Sunny
High: 35°C
Low: 28°C
Alerts
 
< >

How are they different from us?

Published: June 27, 2010

The writer is a human resource consultant currently based in New York (aziz.akhmad@tribune.com.pk)

We all know the profile of our current parliament. It does not resemble that of the population of Pakistan. A lot of lawmakers are rich, with a feudal or business background, many are related to each other, many are maulanas or mashaikhs (I never quite understood the meaning of the latter term), and they all are college graduates although many with fake degrees.

I know comparing Pakistan with the US is neither valid nor fair, but a peek into the composition of the US Congress shows an interesting picture, which some readers might also find of interest.

But before the details, some explanations are in order: The term US Congress is used for the Senate and the House of Representatives combined. The Senate has 100 senators, two from each state, elected for a six-year term. The House of Representatives, also called the House, consists of 435 plus members, one or more from each state, based on population, elected for a two-year term. Members of the House are also referred to as congressmen or women, or simply representatives. There are no reserved seats in either House; everyone is elected directly.

Here is the composition, gleaned from a 10-page report prepared by Congressional Research Service on the current Congress:

Education: A vast majority of the members of the House and Senate (95 per cent) hold college or university degrees, many a law degree. Twenty-four representatives have PhD degrees, and 17 representatives and three senators have a medical degree. However, one senator and 27 representatives have nothing but a high school diploma.

Religion: Other than a large number of what can broadly be labelled as Christian, there are 44 Jewish, two Buddhists and two Muslims (both in the House).

Gender and Ethnicity: There are 93 women (76 in the House and 17 in the Senate), mostly Democrats. There are 42 black members in the Congress, all Democrats. Another 40 odd members, again, mostly Democrats, are either Hispanic or of East Asian heritage. There is one set of brothers and one set of sisters in the House, both Hispanic.

Foreign Birth: Several members were born overseas. One representative, Van Hollen, Jr., a Democrat from Maryland, was born in Karachi in 1958, and – as if to equalise – one senator, Michael Bennet, a Democrat from Colorado, was born in New Delhi in 1964.

Occupations: They come from all walks of life, literally. From sciences, there are 16 medical doctors, two dentists, three nurses, two veterinarians, three physicists, one chemist, six engineers, and one microbiologist.

From justice and law, besides many lawyers, there are three state Supreme Court justices, a federal judge, four sheriffs, a deputy sheriff, and four police officers (equivalent of our S.H.O, Sub-Inspector, and Constable, respectively).

From the media, there are two radio talk show hosts, a television broadcaster, a radio newscaster, a television reporter, and a television commentator.

Then there are two professional musicians, a semi-professional musician, a screenwriter, a comedian, a documentary filmmaker, a major league baseball player, and a professional football player.

Also included are three farmers, four ranchers, two wine makers, and a fruit orchard worker; a driving instructor, a cosmetic sales woman, a mountain guide, and a ski instructor; a casino dealer, a night watchman, and a prison guard; three carpenters, two bank tellers, a furniture salesman, an ironworker, an auto worker, a clothing factory worker, a textile worker, an oil field worker, a waitress, a paper mill worker, a cement plant worker, a meat cutter, a taxicab driver, an auctioneer, a toll booth collector, and a hotel clerk.

From the people in uniform, there are 111 members with military service including the commander of an aircraft carrier battle group, an instructor at West Point, and a pilot of Marine One (the president’s helicopter), an astronaut and a naval aviator. (And, yes, there are four clergymen, too.) Surprisingly, there are no generals. In the US, unlike Pakistan, generals usually fade away.

Reader Comments (11)

  • Jun 27, 2010 - 2:33AM

    America should learn to appreciate its generals the way we do!Recommend

  • Ali
    Jun 27, 2010 - 4:26AM

    Very interesting! I have lived in the US for a long time and didn’t know there was such a diversity in the Congress.Recommend

  • Muhammad Ahsan Khan
    Jun 27, 2010 - 11:55AM

    America does appreciate its Generals. In Pakistan a Generals has to impose his authority to become a de facto President, whereas in the states ithe people elect them as Democratic Presidents (Ulysses S. Grant and Dwight David “Ike” Eisenhower).Recommend

  • Muhammad Ahsan Khan
    Jun 27, 2010 - 8:56PM

    “Very interesting! I have lived in the US for a long time and didn’t know there was such a diversity in the Congress.”

    Dear Ali,

    The diversity of any representative group of people in any country is based on the diversity of people living in the country.

    In Pakistan, the people belong to Indus Valley civilization and they belong to one single religion Islam.

    In any representation in Pakistan the members will be Indus Valley people (Punjabis or Sindhis) and their religion will be Islam.

    So, why to be surprised that Pakistan for last 64 years is governed by the same people of establishment??Recommend

  • Risha
    Jun 28, 2010 - 7:27AM

    Very interesting article. I wish we could learn something from the Americans.Recommend

  • Dr.Munawar Aziz
    Jun 28, 2010 - 7:38AM

    How about comparing an ox-cart with a latest BMW ?Recommend

  • Shahbaz Ali
    Jun 28, 2010 - 12:30PM

    Thank you for sharing it.Recommend

  • AA
    Jun 28, 2010 - 11:43PM

    Dr. Munawar Sahib,

    When you compare an oxcart with a BMW, at least there is chance that a wish or a hope may be kindled in one’s heart to do away with the oxcart and to acquire a BM. No?Recommend

  • Dr.Munawar Aziz
    Jun 29, 2010 - 8:51AM

    Dear AA
    Yes, but wish and hope alone is not enough to achieve,there should be strong will,dedication and hard work.Recommend

  • Asif Khan
    Jun 29, 2010 - 4:25PM

    I think these comparision of ox-cart and BMW’s has destoyed all values from us in real way. Everybody is running to get BMW’s.

    However if we are taking this an example for adopting good things in our way of life that is seperate matter and that can be taken from lot of other countries not only from America.Recommend

  • H Saqib
    Jun 30, 2010 - 2:19PM

    They have nothing in common with those they claim to represent. They can not live the lives of their voter for even one hour. They live in style and they can compromise on principles, but will never comprise on the expensive style. Please read a similar article: link textRecommend

More in Opinion

X