- 02 Feb 2011
No intention to amend blasphemy law: PM - 03 Feb 2011
No equivalent of conservative fascism - 04 Feb 2011
Disgusted by the PPP’s stance - 05 Feb 2011
The extremist majority (II) - 03 Feb 2011
A pitiable retreat
The writer is a sub-editor at The Express Tribune Magazine [email protected]
The Raymond Davis saga has not only cast a pall over US-Pakistani relations, it has also managed to sideline what was one of 2010’s defining issues and 2011’s tragic realities: The status of Pakistan’s blasphemy laws.
Caught up in the thrilling world of espionage, the media and the authorities seem to have forgotten that somewhere, a woman is still being held in custody under a controversial blasphemy law. We have also apparently forgotten that Salmaan Taseer’s death and the collective silence that followed it means our ability to air even moderate opinions has been compromised.
Yes, the governor’s murderer was formally indicted on February 15 — but nothing has been done to curb the sentiments that caused him to act out in the first place. The government is silent, failing to acknowledge that anyone suggesting amendments to the law has been threatened into submission. Self-professed ‘activists,’ prominent media persons and the exalted judiciary, too, seem to be focusing on ‘less controversial’ issues.
This attitude is more troubling than any tangle Pakistan gets into with the US — it is the kind of moral decay that causes societies to fail. It is this deterioration that we need to address most urgently. In comparison, the current spy war playing itself out on TV is just a blip on the radar: Even if we ‘win’ the Raymond Davis case — find him guilty in a Pakistani court, get the US to apologise, or do whatever else we need to do to keep our insecurities at bay, will it make any difference to an average Pakistani’s struggle to live a better life?
Our failure to see the bigger picture reminds me of some news that came out of Egypt recently. On the eve of Mubarak‘s resignation, a female journalist was sexually assaulted by men in a 200-strong crowd. Horrific as the incident was, it was not an irregularity — according to Egypt’s interior ministry, at least 55 women in the country are raped every day.
So what good is a revolution when all that changes is the top leadership and the average citizen’s access to justice remains unaffected? Instead of hyping up people’s movements across the Arab world, we should wait and see what these states evolve into before making our judgments.
Similarly, we shouldn’t be blinded by all the hype surrounding Pakistan’s ‘Spygate,’ nor should we take any ‘successes’ on that front to be indicative of the country’s progress. We should focus on that Christian woman in prison, and people like her — anything less is merely cosmetic.
Published in The Express Tribune, February 21st, 2011.
More in Pakistan
PM tasked to win over Sharif again
Completely agree with you, but we are a nation of hypocrites lead by bigger hypocrites who all have a yellow line running down their back bone.
The handling of the Aasia and Salman Taseer cases by the government, law enforcement and the judiciary is just disgusting in so far as nothing tangible appears to be happening.Recommend
“— anything less is merely cosmetic.”
You are spot on.
Blasphemy laws infringe into God’s jurisdiction, there is no temporal punishment for blasphemy. Recommend
Agreed. The focus needs to remain on these dark laws of General Zia.Recommend
I was just thinking about the same thing yesterday!! Thanks for the article!!Recommend
My plan is to make everyone forget about Asia Bibi and once she is forgotten, we can put her and her family on the first flight out of this Jazbaati Azab called Mullahistan.
So lets not talk about her.
Once the attention is focused elsewhere, I am willing to come back to Pakistan in the near future and fight violently against the Mullahs and Islamists.Recommend
The problem with many Pakistani’s is that they don’t care about the Aasia Bibi’s of the world, they only care about their “beloved” Dr. Afia!
How sad that, instead of focusing on Aasia Bibi’s situation most Pakistani’s are fixated on Dr. Afia and looking forward to seeing Raymond Davis head roll down their streets.
Sickening…Recommend
Apparently, Raymond Davis managed to get all of Pakistan’s blasphemers to start cursing America instead.
