a nation full of pygmy idi amins

    they will rant, sing, and dance on this titanic’s deck…Recommend

  • Sarjeel Mowahid
    Jul 17, 2010 - 12:21PM

    As much as the writer would want us all to turn into hippies and propogate love she fails to realize what Nelson Mandela stood for.

    Please dont comapare the Truth and Reconcilliation Commission or apartheid regime in South Africa with corruption in Pakistan.

    Your idea of justice is based on expense? One is forced to say you have no idea what justice stands for. It isnt abt the million of dollars being spent or recovered, it isnt about forgiving people, its about holding those in position of trust and respect accountable to the masses. Its about knowing that you will not go scott free after having cheated a nation.

    Do you really think the corrupt in pakistan repent? and more importantly are you a fairy?

    I admire your ability to forgive and forget. I really do but I know you dont care if you can. And your idea of rationality well again that may be dictated by expense so one cant expect much of you.

    How dare you corelate a mans effort to get rid of apartheid with corruption. The flaw in your analogy lies in the fact that you have misunderstood what went about in Pakistan.

    Mark my words if we stay silent today history will repeat itself over and over again and yes you will probably be forgiving people in the process. I dont blame you I guess thats just who you are.Recommend

  • Jul 17, 2010 - 1:26PM

    Excellent write-up Mahreen!
    This is precisely the solution to this dis-oriented nation. It’s easier to bash and criticize but to take up the hefty task of building anew from scratch – that’s what makes many a brave, cowards and many a critics, silent. The need of the day indeed is to realize that reactionary intellectualism will yield nothing but more anarchy. And only a reconciliatory process, based on forgiveness and a new start, will bring us out of the state we are in.Recommend

  • Meekal Ahmed
    Jul 18, 2010 - 1:15AM

    Madam,

    You are endorsing the controversial NRO! Where do you think BB got the idea from? I have heard her personally talk about Reconciliation almost a decade ago. She sold it to the Americans and the British and there we have it.Recommend

  • cmsarwar
    Jul 18, 2010 - 4:20AM

    Mahreen has put her very soul into the piece she has written.Unfortunately,however,she has started with a wrong premise ending up in a misdirected message.
    Mandela’s South Africa bears no similarities with Jinnah’s Pakistan.Under the British rule,or even within a United India,with a predominantly Hindu majority,Muslims did not,and would not,experience the subjugation and oppression enforced by Apartheid in South Africa.Mandela’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission was in the context of Apartheid,which the Whites honestly believed was a legitimate arrangement just like slavery which was no big a taboo in America for a long time.America endured a civil war to correct their wrong.Mandela had to wage a long struggle to bring sanity to South Africa.
    In 1947 Pakistan started off,by and large,with so many advantages.Jinnah had a clear and great vision about the state he had created and its brilliant future.Poorly equipped but the new nation inherited a body of justice-oriented civil and criminal laws/procedure codes.(Whatever their faults the British were a civilised/developement oriented colonial power).Pakistan was,therefore,a nation with immense promise without the shackles which imprisoned Mandela’s South Africa.
    I need not dilate on the circumstances which turned Jinnah’s dream of a prosperous Pakistan into the present day nightmare the nation is faced with.As is obvious,slowly and steadily a combine of feudal/civil/military/industrial mafia has established an iron grip on this unfortunate country,with effective connivance and assistance of the vested international players.We are in a very bad shape indeed.I wish Mahreen had noticed the glaring dissimilarities in the two scenarios before suggesting the Mandela solution to our problems.What happened
    in Pakistan was the criminal breaches of the laws of the land by our own elite ,not by white, external colonial occupiers.
    I cannot think of any way out of this mess.But I definitely and defiantly disagree with Mahreen.She wants a complete break from the past in order to avoid some of the discomforts she is too soft to face.To make things easy and comfortable for her my humble suggestion is:Let’s reinstate Musharraf’s NRO in toto,let’s also eliminate some of the time lines to extend the fruits to those not yet covered.Let it be the business as usual.After all God has given limitless patience to our God-fearing nation.Recommend

  • Nadia
    Sep 27, 2010 - 4:38PM

    Mahreen – you are way ahead of your time – this article represents a higher level of consciousness. This nation is still busy tearing itself to shreds. They can’t see that it will lead to more of the same. In times to come this article will be read with a different appreciation altogether.Recommend

More in Opinion

X