Hamna, once this Davis thing blows over we’ll find something else to be outraged about.
So why don’t you get to work on setting the agenda that lies ahead, instead of trying to convince us to go back to that tired old issue we no longer find as interesting?
As for Pakistan’s “moral decay”… isn’t a bit late in the game for us to pretend that even worries us anymore? How cute of you to bring it up anyway.Recommend
So true hamna. the problem with our television media is that it doesnt follow up much on issues. nobody cares that the sialkot brothers’ family still awaits justice after 6 months of the incident, asia bibi and salman taseer are long forgotten. news becomes stale way too soon.Recommend
Good points, but if you live in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, you know ‘Islamic’ is more important. Asia bibi is a Christian. sad but true. You are allowed,in fact encouraged to blasphemy against other faiths, but it appears this is one way street. You can preach others to join Islam and by so doing state all the ‘bad’ things about their faiths, but a retort can shorten your life. Others can join Islam, but anybody leaving Islam should be killed. “Kill those who join other Gods”, I read
But thanks for writing about Asiua bibi and other future victims of intolerance. .I wish there are more like you. around.Recommend
all the media & the barbaric “mazhabi jamatain” have been crying about the terrorist afia for so long.Why no tears for asia?? she is just as much a pakistani as the religious terrorist afia.
Why doesn’t our media highlight the real “qaum ki betis” like sheryy rehman,asma jehangir,sheharbano taseer?? These women are the real ones doing a great service to this country.Recommend
Agree with you Hamna. Selective memory and short attention span are what has perpetually plagued our mushrooming media scene. This has actually become such a regular occurrence that it has conditioned us consumers of media accordingly. We are being fed sensationalism and the breaking news culture and most of us are gradually falling prey to it as well. It has hence become a vicious cycle where the media keeps supplying newer and newer, juicier stories and we keep demanding or thriving on them more and more. In the process we are losing sight of the bigger picture, as you rightly pointed out. What with the newfound obsession with the Arab and Middle East revolution we see valuable slots in important shows on TV that hold the keys to thought and opinion influence being dedicated to ‘Whether or not such revolutions will work in Pakistan’ What if this and what if that, completely ignoring the plights of the common man and the realities of everyday life in the country that remain unattended.
Efforts by the few voices of reason like yours to keep pertinent issues such as that of the blasphemy laws in the forefront until they are resolved are much needed. An issue that is more symbolic and less consequential in nature like the Raymond Davis case shouldnt have gotten this much mileage for sure. Recommend
I hope Aasia bibi finds justice, even if it is delayed, and the blood of Shaheed Taseer does not go in vain.
But please, enough damage has been done by the media’s positive attention to this topic which makes the religious right see red. Let’s be smart and realistic about it and let the topic rest in the media (for the time being). Let’s use silent means to pressurise/support the high court to overturn the verdict and release Aasia in appeal. Otherwise no judge will risk his/her neck by giving Aasia freedom. And even if s/he does, Aasia herself may not live long enough to gather her family, find asylum and leave this religious hellhole. Recommend
Because in Pakistan we have a lust for blood. We always want revenge and like to see people we don’t like suffer. In spite of having grown up with tales of the prophet’s (pbuh) forgiving and merciful nature we fail to apply it in daily life. We are in a constant frenzy being fed by the media. And instead of celebrating the many unsung heros amongst us we are too busy making heros of murderer and terrorists. Just goes to show how skewed our moral compass is. Shame on us!Recommend
Quite self-contradictory! On the one hand, you are so upset about Aasia bibi, and rightly so, but, on the other, least bothered about the three men murdered in cold blood (at least one of whom was undeniably innocent). And your supporters above want to vociferously root for any campaign that is against the “mullah”; otherwise, it’s all hunky dory. So Raymond Davis is a non-issue because he is not a “mullah”; who cares if he has killed two people and his saviors ran over another in trying to rescue him. O our liberals!! Recommend
Afia – Asia
left – rightRecommend